A mystery beyond words: sermon for Transfiguration Sunday, 19 February 2023
Both of our scripture readings are stories that happen on mountain tops, and involve mortals experiencing the glory of God. The first reading is Exodus 24:12-18. Moses has freed the people of Israel from slavery in Egypt, and is now leading them through the desert to the promised land. On the way, however, God has made a new covenant with them, based on the Ten Commandments. Now, to seal the covenant, Moses goes up the holy mountain, Mount Sinai, where God will give him the Ten Commandments on stone tablets.
The Gospel reading is Matthew 17:1-9. The apostle Peter has declared that Jesus is, indeed, ‘the Messiah, the Son of the Living God’. But Jesus has warned his disciples that he will suffer and die, and that they must ‘carry their cross’ and suffer, too, if they want to follow him. So the disciples are pretty confused, as Jesus takes just three of them up a mountain. The mountain, the clouds, the light and the voice from heaven is all very reminiscent of Moses’ experiences on Mount Sinai. And, indeed, Moses, together with the Hebrew prophet Elijah, appear in this story.
In the name of God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, Amen.
In the tale of what has become known as the ‘transfiguration’ of Jesus, the disciples get a glimpse of the glory of the God who has sent Jesus. Maybe we should just go through this story and how it might help us to see glimpses of God’s glory and wisdom.
The story begins with Jesus, Peter, James and John climbing ‘a high mountain’. It’s a bit odd that Jesus would take just three of his friends off at this point. For the disciple band is restless- it seems that their following Jesus will get them into trouble. He is not going to set Israel free, like a conventional politicians or guerrilla leader. In fact, he’s told them that he will suffer and die- and that suffering is ahead for them, too. Shouldn’t Jesus be staying with his, answering their questions and offering them comfort at this difficult time?
Well, we know from other parts if the Gospels that Jesus did sometime seek solitude. He needed time by himself, to pray and commune with his Father. So it’s not really surprising that he would take his closest confidants off on their own. There are Christians who claim that they are too busy to pray. But if Jesus needed to take time for God, why shouldn’t we need it as well? We can certainly experience God in everyday life. But worship and prayer are essential. We all need to make time for God.
It is no accident that they go up a mountain, for this strange tale is meant to remind us of Moses going up a mountain to receive the Law which governed the life of Israel- of which the Ten Commandments are at the basis. We are told that Moses climbed Mount Sinai, it was covered in cloud, and then
The dazzling light of the Lord’s presence came down on the mountain. To the Israelites the light looked like a fire burning on top of the mountain.
In the culture in which Jesus lived, light and clouds were to be expected when you experienced the presence of God. So it is in our Gospel reading: as his friends watch, something odd happens to Jesus:
As they looked on, a change came over Jesus: his face was shining like the sun, and his clothes were dazzling white.
When I read stories from the Bible, I always wonder ‘what really happened?’ For we know that the stories were handed down through a number of people, before they were written down.
But if you ask me about the ‘what really happened’ behind today’s Gospel story, I have to say I don’t have a clue. It’s all so very strange- man going shiny, clouds and light and so on- it’s very alien. But what I do think is this- something deeply moving and mysterious happened to the disciples on that mountain. Peter, James and John were what you might call the chief disciples. They would go on to take leading roles in the Jesus movement after his death and resurrection. This story must have come from them. And it was thought to be so important that, strange story that it is, Matthew, Mark and Luke included it in their Gospel books.
So the mountain, the light, the cloud- all is an attempt to put into human words something which is almost impossible to put into words.
Of all the arts, the only one I can claim to have much understanding of is music. I learned piano when I was young, and had good teachers. I know something about musical techniques, where I know almost nothing about, say, painting. I can look at a Rembrandt and be impressed without knowing what he did with the paint to do that, but I can listen to Beethoven and be impressed in a different way, because I know a wee bit of musical theory. But what I really like about music is that it doesn’t need show you anything, or tell you something, for it to work. A song, of course, has words; musical theatre or opera can be a feast for the eyes as well as the ear. But you can listen to just pure music on its own, and be moved by it. But why it moves you is ultimately impossible to put it into words.
But I like words, and I like to explain things, and so the mystery of music is a bit unsettling. And yet, in that respect, it’s a bit like my faith. I obviously do a lot of explaining about faith (it’s my job- and I’m doing it now). But isn’t there an element of faith which is just inexplicable? Don’t we all sometimes feel that we believe, because we just do? And isn’t God, ultimately, inexplicable?
Jeremy Taylor, who was an Anglican bishop in the era of Oliver Cromwell, once wrote
A religion without mystery must be a religion without God.
I used to think that everything could be explained, but as I get older, I realise that old bishop had a point. Take away the mystery of faith, and there is nothing left.
This Gospel story speaks of mystery. The greatest mystery of Christianity is how Jesus of Nazareth could be, somehow, also God. When we read of Jesus shining in this story, I think that was Peter, James and John trying to speak of something which they couldn’t really put into words.
Recently, someone said to me ‘The trouble with people in our culture is that they have not experienced Christ directly’. We talk a lot about feelings and experiences in our culture, but I think it is true that we seem to have lost the capacity to experience the divine. We are entertained to death, we have music and art and culture all around us at the touch of a button, but it seems to serve to cover up a gap in our culture. That gap is what we might once have described as the mystery of God.
As Jesus is bathed in light, it is as if the barriers between time and eternity are breached temporarily, for Jesus seems to be in conversation with two men who had lived centuries earlier- Moses, and the prophet Elijah. I think their appearance reminds us about something which is important to our understanding of worship.
I think our worship should be contemporary. I think it should reflect the world as it is today- in music, in prayer, in preaching. But the best worship always takes us back to the past. We read from the Bible, a set of ancient books. Our preaching is coloured by the theology of those who came before us. We often sing hymns written a long time ago. But if you take all that too far, you end up with what is called traditionalism. That’s when (in church or elsewhere) nothing new ever happens. As grumpy Scots might say, doing things ‘as it’s aye been’ (or we think it’s aye been!). Traditionalism is the fear that, if we deviate too much from what we did before, God and our ancestors might get angry with us!
But traditionalism is a dead religion, frozen in time, scared to move forward. Perhaps Peter, the disciple, was a bit prone to that. For when he sees Moses and Elijah talking to Jesus, he says a very strange thing: ‘Let’s make tents! One for you, Jesus, and one for Moses and one for Elijah!’
Deciding you want to make tents in the middle of a profound spiritual experience is very odd. But I think it is that Peter wanted to capture the moment, capture the situation, to have some physical manifestation of spiritual moment. But that’s to freeze a spiritual moment in time. Traditionalism is when you try to capture your spiritual ancestors and keep them frozen so you can come and see them when you feel like it. The Bible often speaks of ‘the living God’- God who is present, and at work, in the here and now. But traditionalist church is like a mausoleum- an empty monument to the past.
For Peter should have noticed that Jesus wasn’t worshipping Moses and Elijah- he was talking to them. For Jesus, his spiritual ancestors are living beings, visiting from the past, with whom it’s possible to have a conversation. And it’s a moment which quickly passes- Peter doesn’t get a chance to put up his tents. For these mysterious divine moments don’t last. The curtain is pulled back for just a moment, before the ancestors send us off to live our faith in our own way, in our own time. The Bible, the tradition of the church, our ancestors in the faith- they are there, not to solid block of marble weighing down on us, but sources of wisdom, conversation partners, witness to the mystery of God in the past which can help us live our faith in the contemporary world that we live in.
The light fades, a cloud comes across, and from the cloud, the voice of God-
This is my son, with whom I am well pleased- listen to him.
Perhaps these are the most important words in this story. The disciples have seen Jesus in literally a new light. It’s a glimpse of who Jesus really is. The light is the divine light- Jesus is man like no other. But it’s not enough to simply acknowledge in words that Jesus is the Son of God. More is required of us: ‘listen to him!’
Christians are required to listen to Christ, to let his words and actions shape the way we live. Jesus was a man of peace. He healed the sick. He had time for outcasts and foreigners. He teaches us to love our neighbours, and reminds us that our neighbours are not just people who are like us. He taught us to be forgiving. But do we listen to him?
There have been Christians who thought that slavery is acceptable. There are Christians who think that women should be second class citizens. There are Christians who believe that racism is approved by God. There are Christians who think it’s okay to treat people badly because of their sexuality. The leaders of the Russian Orthodox Church think that God wants Putin’s armies to destroy Ukraine.
This is my own dear Son, with whom I am pleased—listen to him!
But who’s listening? Am I listening? Are you listening?
The mystery of Christianity is that God became a human being and lived among us. In the first chapter of the Gospel of John, we read
The Word became a human being and, full of grace and truth, lived among us. We saw his glory, the glory which he received as the Father’s only Son.
Peter, James and John certainly saw the glory of Christ on the mountain that day. They are our spiritual ancestors, and if they walked and talked among us today, what might they say to us? I think they would remind us that we, too, can see the glory of God in Christ. And that if we listen to him, we might help other see that glory, too.
Ascription of Praise
To God be honour and eternal dominion! Amen.
1 Timothy 6.16 (GNB)Biblical references from the Good News Bible, unless otherwise stated
© 2023 Peter W Nimmo
Featured image: Transfiguration (Anonymous artist) Mural, San Francisco, USA. From from Art in the Christian Tradition, a project of the Vanderbilt Divinity Library, Nashville, TN. https://diglib.library.vanderbilt.edu/act-imagelink.pl?RC=58833
#Transfiguration








