We need a name for the property-protecting canon the Supreme Court used in Sackett, the recent Clean Water Act case, and I propose calling it the Sagebrush Canon.
The name is inspired, of course, by the Sagebrush Rebellion, which admittedly more involved public lands as opposed to public regulation of private lands. But the vibes line up.
1/3
Manufactured finality, preservation via denied summary-judgment motions, the standards for (and scope of) class-certification appeals, appealing after dismissals with leave to refile, a slew of new cert petitions, and much more.
“Crowdsourcing a question for #AppellateTwitter: in a party brief (not amicus) do you ever cite non-legal information (empirical data, economic theory, etc.) in support of your legal argument? If so, please indicate type of case (patent, civil rights, etc.) in the comments”
After an interlocutory order that appears to have precluded the plaintiff from prevailing, the plaintiff asked the district court to enter summary judgment against it. The Sixth Circuit held that this didn’t produce a final decision.
March's appellate-jurisdiction roundup is up. It features a court's skipping appellate-jurisdiction issues to address subject-matter jurisdiction, party status for discovery appeals, appealing §1447(e) remands, and much more.
#AppellateMastodon #AppellateTwitter
https://finaldecisions.org/the-month-in-federal-appellate-jurisdiction-march-2023
The #2dCir tackled a series of remand-appeal issues, including whether §1447(d)’s bar on appeals applies to §1447(e) remands and whether an appellate court can inquire into the true grounds for a remand.
#AppellateMastodon #AppellateTwitter
https://finaldecisions.org/appealing-§-1447e-remands-genuine-otherwise
The Second Circuit tackled a series of issues concerning remand appeals, including whether § 1447(d)’s bar on appeals applies to § 1447(e) remands and whether an appellate court can inquire into the true grounds for a remand.
The #DCCir held that someone challenging a discovery order directed to someone else must first obtain some sort of party status before appealing.
#AppellateMastodon #AppellateTwitter
https://finaldecisions.org/third-parties-party-status-for-discovery-appeals
from @jodyssanders:
> Texas parents, the Texas Supreme Court just approved a form to use to initiate an action to obtain an injunction to stop cyberbullying. See the attached link: https://www.txcourts.gov/media/1455991/239014.pdf