Mastodawn

In the Q&A/ discussion the topics of #OpenReviews and #PostPublication review came up, as well as options on how to make #PeerReview work more visible.

Especially the latter could have had more room for me, as views were seemingly different (e.g.,
@hansonmark.bsky.social
?), but alas, time ran out!

An excellent impulse event, a great way to spend my lunch time!

Ross Mounce Aug 27, 2025

Wrote my first comment on a paper over at @PubPeer today: https://pubpeer.com/publications/E336CA398E25647EBF5620F2378D72

How did I do?

I don't doubt that I missed some errors in the paper - it's chock-a-block full of oddities!

#PeerReview #Postpublication

PubPeer - Designing Ecological Networks to Foster Regional Economic Su...

There are comments on PubPeer for publication: Designing Ecological Networks to Foster Regional Economic Sustainability: source identification in the Longdong Loess Plateau using self-organizing map and complex network theory (2025)

ndocist Oct 8, 2024

BishopBlog: Using PubPeer to screen editors
Utiliser @PubPeer pour surveiller les #editeurs #publishers #postpublication #peerreviewing
https://deevybee.blogspot.com/2024/09/using-pubpeer-to-screen-editors.html?m=1

Using PubPeer to screen editors

2023 was the year when academic publishers started to take seriously the threat that paper mills posed to their business. Their resear...

HighWire Press Sep 19, 2023

Meet our presenters for the HighWire's Best Practices Webinar.

@BorisBarbour is from @PubPeer, which is a nonprofit that aims to improve the quality of scientific research by providing a platform for the scholarly community to discuss about scientific research after publication. Boris will talk about ‘Post-publication peer review and the PubPeer website’.
Register for the webinar here: https://us06web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_JhLG9pnLR_ypeP-XyiIaDg

#PostPublication #PeerReview #CommunityEngagement #ScholarlyResearch #PubPeer

Welcome! You are invited to join a webinar: The Future of Peer Review: Diversification and Decentralization?. After registering, you will receive a confirmation email about joining the webinar.

"Scholarship is iterative; it builds on itself. Researchers conduct experiments based on the experiments that were conducted in the past, with the hope that the articles describing their experiments and conclusions will be cited by other researchers in the future. A research article can be seen as a conversation between scholars, and in the past, this conversation almost exclusively took place privately between colleagues, and then more officially as part of the anonymous peer review process. Today technology allows this conversation to take place in the open, in forums like preprint servers, or as part of reviewed preprint outputs and the conversation can be ongoing with post publication commenting. The reputation and the utility of peer review performed outside of the journal setting has improved and there are now multiple providers of what is sometimes called “community peer review” offering various services targeted at different parts of the scholarly communications ecosystem, from preprint to reviewed preprints to journal peer review to post-publication commenting. This Peer Review Week Webinar will examine different types of community and third-party peer review services, and examine how community peer review, including pre-submission and post acceptance review, fits into the future of peer review." Join us on 28 September 10 am – 11 am ET. Panelists include representatives from PREreview, eLife and PubPeer.

Zoom

Show thread

Matt Hodgkinson Feb 16, 2023

@ebrandom It's a post-publication peer review platform much like F1000 Research. Qeios make their money from authors paying to have their AI send out reviewer invites.

On PPPR: https://scholarlyassessmentreports.org/articles/10.29024/sar.26
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4472664/
#PeerReview #PostPublication #PPPR