Forget F1: the only car race that matters now is the race to turn your car into a digital extraction machine, a high-speed inkjet printer on wheels, stealing your private data as it picks your pocket. Your car's digital infrastructure is a costly, dangerous nightmare - but for automakers in pursuit of postcapitalist utopia, it's a dream they can't give up on.
1/
If you'd like an essay-formatted version of this thread to read or share, here's a link to it on pluralistic.net, my surveillance-free, ad-free, tracker-free blog:
https://pluralistic.net/2023/07/24/rent-to-pwn/#kitt-is-a-demon
2/
Your car is *stuffed* full of microchips, a fact the world came to appreciate after the pandemic struck and auto production ground to a halt due to chip shortages. Of course, that wasn't the whole story: when the pandemic started, the automakers panicked and canceled their chip orders, only to immediately regret that decision and place new orders.
3/
But it was too late: semiconductor production had taken a serious body-blow, and when Big Car placed its new chip orders, it went to the back of a long, slow-moving line. It was a catastrophic bungle: microchips are so integral to car production that a car is basically a computer network on wheels that you stick your fragile human body into and pray.
4/
The car manufacturers got *so* desperate for chips that they started buying up *washing machines* for the microchips in them, extracting the chips and discarding the washing machines like some absurdo-dystopian cyberpunk walnut-shelling machine:
These digital systems are a huge problem for the car companies.
5/
They are the underlying cause of a precipitous decline in car quality. From touch-based digital door-locks to networked sensors and cameras, every digital system in your car is a source of endless repair nightmares, costly recalls and cybersecurity vulnerabilities:
What's more, drivers *hate* all the digital bullshit, from the janky touchscreens to the shitty, wildly insecure apps.
6/
Quality of new vehicles sold in the United States is declining as factors such as growing use of technology and lower build quality of certain parts are making the models more "problematic", according to automotive consultant J.D. Power.
Digital systems are drivers' most significant point of dissatisfaction with the automakers' products:
https://www.theverge.com/23801545/car-infotainment-customer-satisifaction-survey-jd-power
Even the automakers sorta-kinda admit that this is a problem.
7/
Back in 2020 when #Massachusetts was having a #RightToRepair ballot initiative, Big Car ran these *unfuckingbelievable* scare ads that basically said, "Your car spies on you so comprehensively that giving anyone else access to its systems will let murderers stalk you to your home and *kill you*:
https://pluralistic.net/2020/09/03/rip-david-graeber/#rolling-surveillance-platforms
8/
But even amid all the complaining about cars getting stuck in the #InternetOfShit, there's still not much discussion of *why* the car-makers are making their products less attractive, less reliable, less safe, and less resilient by stuffing them full of microchips. Are car execs just the latest generation of rubes who've been suckered by #SiliconValley bullshit and convinced that apps are a magic path to profitability?
9/
Nope. Car execs are sophisticated, and they're surfing capitalism's latest - and last - hot trend: dismantling capitalism itself.
Now, leftists have been predicting the death of capitalism since *The Communist Manifesto*, but even Marx and Engels warned us not to get too frisky: capitalism, they wrote, is endlessly creative, constantly reinventing itself, re-emerging from each crisis in a new form that is perfectly adapted to the post-crisis reality:
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/31/books/review/a-spectre-haunting-china-mieville.html
10/
But capitalism has finally run out of gas. In his forthcoming book, *Techno Feudalism: What Killed Capitalism*, #YanisVaroufakis proposes that capitalism has died - but it wasn't replaced by socialism. Rather, capitalism has given way to *#feudalism*:
https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/451795/technofeudalism-by-varoufakis-yanis/9781847927279
Under capitalism, capital is the prime mover. The people who own and mobilize capital - the capitalists - organize the economy and take the lion's share of its returns.
11/
Capitalism is dead. The #1 bestselling economist shows how the owners of big tech have become the world's feudal overlords. ‘What an amazing piece of work this is. Everyone should read it. 100 out of 100’ IRVINE WELSH In his boldest and most far-reaching book yet, world-famous economist Yanis Varoufakis argues that capitalism is dead and a new economic era has begun. Insane sums of money that were supposed to re-float our economies in the wake of the financial crisis and the pandemic have ended up supercharging big tech's hold over every aspect of the economy. Capitalism's twin pillars - markets and profit - have been replaced with big tech's platforms and rents. Meanwhile, with every click and scroll, we labour like serfs to increase its power. Welcome to technofeudalism. Drawing on stories from Greek Myth and pop culture, from Homer to Mad Men, Varoufakis explains this revolutionary transformation: how it enslaves our minds, how it rewrites the rules of global power and ultimately what it will take overthrow it. **A FINANCIAL TIMES BEST BOOK OF THE YEAR** ‘An epochal, once-in-a-millennium shift . . . this isn't just new technology. This is the world grappling with an entirely new economic system and therefore political power’ Carole Cadwalladr, Observer ‘With superb storytelling, Varoufakis shows how capitalism has eaten itself alive’ Brett Scott, author of Cloudmoney
But it wasn't always this way: for hundreds of years, European civilization was dominated by #rents, not #markets.
"Rents" are income you get from owning something other people need to produce value. Think of renting out a house: not only do you get paid when someone lives there, you also get the benefit of rising property values, which are the result of the work that all the other homeowners, business owners, and residents do to make the neighborhood more valuable.
12/
The first capitalists *hated* rent. They wanted to replace the "passive income" that landowners got from taxing their serfs' harvest with *active* income from enclosing those lands and grazing sheep in order to get wool to feed to the new textile mills. They wanted *active* income - and lots of it.
Capitalist philosophers railed against rent. The "free market" of #AdamSmith wasn't a market that was free from regulation - it was a market free from *rents*.
13/
The reason Smith railed against monopolists is because he (correctly) understood that once a monopoly emerged, it would become a chokepoint through which a rentier could cream off the profits he considered the capitalist's due:
https://locusmag.com/2021/03/cory-doctorow-free-markets/
Today, we live in a rentier's paradise. People don't aspire to create value - they aspire to capture it.
14/
In *Survival of the Richest*, Doug @Rushkoff calls this "#GoingMeta": don't provide a service, just figure out a way to interpose yourself between the provider and the customer:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/09/13/collapse-porn/#collapse-porn
Don't drive a cab, create #Uber and extract value from every driver and rider. Better still: don't found Uber, invest in Uber options and extract value from the people who invest in Uber.
15/
Even better, invest in *derivatives* of Uber options and extract value from people extracting value from people investing in Uber, who extract value from drivers and riders. Go meta.
This is your brain on the #FourHourWorkWeek, #PassiveIncome mind-virus. In *Techno Feudalism,* Varoufakis deftly describes how the new "#CloudCapital" has created a new generation of rentiers, and how they have become the richest, most powerful people in human history.
16/
Shopping at #Amazon is like visiting a bustling city center full of stores - but each of those stores' owners has to pay the majority of every sale to a feudal landlord, Emperor Jeff Bezos, who also decides which goods they can sell and where they must appear on the shelves. Amazon is full of capitalists, but it is not a capitalist enterprise. It's a feudal one:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/11/28/enshittification/#relentless-payola
17/
This is the reason that automakers are willing to #enshittify their products so comprehensively: they were one of the first industries to decouple rents from profits. Recall that the reason that Big Car needed billions in bailouts in 2008 is that they'd reinvented themselves as loan-sharks who incidentally made cars, lending money to car-buyers and then "securitizing" the loans so they could be traded in the capital markets.
18/
Even though this strategy brought the car companies to the brink of ruin, it paid off in the long run. The car makers got billions in public money, paid their execs massive bonuses, gave billions to shareholders in buybacks and dividends, smashed their unions, fucked their pensioned workers, and shipped jobs anywhere they could pollute and murder their workforce with impunity.
19/
Car companies are on the forefront of postcapitalism, and they understand that digital is the key to rent-extraction. Remember when #BMW announced that it was going to rent you the seatwarmer in your own fucking car?
https://pluralistic.net/2020/07/02/big-river/#beemers
Not to be outdone, #Mercedes announced that they were going to rent you your car's *accelerator pedal*, charging an extra $1200/year to unlock a fully functional acceleration curve:
20/
This is the urinary tract infection business model: without digitization, all your car's value flowed in a healthy stream. But once the car-makers add semiconductors, each one of those features comes out in a painful, burning dribble, with every button on that fakakta touchscreen wired directly into your credit-card.
But it's just for starters. Computers are *malleable*.
21/
The only computer we know how to make is the #TuringComplete #VonNeumannMachine, which can run every program we know how to write. Once they add networked computers to your car, the Car Lords can endlessly twiddle the knobs on the back end, finding new ways to extract value from you:
https://doctorow.medium.com/twiddler-1b5c9690cce6
22/
That means that your car can track your every movement, and sell your location data to *anyone* and *everyone*, from marketers to bounty-hunters looking to collect fees for tracking down people who travel out of state for abortions to cops to foreign spies:
Digitization supercharges financialization. It lets car-makers offer #subprime auto-loans to desperate, poor people and then killswitch their cars if they miss a payment:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4U2eDJnwz_s
23/
Subprime lending for cars would be a terrible business without computers, but digitization makes it a *great* source of feudal rents. Car dealers can originate loans to people with teaser rates that quickly blow up into payments the dealer knows their customer can't afford. Then they repo the car and sell it to another desperate person, and another, and another:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/07/27/boricua/#looking-for-the-joke-with-a-microscope
Digitization also opens up more exotic options.
24/
Some subprime cars have secondary control systems wired into their entertainment system: miss a payment and your car radio flips to full volume and bellows an unstoppable, unmutable stream of threats. Tesla does one better: your car will lock and immobilize itself, then blare its horn and back out of its parking spot when the repo man arrives:
25/
Digital feudalism hasn't stopped innovating - it's just stopped innovating *good* things. The digital device is an endless source of sadistic novelties, like the cellphones that disable your most-used app the first day you're late on a payment, then work their way down the other apps you rely on for every day you're late:
https://restofworld.org/2021/loans-that-hijack-your-phone-are-coming-to-india/
#Usurers have always relied on this kind of imaginative intimidation.
26/
The loan-shark's arm-breaker knows you're never going to get off the hook; his goal is in intimidating you into paying his boss *first*, liquidating your house and your kid's college fund and your wedding ring before you default and he throws you off a building.
Thanks to the malleability of computerized systems, digital arm-breakers have an endless array of options they can deploy to motivate you into paying them first, no matter what it costs you:
https://pluralistic.net/2021/04/02/innovation-unlocks-markets/#digital-arm-breakers
27/
Car-makers are trailblazers in imaginative rent-extraction. Take #VINLocking: this is the practice of adding cheap microchips to engine components that communicate with the car's overall network. After a new part is installed in your car, your car's computer does a complex cryptographic handshake with the part that requires an unlock code provided by an authorized technician. If the code isn't entered, the car refuses to use that part.
28/
VIN-locking has exploded in popularity. It's in your iPhone, preventing you from using refurb or third-party replacement parts:
https://doctorow.medium.com/apples-cement-overshoes-329856288d13
It's in fuckin' *ventilators*, which was a nightmare during lockdown as hospital techs nursed their precious ventilators along by swapping parts from dead systems into serviceable ones:
29/
And of course, it's in tractors, along with other forms of remote killswitch. Remember that feelgood story about #JohnDeere bricking the looted Ukrainian tractors whose snitch-chips showed they'd been relocated to Russia?
https://doctorow.medium.com/about-those-kill-switched-ukrainian-tractors-bc93f471b9c8
That wasn't a happy story - it was a cautionary tale.
30/
After all, John Deere now controls the majority of the world's agricultural future, and they've boobytrapped those ubiquitous tractors with killswitches that can be activated by anyone who hacks, takes over, or suborns Deere or its dealerships.
Control over repair isn't limited to gouging customers on parts and service. When a company gets to decide whether your device can be fixed, it can fuck you over in all *kinds* of ways.
31/
Back in 2019, Tim Apple told his shareholders to expect lower revenues because people were opting to fix their phones rather than replace them:
https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2019/01/letter-from-tim-cook-to-apple-investors/
By usurping your right to decide who fixes your phone, Apple gets to decide whether you can fix it, or whether you must replace it. Problem solved - and not just for Apple, but for car makers, tractor makers, ventilator makers and more.
32/
Apple leads on this, even ahead of Big Car, pioneering a "recycling" program that sees trade-in phones *shredded* so they can't possibly be diverted from an e-waste dump and mined for parts:
https://www.vice.com/en/article/yp73jw/apple-recycling-iphones-macbooks
John Deere isn't sleeping on this.
33/
They've come up with a valuable treasure they extract when they win the #RightToRepair: Deere singles out farmers who complain about its policies and refuses to repair their tractors, stranding them with six-figure, two-ton paperweight:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/05/31/dealers-choice/#be-a-shame-if-something-were-to-happen-to-it
34/
The repair wars are just a skirmish in a vast, invisible fight that's been waged for decades: the #WarOnGeneralPurposeComputing, where tech companies use the law to make it illegal for you to reconfigure your devices so they serve you, rather than their shareholders:
https://memex.craphound.com/2012/01/10/lockdown-the-coming-war-on-general-purpose-computing/
35/
The force behind this army is vast and grows larger every day. General purpose computers are antithetical to technofeudalism - all the rents extracted by technofeudalists would go away if others (tinkereres, co-ops, even capitalists!) were allowed to reconfigure our devices so they serve *us*.
36/
You've probably noticed the skirmishes with #inkjet #printer makers, who can only force you to buy their ink at 20,000% markups if they can stop you from deciding how your printer is configured:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/08/07/inky-wretches/#epson-salty
But we're also fighting against #InsulinPump makers, who want to turn people with #diabetes into walking inkjet printers:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/06/10/loopers/#hp-ification
37/
And companies that make powered wheelchairs:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/06/08/chair-ish/#r2r
These companies start with people who have the least agency and social power and wreck their lives, then work their way up the privilege gradient, coming for everyone else. It's called the #ShittyTechnologyAdoptionCurve:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/08/21/great-taylors-ghost/#solidarity-or-bust
38/
Technofeudalism is the public-private-partnership from hell, emerging from a combination of state and private action. On the one hand, bailing out bankers and big business (rather than workers) after the 2008 crash and the covid lockdown decoupled income from profits. Companies spent billions more than they earned were still wildly profitable, thanks to those public funds.
But there's also a policy dimension here.
39/
Some of those rentiers' billions were mobilized to both deconstruct antitrust law (allowing bigger and bigger companies and cartels) and to expand "#IP" law, turning "IP" into a toolsuite for controlling the conduct of a firm's competitors, critics and customers:
https://locusmag.com/2020/09/cory-doctorow-ip/
IP is key to understanding the rise of technofeudalism.
40/
The same malleability that allows companies to "twiddle" the knobs on their services and keep us on the hook as they reel us in would hypothetically allow us to *countertwiddle*, seizing the means of computation:
https://pluralistic.net/2023/04/12/algorithmic-wage-discrimination/#fishers-of-men
41/
The thing that stands between you and an alternative app store, an interoperable social media network that you can escape to while continuing to message the friends you left behind, or a car that anyone can fix or unlock features for is IP, not technology. Under capitalism, that technology would *already* exist, because capitalists have no loyalty to one another and view each other's margins as their own opportunities.
42/
But under technofeudalism, control comes from rents (owning things), not profits (selling things). The capitalist who wants to participate in your iPhone's "ecosystem" has to make apps and submit them to Apple, along with 30% of their lifetime revenues - they don't get to sell you jailbreaking kit that lets you choose their app store.
43/
Rent-seeking technology has a holy grail: control over "ring zero" - the ability to compel you to configure your computer to a feudalist's specifications, and to verify that you haven't altered your computer after it came into your possession:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/01/30/ring-minus-one/#drm-political-economy
For more than two decades, various would-be feudal lords and their court sorcerers have been pitching ways of doing this, of varying degrees of outlandishness.
44/
At core, here's what they envision: inside your computer, they will nest *another* computer, one that is designed to run a very simple set of programs, none of which can be altered once it leaves the factory. This computer - either a whole separate chip called a "#TrustedPlatformModule" or a region of your main processor called a #SecureEnclave - can tally observations about your computer: which operating system, modules and programs it's running.
45/
Then it can cryptographically "sign" these observations, proving that they were made by a secure chip and not by something you could have modified. Then you can send this signed "attestation" to someone else, who can use it to determine how your computer is configured and thus whether to trust it. This is called "#RemoteAttestation."
46/
There are some cool things you can do with remote attestation: for example, two strangers playing a networked video game together can use attestations to make sure neither is running any cheat modules. Or you could require your cloud computing provider to use attestations that they aren't stealing your data from the server you're renting.
47/
Or if you suspect that your computer has been infected with malware, you can connect to someone else and send them an attestation that they can use to figure out whether you should trust it.
48/
Today, there's a cool remote attestation technology called "#PrivacyPass" that replaces #CAPTCHAs by having you prove to your own device that you are a human. When a server wants to make sure you're a person, it sends a random number to your device, which signs that number along with its promise that it is acting on behalf of a human being, and sends it back. CAPTCHAs are all kinds of bad - bad for accessibility and privacy - and this is really great.
49/
@pluralistic yup
Certainly agree with all of that.
Years went past and no change but very expensive machines to save you colour matching the stick after a minute.
PowerPoints and growing numbers meant CHANGE!
I call it diabetic disneyland now
Gauge-a-betic. It’s really one of those things that so spikey and vile. #NormaliseThatGreed.
John Deere also links essential running components to nonessential components.
Hutterite colonies try to avoid modern things like music and the like. When I worked at a JD dealership, a Colony had all the radios removed from the new combines and tractors and they went in the Minister's safe. The workers bought 3rd party radios and tried to install them. Chaos ensued.
Removing the radios required a re-program of the machine along with a check and approval from JD. When the boys tried to install the 3rd party radios, the machines wouldn't start. They wouldn't even initialise the computer boot-up.
It was a month of diagnostics, back and forth with Deere and finally a workaround so that the equipment would run without the radio and sneakily run the 3rd party radios for the boys who weren't even supposed to have them in the first place.
@manopie @pluralistic we had a goot talk on this at Skytalks around 10 years ago. Sidragon (of planes flying sideways fame) and Jesse did a pretty good breakdown of JD's bullshit, as I recall.
We really should do a redux of that some day.
Cory Doctorow
zenith
TheManopie
infosec zathras
mrpommer