I almost stopped watching the first episode of Paradise because what was happening isn't at all how things would go in such a scenario.
Watching through to the end paid off as all of the little things I noticed from the first 10 minutes or so that were off and odd were shown to be just so, and presumably the underlying plot of the series.
A unique premise that can go either way, brilliant or terrible; I don't think it can land in the middle.
*I lived off Rhode Island Ave.