a lot of these feats are just the authors not understanding how like... basic physics works lol

is there magic in 40k. like for space marines. literal magic. because that's what you'd need

like consistently shooting a coin at 3km is not just space marines being super cool and having good sensors

there's... a lot to unpack in that kind of thing

being gyrostabilized like... no lol

i see why the 40k nerds say the bolter is like an automatic grenade launcher

these book authors are wild lol they treat each bolter round like a grenade

not a mini-grenade

like an obscenely big grenade

i am not going to even discuss the chainsword because that thing makes no sense

in fairness fallout has rippers and chainsaws xD

nothing about the bolter makes sense

it is just a magic weapon

it's supposed to be super efficient gyrojet futuristic bolter but also it's damn heavy and a normal person can't lift it

😖

there is literally no reason the bolter should be heavy

you literally designed it to be all cool so it doesn't have to be

imagine if star wars was like "oh yeah also the lightsaber is super heavy. only the jedi can wield it by using the force to lift it"

it's that level of wtf

so what you're saying is i can also kill you by shooting the weak point at your armor's neck xD

/r/warhammer40k: "we hate this. space marines are invincible and never die"

/r/40klore: "here's all the times they died to kitchen knives and shit"

so a common theme of space marines getting murked is a buncha people just burying them under bodies

in other words, drop a tank on them then stab their exposed bits

depending on author one might decide the space marine can pinky flip the tank tho

apparently a chaos marine got killed by an elevator falling on him

literally had an elevator dropped on him lol

i think a lot of this is on gw being terrible at numbers
like if gw tells you 50,000 space marines is wiping the floor with billions you don't wanna hear a space marine got murked with a spear

anyway, given how resource intensive it is to train and outfit one single ass space marine, the 40k universe should have developed fancy ass missiles to just target space marines at this point

yes that missile cost ten million money

it still cost way less than that space marine did

it's particularly bonkers given the scale of the warhammer universe

that cost is a drop in the bucket, and space marines are a finite, very limited, commodity

just blow them the fuck up

space marines would never survive in 40k

"i can run through walls and face tank heavy machine guns"

*drops a fucking nuke on you*

lasguns are significantly weaker than even civilian laser pistols in fallout lore

yeah i'm pretty sure i am gonna one round vats that squad down now

also lasguns can recharge... from solar? the fuck how long would that take xD

shouldn't a telekinetic psyker just be able to squish a space marine's brain from inside their skull

i feel like i've watched astartes before

seems vaguely familiar

i think i figured it out

not only are 40k fans just fanatically horny about space marines, they also seem to be largely unaware of any other universe

also i felt like wargamers in general would have a better grasp of military logistics, but i am getting the feeling that the 40k base is actually really split between the wargaming, the collecting/painting, and the lore

there are some people who are just in it for the lore and don't play or own any minis

the problem is that this is a miserable return on resource investment in the 40k universe where this is scaled up tremendously

a few thousand space marines? tens of thousands?

in 40k lore there are quadrillions. a galactic ocean of randos with lasguns

if you want historical, real life precedent, special forces are wiped out or forced to retreat by conventional forces all the damned time

are you really gonna risk 20 space marines to tie up 100 orks?

1,000? 10,000?

it's pretty well-established that a whole host of things can grease space marines. using them like shock troops (as widely depicted in the lore and cinematics i have seen) is wildly irresponsible and likely ineffective

"we sent the space marines in and they KILLED EVERYONE"
if you wanna kill everyone you just level the place. stand off and use explosives. what the hell are you doing

space marines in 40k aren't shown to do any of the actually special things real life special forces do

their lore dictates that only they can do/use their Cool Guy shit and toys, so they can't even train a partisan force

sneak over here and plant a bomb

aren't they expert tacticians? you should be laying battle plans and setting the stage for how your overwhelming conventional forces secure victory

i'm being told the imperium of man might have extremely limited capability to actually manufacture weapons of war

standby for lore checking and rage

alright lol

so this is a whole new threat level

not only does my fallout character one round vats that squad of space marines, i am not reverse engineering all their toys with the aid of micro fusion energy sources

"this is fucking pointless. why was this in here"
- my character, taking apart a bolter and instantly making it 10x lighter while not taking away any functionality apart from the possibility of recoil management
it's possible i could theoretically take over a substantial portion of the 40k universe by spamming gen 1 synths with institute energy weapons

ALSO THIS MAKES ALL THE GENERIC ASS SPACE MARINES GAMES WORKSHOP SELLS EVEN WORSE

IF THESE SUITS OF ARMOR ARE LIKE THIRTY THOUSAND YEARS OLD THEY SHOULD HAVE BEEN REPAIRED WHO KNOWS HOW MANY TIMES AND TOTALLY CUSTOMIZED BY NOW

how are the tau not wiping the iom off the galactic map
everything i said about the space marines being a pointless waste of resources and being employed terribly multiply that by about 999999999999999999999999999999999999
one clever accountant with a spacefaring fleet could disable the entire imperium
me, loading up liberty prime with mini-nukes and tesla canons: "get in loser, we're going to kill space nazis"
i have swung almost completely 180 from "okay sure 40k would stomp most of fallout" straight into "no, wait, fallout would 9000% outproduce and outresearch you fucking losers"

so let's say a space marine's bolter jams

is he allowed to engage in a corrective procedure

would he even know how

rpg goal unlocked

*vibrates in escape velocity*

@worthlessbums uhhh

I mean, that's where 40k comes from.

The rogue trader rpg.

@DarkestKale look i just started reading wh lore like a week ago xD

@worthlessbums I think you'd be better overall reading White Dwarf rather than lore, so you get a feel of where the whole thing came from.

Cause the lore is a piece of shitmess, and it's causing you... misconceptions.

@DarkestKale i dunno what white dwarf is

@worthlessbums **runs hand across face**

BUMS

@worthlessbums BUMS IT IS PAST MY BED TIME AND YOU CAN'T PULL THIS SHIT ON ME NOW
@DarkestKale look man you can't accuse me of misconstruing 40k lore and then also tell me 40k lore is as bad as mtg lore xD

@worthlessbums My point is, 40k lore has had HUGE awful creep in some directions and rewrites and it's just...

Start at the start and get a proper feel for it.