Why are big Instances bad for the Fediverse?

It's quite simple:
bigger instance -> more moderation work -> need for bigger team -> harder to find consensus within the moderation team -> less strict moderation

Also:
bigger instance -> more different ideologies among userbase -> harder for other instances to decide to block that instance / or greater impact on federation if big instances are blocked

Additionally small instances can't easily block big instances, because doing so would impact their own userbase a lot and drive even more people to large instances.

So big instances mean a lot more work for smaller instances, because they have to deal with much more individual bad actors instead of just FediBlocking them in bulk.

All Fediverse softwares should have a 2k limit for monthly active users, so all instances automatically temporarily close registrations when that limit is reached.

#FediverseMeta #BigInstances #FediModeration #FediMods #FediBlockMeta

@yuki2501 I think that's a bad approach as this will only benefit #BigInstances and benefit #HostileTakeovers like those of #NSAbook:

Just like #eMail isn't #AllowListing-only!

This will basically make #SelfHosting impossible because neither will users manually request to have their instances be #allowed nor will admins bother to allow every small bona fide instance in.

mastodon.cloud has over 260.000 registered users

mstdn.jp has over 250.000 registered users, with over 85.000 of them "daily active users" (by their internal measurement)

#metaMasto #observation #UserStats #BigInstances