Calls for major rebuild as more than 700 building faults uncovered at Tenby’s Ysgol Greenhill
School faces infrastructure crisis despite academic progress
A report to Pembrokeshire County Council’s Schools & Learning Overview and Scrutiny Committee this week warns that extensive building improvements — or even a completely new school — may be required at Ysgol Greenhill, Tenby.
The secondary school, which educates around 900 pupils, has been led by headteacher David Haynes since 2021. Under his leadership, the school was removed from special measures in 2024 following significant improvements in teaching and leadership.
But despite the academic turnaround, councillors are being told that the physical condition of the school is now a major concern.
Over 700 faults identified
An inspection by the Schools Scrutiny Panel in July found more than 700 building defects, ranging from structural issues to maintenance failures.
Emergency works began in May 2025, with a contract worth more than £0.5m awarded for urgent repairs. The council has said every effort is being made to minimise disruption to teaching and exams while the work continues.
Concerns raised by pupils and staff
During the panel visit, both staff and pupils highlighted the poor state of the premises, though acknowledged that construction work was underway at the time.
The report also noted:
- Welsh language provision remains limited, with pupils saying they would like to see it more integrated across lessons.
- Attendance continues to be a challenge post‑Covid, with the school working with its cluster to improve figures.
- Reading standards among incoming Year 7 pupils are a concern, with guided reading sessions and assessments being introduced to help pupils catch up.
Praise for leadership but call for long‑term plan
The panel praised Mr Haynes’ “strong leadership” and the school’s strengthened cluster partnerships, particularly with Narberth CP School on Welsh language development.
However, councillors are being advised to prioritise long‑term funding and strategic planning for the site, including the possibility of a new school build.
The report also recommends:
- Expanding partnerships beyond the current cluster
- Providing resources for bilingual signage and Welsh‑language enrichment
- Earlier reading assessments in primary schools to support transition
Background: urgent works already underway
According to Pembrokeshire County Council, urgent structural works began in May 2025 and are expected to continue into the new academic year. Parents were informed directly by the headteacher, with assurances that safety and learning continuity remain the priority.
Related stories from Swansea Bay News
£420m school plan for Blaenymaes and Portmead sparks row
Swansea Council approves plans for a new school, but governors at Portmead raise strong objections to amalgamation.
Carway Primary School to remain closed this September
Pupils moved to Gwynfryn School after structural safety concerns force the closure of Carway Community Primary.
Plans unveiled for new pre‑16 Vocational Centre in Port Talbot
Former Victorian school building could be transformed into a bilingual hub offering hands‑on training and career pathways.
More education news
Catch up on the latest school, college and university stories from across South West Wales.
#buildingDefect #education #GreenhillSchool #newSchool #PembrokeshireCouncil #reading #SchoolAttendance #SchoolsLearningOverviewAndScrutinyCommittee #specialMeasures #Tenby #WelshLanguage