Happy Enshittification Day! šŸ’„

July 1, 2023: Reddit cuts off API access, Twitter requires login, Youtube may ban ad-blockers, Meta & Google block news in Canada...

A half-year since Cory Doctorow's seminal thesis on #enshittification, how corporate platforms die (https://pluralistic.net/2023/01/21/potemkin-ai/#hey-guys), and every corporate site seems hell bend on its own destruction.

Celebrate #EnshittificationDay by going to [instance address]/about, find the donations link, and make your contribution to open social media!

Pluralistic: Tiktok’s enshittification (21 Jan 2023) – Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow

@mastodonmigration Seems fitting that #EnshiitifictionDay land on the day that Reddit cuts off API access to all third-party apps, and that Elon crops users to reading 600 posts per day and suffers a site outage.

@tchambers @mastodonmigration

Very soon we're going to need another term for these sites. I don't think Social Media really applies at this point. Social Miasma?

@tchambers It couldn't be a coincidence... 🤷
@tchambers @mastodonmigration WAT!? Did Elmo really restrict the number of posts per day?
@mastodonmigration Ah, I finally know where that jargon came from!
@mastodonmigration I disagree Google is doing enshittification here. Other examples are platforms shittifying their projects after success, but Google here is responding to a new law (i.e. external event) here. FWIW I agree with Google that a link tax breaks how the internet should work and should not be celebrated and I think they did the right thing here (Meta is a little different because they tend to embed more copyrighted content whereas Google mostly just show a link with minimal embed).

@brothercheng @mastodonmigration
I think Google’s advertising monopoly has broken ā€œhow the internet should workā€

If that idealism ever worked beyond the back of a napkin

Especially when confronted by billions of dollars itching to be accumulated in post-1980s trickle-up economies

@brothercheng agreed. Google and Facebook are responding to an awful law that breaks the internet. It won’t last though - Canada will repeal the law just like Spain did to avoid tanking their news providers. Google and Facebook are evil, they just happen to be right about this issue.

@brothercheng
I agree that Google is only responding in an appropriate way to a very boneheaded piece of legislation in this case. More broadly though enshitification at Google is and has been in full swing for quite some time now. Meta, while they might take a bit more liberties than Google does, it doesn't make the law in question any less ridiculous nor Meta's response to it any less appropriate either.

@mastodonmigration

@mastodonmigration @pluralistic Cory we need your blessing for this
@pluralistic @Shine_McShine
šŸ’„ BOOM! šŸ’„
It's official!

@mastodonmigration @pluralistic @Shine_McShine

Calendar updated! I assume celebrations will consist of ripping out coax cables and exchanging public keys?

@mastodonmigration Every time a corporate platform dies, the standards-based, federated world will get a little bit stronger. Someday the network effect will kick in and federated will be the default - again. Email managed to get there early, #XMPP nearly achieved it too (and still can, if we finally stop using walled-garden messengers like WhatsApp or Signal). Let's make interoperability a hard requirement.
@jabberati Every time a corporate platform dies... an angel gets it's wings. šŸ‘¼

@jabberati @mastodonmigration

That phrase right there:

"Let's make interoperability a hard requirement"

Truth!

@mastodonmigration It’s actually amazing how prescient that essay was

@mastodonmigration
I like this. My thinking on the problem is that Musk, Google, FB et al think they’re air when they’re mostly chocolate cake.

Bad move by FB to dig in their heels with Canada though - Google seems to still want to negotiate. Canadians get pissed when people try to blackmail us (Meta), and we’re stubborn.

Wake up babe, new anti-holiday just dropped
@mastodonmigration I signed up for medium annual support for my insurance, Mastodon.uno and buy the admins a cup of coffee weekly.
@mastodonmigration looks like we are hitting end stage enshitification and I for one am really impressed at how quick it's come about!

@mastodonmigration

should be a worldwide extra holiday 😁

@mastodonmigration
personally Ii prefer "pinterestification".
@mastodonmigration I give eight bucks every month to my home instance kind.social, because to me, that is more valuable than some Badge of Dishonor that shows I am part of Elon's Musketeers.
@mastodonmigration Corpo Internet needs to why, and it deserves to, long due.
@mastodonmigration the ida that they were always #dotcons has been around for 20 years... So this hashtag is a little late ;)
@mastodonmigration @pluralistic How truly ironic that the links to Twitter, such as the on in this screen shot from https://pluralistic.net/2023/01/21/potemkin-ai/ , is now dead unless you’re logged in.
Pluralistic: Tiktok’s enshittification (21 Jan 2023) – Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow

@mastodonmigration wow, was the enshittification blog only this year? It feels like it's been around a lot longer.

@mastodonmigration

While I’m not happy with FB and googles decision, I don’t blame them for it.

The current government here in Canada is a joke.

@mastodonmigration Corporations suddenly decide seppuku is the best way to run the place
@mastodonmigration Social media sows the seeds of it's demise within itself. Decentralization, "don't be a hateful a-hole" community standards are hopeful signs on a more positive next gen
@mastodonmigration May this day be remembered. And hopefully other closed social platforms join Enshittification Day too! ^_^

@mastodonmigration Every time I read the words "#Mastodon #Migration" I think it's the name of some cool #reggae song by Thievery Corporation, ya mon.

I and I be done with the tweets
Bab-Elon man can't take da heat
Time to move on to da Mastodon
Irie future in da Mastadon

Mastadon Migration
It's a Mastadon Migration, mon
Shakin' up the nation, mon
It's the Mastadon Migration, ya!

@mastodonmigration TIL Google Reader shutdown anniversary day changed names to Enshitification Day. I'm down
@mastodonmigration How would you respond to Twitter users who are unwilling to migrate to Mastodon because Mastodon chose not to allow searching of post text (as opposed to hashtags)?
@GCarty80 @mastodonmigration That it's like loosing the taste of a sweet grape because it has seeds. True that they could swallow them or spit them (adapt), but each one chooses their choice for their reasons.

@mastodonmigration

From the point of view of the investors, #enshittification is not suicidal. It’s a cash out. It turns a long term track record of usefulness to consumers and suppliers into a short term grift. It’s the natural result of capitalist-backed internet properties.

#Enshittification is probably the most important phenomena @pluralistic has identified and articulated. Nobel Prize in Economics worthy, really.

The upside of course is the opposing market force of competition. When sites cash out, the window is short for the grifters, and new sites to serve the now-abandoned markets should spring up.

If they’re good enough for their consumers and suppliers, they’ll last until their own #enshittification processes conclude.

Easiest (and only?) way to avoid the cycle and be more-or-less permanently useful is ā€œdon’t be capitalist.ā€ You’ll still have other problems, but #enshittification isn’t one.

@internetarchive and #Mastodon appear to be operating this way, but are vulnerable to attack by capitalist interests. But they won’t go grifter - there’s nobody to collect a payoff.