@donaldball
Defederating an instance is a major step. All follower relations are deleted. And rather permanently, especially if you don't keep a good register of why you defederated who, why and when. If you dont revise regularly your decisions, you won't even notice if things improve on the other side (volunteer moderation teams have sometimes a significant fluctuation).
So, of course, you are totally free to block an entire instance if you feel that the instance culture promotes harassment (or whatever else one does not want to interact with) and their mod team do not respond to reports.
However, suggesting to #fediblock an entire instance is a major step of escalation. As good practice in this cases, we would do good to provide receipts/screenshots and a reasoning. And especially if it is not an obvious nazi/CSAM cesspool, it would be nice to know if you tried to interact with the mods there before using the fediblock hashtag.
fediblock is (unfortunately) almost the only widely adopted communication channel between mods&admins, but the hashtag is frequently abused for personal feuds and low-quality jokes.
Thus, if you consider the issue to be serious, please invest your time to use this tool responsibly (if you can, I don't know your personal situation).
The following could make sense (depends on what you did already):
- report offensive posts of the instance, checking the box to forward the reports to the instance in question.
- browse through the local timeline of the instance to see whether this is a generalized problem (also you might find even worse actors). Take screenshots.
- if that doesn't work out, contact the admins/mods directly. Be polite, most are volunteers. And give them some time to respond.
- if the problem still persists, and you consider it so serious that the instance in question deserves to be ostracized completely, then you can still suggest a #fediblock. But in this case, you'll have receipts and if your case is strong, you make also the work for other mods/admins easier because then we can build on your research and need only to check it.
Again, depending on your personal situation, or if you are directly affected by bigotry and harassment, and in the really obvious cases there might be reasons to escalate quicker.
But keep in mind that when you write a fediblock post, several thousand of people will read it and then have to decide what to do with the information.
PD: I have absolutely no stake with the instance you are talking about. I just saw this fediblock suggestion and felt the need to weigh in.
#Moderation #FediModeration