A dataset without a code book: ethnography and open science

This paper reflects upon calls for “open data” in ethnography, drawing on our experiences doing research on sexual violence. The core claim of this paper is not that open data is undesirable; it is that there is a lot we must know before we presume its benefits apply to ethnographic research. The epistemic and ontological foundation of open data is grounded in a logic that is not always consistent with that of ethnographic practice. We begin by identifying three logics of open data—epistemic, political-economic, and regulatory—which each address a perceived problem with knowledge production and point to open science as the solution. We then evaluate these logics in the context of the practice of ethnographic research. Claims that open data would improve data quality are, in our assessment, potentially reversed: in our own ethnographic work, open data practices would likely have compromised our data quality. And protecting subject identities would have meant creating accessible data that would not allow for replication. For ethnographic work, open data would be like having the data set without the codebook. Before we adopt open data to improve the quality of science, we need to answer a series of questions about what open data does to data quality. Rather than blindly make a normative commitment to a principle, we need empirical work on the impact of such practices – work which must be done with respect to the different epistemic cultures’ modes of inquiry. Ethnographers, a...

Zuckerman v. Meta Platforms, Inc.

Buy Items

EU AI Act will fail commitment to ban biometric mass surveillance (Deutsche Version unten) - Reclaim Your Face

On 8 December 2023, EU lawmakers celebrated reaching a deal on the long-awaited Artificial Intelligence (AI) Act. Lead Parliamentarians reassured their colleagues that they had preserved strong protections for human rights, including ruling out biometric mass surveillance (BMS). Yet despite the lawmakers’ bravado, the AI Act will not ban the vast majority of dangerous BMS […]

EU targets music streaming platforms to ensure fair pay and visibility

Parliament members in the EU are trying to introduce music streaming laws that promote diversity and ensure underpaid artists are being fairly compensated.

How to deal with visual misinformation circulating in the Israel-Hamas war and other conflicts

A human rights scholar explains how social media users can take charge of what content comes into their feed and reduce the risk of receiving misinformation.

Web Security Lead job posting

Open position for a Web Security Lead, for full-time remote work, to lead our Web security standardization efforts.

How do I disable the "home" button on a game controller in macOS?

My 8bitdo SN30 has a "home" button on the lower right hand side. I only ever hit this button by accident when gaming on my mac, and it opens some weird sub-folder of the never-used Launch...

ChatGPT and its magical metaphors - Making Science Public

Last week, a new issue of Technoscienza, an Italian journal of Science and Technology Studies, landed in my inbox. It had a very intriguing cover, co-created between Sergio Minniti and ChatGPT — a portrait drawn by ChatGPT using ASCII. But that was the least of it. After Sergio had prompted ChatGPT to create this stunning ...