There's lots of hype about the Fediverse, and I'm getting kind of leery.

Hype can be good, but it can also be bad.

There was hype for the Steam Deck. It was good.

There was hype for NFTs. It was bad.

Yes, I believe the Fediverse is the future of social media, as well as the web. But this is not a sprint, it's a marathon.

Lots of things need to be built. Projects require more funding. Design decisions need to be considered with empathy, not with "move fast and break things."

I'm thinking about hype because I'm seeing a lot of business-y types talking about the Fediverse.

A few months ago, I mentioned that investor types have the Fediverse on their radar. They're not actively dropping millions into Fediverse startups, but it's definitely on their radar.

Most of us have high and lofty ideals. But there's sharks who are eyeing the Fediverse and thinking, "Ah, another opportunity for disruption."

Keep that strongly in mind when the buzzwords start flowing.

Some folks might be thinking, "You're just being anti-business! How are Fediverse developers supposed to be paid?"

As it happens, I run a business. I build software. I very much talk about the need for developers to make a sustainable living.

And I've indeed talked about how to best monetize the Fediverse.

Here's where I say the quiet part out loud: the Fediverse is already being monetized.

Mastodon accepts donation. Masto.host charges for hosting. A few devs are hired for theming.

@atomicpoet yup, people make a living from email too, but it isn't just one honking great big email server that everyone has to use.
@alanbell @atomicpoet fediverse #MailChimp ! Hire us and we will post across all areas adjusting your message to server rules and deviating through micro federated hosting sites that will be blocked but we can bring up again.

@alanbell @atomicpoet
Or #outlook #gmail #apple like fediverse that blocks everything that is not the top 5 fedirated systems so you cannot self host like it is happening with #email and #xmpp

Is there a rule in the #fediverse that does not allow a server to grow past a certain size to avoid it taking over? E.g. what would happen if #elon_musk suddenly adds #twitter to the fediverse? Would it just suck up everybody else just out of convenience? And then proceed to block lesser known servers?

@amunizp @atomicpoet I don't see a massive problem with that, if birdsite implemented activitypub and federated, then sure, users might want to use that, but they would be free to leave
@amunizp @atomicpoet There are user benefits to big professional sites, like data controllers doing compliance with various regulations, I could see various brands running a mastodon server and trying to attract people to it.