So, today I was called a "Luddite" because I don't like AI.

Call me what you want, but when it comes to folks losing their jobs, data centers sucking up our water and causing higher energy bills for people already struggling, LLMs being trained on stolen data, and so many other ethical issues, I won't budge or back down on how I feel.

I will proudly accept the Luddite label. I've been around for nearly 60 years and have had a pretty shitty go of it the past 5 or so years. You can't hurt my feelings.

#noai #fuckai
@cmccullough I guess I am a Luddite as well. At least I'm in good company!
@cmccullough Funny how often insults say more about the insulter than about the insultee.

@cmccullough

Considering that the Luddites were all about maintaining a standard quality of work and being paid a fair share of the organization in which they were a part, something which capitalistic automation threatened on various levels, I daresay it's no insult, no insult at all.

The use of 'luddite' as a pejorative is a capitalist fiction.

@theogrin @cmccullough yes!

i think more and more people are realizing that what we were taught about the luddites was pure capitalist propaganda. i could see "luddite" being reclaimed for anti-tech oligarchy use
@cmccullough Solidarity. I'd take that Luddite label too, knowing I'm on the right side of history.

@cmccullough
Wear the title with pride. Remember, the Luddites were against technology exploiting people, and maintaining their quality of life and work environment as a primary movement. Followed by anti-surveillance via technology, and rights to repair.

I say this as a person who grew up with Mennonites and Amish.

@cmccullough I’m a Luddite, you’re a Luddite, we are all Luddite except those who are Capitalists or aspire that direction.
@cmccullough The Luddites were actually way cool. You should definitely be proud of being called one.

@cmccullough Short version: the Luddites were labour activists who spent TEN YEARS trying to get justice, and when they couldn't, they started busting the machines that were ruining their lives. They were BAD. ASS.

Skim:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite

Deep dive:

https://www.bloodinthemachine.com/p/understanding-the-luddites-in-the

#luddites #AI

Luddite - Wikipedia

@cmccullough Also, broader context (and this one's a comic book):

https://thenib.com/im-a-luddite/

I’m a Luddite (and So Can You!) | The Nib

What the Luddites can teach us about resisting an automated future.

The Nib
@OrionKidder @cmccullough Blood in the Machine is a great book, I recommend everyone read it. I'd even go as far to say that if you enjoyed it, and if you have the spare cash, to buy a copy too.
@aaron Thanks for the recommendation.

@OrionKidder
@cmccullough being the kind of person who would so totally sabotage a data center so that people can have fresh water to drink is heroic
@cmccullough I'm proud to be a Luddite, someone who fights against technology used for exploitation. It's a complement.
@cmccullough Luddites were good actually. We need Luddites now.
@cmccullough I just posted a few min ago about how today I downloaded the DuckDuckGo browser to avoid feeding the AI monster.
@cmccullough Fellow Luddite here ... you are not alone!
@cmccullough Luddites are bad, and if you are one you should seriously reconsider your position because it is distinctly bad.
@Newhereish @cmccullough You seem to be new here, so I will help you out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite
Luddite - Wikipedia

@cmccullough That's actually a pretty solid description of what Luddites were.

They broke machines that were being used to devalue their professions and force them into becoming lower waged labourers.

@cmccullough +9001%

Fuck the genocidal #AIbros, they are a net negative to this world!

- We all should #MoveSlowAndBuildThings instead of #MoveFastAndBreakThings!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W1dIC287Zz0

Tech Billionaires Want Us Dead

YouTube

@cmccullough @nifta “it would be a shame if those GPUs were to overheat.” is the sort of thing a modern #Luddite might be heard to mutter from time to time.

#Sangamon from #Zodiac would have #MonkeyWrenching ideas.

@cmccullough
🎶 Call me a Luddite, call me what you will
Say I'm old fashioned, say I'm over the hill
So-called "AI" hasn't got the same soul
I prefer the old-fashioned results of human toil
@cmccullough  from a fellow luddite.

@cmccullough

Clearly what ever genius called you a Luddite knows nothing about the actual history and purpose of that movement.

@cmccullough Luddites we good actually. They weren’t against machines, but the destruction of social structure that the corrupt men wielding them brought. What we’ve been told about them is propaganda.
@cmccullough Being left behind is good. Behind has cake!

@cmccullough One thing about the current wave of Luddite epithets is that they're prompting people to learn the real labour history of the Luddite movement.

I've boiled it down to this: The Luddites were *expert* loom-users who only smashed the equipment of loom-owners who didn't engage in fair dealing.

@cmccullough “As the Liberty lads o'er the sea
Bought their freedom, and cheaply, with blood
So we, boys, we
Will die fighting, or live free,
And down with all kings but King Ludd”
― Lord Byron

#ButlerianJihadNow

@cmccullough

Eli make them, Eli break them, up the Luddites.

@cmccullough

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJ8_PnlEdBc

I'll drink to the memory of General Ludd

Seize The Day "Ned Ludd"

YouTube
@cmccullough You're not a luddite if you don't like a technology that's not fit for purpose. That's just being sensible.

@cmccullough Luddites understood technology and its social and political implications better than most.

Wear the label with pride.

@cmccullough

The Luddites were right - and whatever one things of their tactics, all peaceful routes had been closed off and the owners used violence against them. They couldn't vote, the judiciary and the press were broadly in the hands of those who owned the mills... union activity was illegal -

@cmccullough
Certainly you are not luddite, they had pretty clear that technology isn't the problem but who and how uses it. In fact the stupid idea that the technology itself is to blame is widespread by corporate lords.
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/what-the-luddites-really-fought-against-264412/
What the Luddites Really Fought Against

The label now has many meanings, but when the group protested 200 years ago, technology wasn't really the enemy

Smithsonian Magazine
@cmccullough @lisamelton “Luddite” in this case may be true to the original usage of it! A lot of people use that term while only guessing at its meaning, from the context of others using it half-wrong also.