@simon_brooke @BylinesEast

It looks like we both failed successfully.

I love these challenges as I always learn something.

My failure: 🚫 Use of LLMs can impact your cognition, though Longitudinal data is lacking and there is a performance increase at the time of use.

Your failure: 🚫 LLM can create an accurate and well sourced article (if you know how to use the model).
Further, if you accept the veracity of the article, you falsify your own premise (which was based on flawed data) /chefs kiss 😘

Thanks for playing.

#Ai #LLM #cognition #criticalreasoning #psychology #cognitivescience

https://claude.ai/public/artifacts/5d67ba34-d702-48bd-8b41-706fb8b2a9af

cognitive.md | Claude

New studies reveal AI chatbots boost grades but damage critical thinking by 68%. Learn the hidden cognitive costs and how to protect your thinking skills.

Claude

Basically every debate I have with a #Republican nowadays:

Republican: *makes outlandish, baseless claim*
Me: *explains how the claim is inaccurate using evidence*
Republican: *inserts whataboutism*
Me: *explains the whataboutism with more evidence*
Republican: *moves goalposts*
Me: *drills another ball of evidence through the uprights*
Republican: *ends conversation with a thought terminating cliche*

#Democrat #Debate #Republican #Politics #Democracy #FallaciousReasoning #CriticalReasoning

In "City as a Classroom", they describe an experiment comparing comprehension between a front-projected vs back-projected screens and found very similar results, that back projection triggers a fireplace-stare lull. McLuhan often cited this result in comparing television to cinema.
#medialiteracy #mcluhan #smartphones #criticalreasoning

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-05605-0

Reading on a smartphone affects sigh generation, brain activity, and comprehension - Scientific Reports

Electronic devices have become an indispensable part of our daily lives, while their negative aspects have been reported. One disadvantage is that reading comprehension is reduced when reading from an electronic device; the cause of this deficit in performance is unclear. In this study, we investigated the cause for comprehension decline when reading on a smartphone by simultaneously measuring respiration and brain activity during reading in 34 healthy individuals. We found that, compared to reading on a paper medium, reading on a smartphone elicits fewer sighs, promotes brain overactivity in the prefrontal cortex, and results in reduced comprehension. Furthermore, reading on a smartphone affected sigh frequency but not normal breathing, suggesting that normal breathing and sigh generation are mediated by pathways differentially influenced by the visual environment. A path analysis suggests that the interactive relationship between sigh inhibition and overactivity in the prefrontal cortex causes comprehension decline. These findings provide new insight into the respiration-mediated mechanisms of cognitive function.

Nature