Hugo 26: Dramatic Presentation Longggggg
Time to kick off some ballot picking! An easy category because I had seen all of these things long before the finalists were announced!
This is a great set of films, and you could split them up into sub-categories and say they were (arguably) the best of 2025:
- Best long-form TV show
- Best classic science fiction story remake
- Best animated kid-friendly film
- Best science fiction qua science fiction film
- Best horror film
- Best superhero film
I would also happily rewatch any of them. The question is how to rank them?
I’ll start at the bottom first and work my way up. I think I have a bottom three and a top three.
6. At the bottom: Frankenstein. Del Toro’s adaptation is a visually appealing version of the classic story with compelling acting from Oscar Isaac and Jacob Elordi. It captures the idea of the story as a nightmare. However, it wobbles between the psychological drama and a story with action sequences and visual effects.
5. Superman. A great version of Superman that gets at Clark Kent as the core of the character. I enjoy Gunn’s films, but we all know his tricks now, so while this is a good superhero film, there have been better ones and better ones by Gunn.
4: KPop Demon Hunters. Way better than you expect it to be. A colourful musical with hidden depths and interesting characters. Having said that, it is still the film that you expect it to be, just a really well-done version of that film.
This bottom trio all have something in common. In each case, you know in advance what kind of film these should be. Superman and KPop Demon Hunters rise above those expectations, but fundamentally commit to being a really good version of themselves. Frankenstein is more of a flawed version of something that maybe could have been better, which, on reflection, is surprisingly apt.
The top three are much harder to rank.
3. Mickey 17. This is an enjoyable remix of a whole bunch of science fiction ideas. Well made and with fun (often over the top) performances by talented people. If it won a Hugo that would be great.
2. Andor (Season 2). Here we have a contrast with my bottom trio. Everything about the premise of this show appears to be derivative. There are also many aspects of the show that you can list as obvious flaws (e.g. the plot jumps about and many characters are underdeveloped). The show doesn’t attempt to mimic its source material or follow the expected rules of a high-profile streaming series. The net effect is a show that feels more original and fresh despite it being the sequel to a prequel of a film that already has far too much derivative media. The only other recent example I can think of that does something similar was the 2023 animated series Pluto (https://camestrosfelapton.wordpress.com/2023/12/02/pluto-netflix/), which re-worked a classic Astro Boy storyline into something deeper.
Sinners. I regret that I missed this on the big screen. For me, this was close to being a perfect film. It integrates so much while telling a clear story with emotional depth. I can see an objection that it is horror rather than fantasy, but plenty of things can be both. More importantly, it has its own fantastical ideas that are explored beyond just “there are vampires”. The film overtly equates music with magic, and hence magic with culture and cultural heritage. The idea of music as a form of magic or the performance of magic as akin to performing music is not a new one in fantasy, but this is still an excellent depiction of the idea. It also addresses a very difficult set of concepts about the interaction of different cultural heritages, particularly between marginalised people. Is the interaction one of cooperation and mutual respect, or is it one of predatory exploitation and theft? Remarkably, the film makes a very interesting pairing with KPop Demon Hunters.Andor was hard to beat, but Sinners wins my top ranking for 2026.
#2025 #awards #film #movies #oscars