Alex Pretti’s ICE murder is beyond politics. This is about good vs. evil

Trump's inhumane immigration raids and two ICE murders has triggered an American yearning for a return to morality.

The Philadelphia Inquirer

Robert F. Worth
Robert F. Worth describes what caused Minneapolis documentary filmmaker Chad Knutson, who wasn't previously an activist, to join the protests:

"On the morning after Good was killed, [documentary filmmaker Chad Knutson] was at home with his two hound dogs, watching a live feed from the Whipple Building, where ICE is based, a five-minute drive from his house."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #fascism #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/2

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/2026/01/minneapolis-uprising/685755/?gift=8DuZT5mBYqmK1I4zfwIFq_jo6b7DrQ-VCEmjDqkdw74&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share

The Minneapolis Uprising

In the frozen streets of Minneapolis, something profound is happening.

The Atlantic

"A protester had laid a rose on a makeshift memorial to Good. As Knutson watched, an ICE agent took the rose, put it in his lapel, and then mockingly gave it to a female ICE agent. They both laughed.

Knutson told me he had never been a protester. It seemed pointless, or just a way for people to expiate their sense of guilt. But when he saw those ICE agents laughing, something broke inside him."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #fascism #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/3

"One of the striking developments about the extremism of Trumpian violence, lying, and abuse of power is its recruitment power – but for the opposition. A lot of mild-mannered moderates are now ferociously against ICE, the attack on immigrants, and in some cases the whole Trump Administration."

Rebecca Solnit

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #fascism #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/4

https://www.meditationsinanemergency.com/this-cold-winter-love-is-a-superpower/?ref=meditations-in-an-emergency-newsletter

This Cold Winter, Love Is a Superpower

There are great days and terrible days in history, days a nation or world changed, that you remember forever. For me that's the fall of the Berlin Wall, the rise of the Zapatistas, 9/11, Hurricane Katrina, the days of Occupy and BLM, and it's Friday in Minneapolis, when the

Meditations in an Emergency

:Pretti was holding a phone, filming masked men who were terrorizing people on his city’s streets. We know this because other courageous neighbors were doing the same thing. One of them captured the celebratory clapping of agents that began as the ten shots that killed Pretti were still being fired."

~ William J. Barber II and Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #fascism #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/5

https://ourmoralmoment.substack.com/p/a-man-was-lynched-yesterday

A Man Was Lynched Yesterday

Alex Pretti was killed by people who celebrated his death. They do not need better training. They demand a moral movement to disarm them and reconstruct democracy.

Our Moral Moment w/ Bishop William Barber & Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove

"Ross leaned into the car to shoot [Renee Good] at close range through the windshield, not something you would do if you thought a car was about to run you over. He then shot her twice more through the side window as the car rolled by in front of him, one of those shots being fatal."

~ Paul Krugman

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #fascism #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/6

https://paulkrugman.substack.com/p/was-this-a-murder-too-far

Was This a Murder Too Far?

The execution of Alex Pretti has made even some MAGA loyalists waver

Paul Krugman

"The MAGA faithful closed ranks, echoing the party line that she was a militant terrorist, albeit one with a dog in the back of the car, who smiled and said soothing words to her killer. ...

But this time, after the killing of Alex Pretti, feels different. Media coverage has been much clearer than the coverage after Good’s death."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #fascism #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/7

"As I was writing this, the Wall Street Journal headline read 'Videos Contradict U.S. Account of Minneapolis Shooting'. After some initial equivocation, the New York Times is calling out administration lies and featuring a chilling moment-by-moment analysis of videos showing what really happened. ...

I think that this time is different, for several reasons."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #fascism #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/8

"First, views of the Pretti murder aren’t distorted by misogyny and anti-LGBTQ bigotry. I believe that a significant number of people brushed aside the murder of Renee Good because she was a woman — at a time when right-wingers are still dismissing opponents of fascism as 'gangs of wine moms' — in a same-sex relationship."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #fascism #Trump #Minnesota #evil #misogyny #homophobia
/9

"Second, while the video evidence on Good’s killing was clear if examined closely, it did need close examination to reveal that she was simply murdered. The videos of Pretti’s killing don’t need close examination. That sound you heard Saturday was millions of Americans, myself included, crying out in horror as we watched agents repeatedly shoot a man who was already restrained."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #fascism #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/10

"And the contrast between the damning videos and the blatant lies from Kristi Noem, Stephen Miller and Gregory Bovino was too much even for many people who were still, for some reason, inclined to trust this administration. ...

Finally, it matters that this was the second broad-daylight murder, and that it came after weeks of horror stories about kidnapped children, citizens pepper-sprayed in the face, and more."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/11

"I already knew, and most readers of this newsletter probably also knew, that the people besieging Minneapolis were lying, brutal thugs. But most Americans don’t follow the news closely and tended until recently to give the government the benefit of the doubt.

The murder of Alex Pretti may be a tipping point...."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/12

"While both killings sickened and horrified many Americans, the killing of Alex Pretti is evoking a far stronger reaction than the killing of Renee Good."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/13

And as Oliver Kornetzke reminds us, while there's been strong reaction and even revulsion at the murders of these two white protestors, Good and Pretti, they are far from the only people killed by the regime pursuing immigrants and those in solidarity with them.

Kornetzke offers photos of the people of color who have met the same fate and whose murders have elicited less response.

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/14

https://substack.com/home/post/p-185750068

No More Denial.

What I want to say is not meant in any way to diminish the senseless loss of life of Renee Good and Alex Pretti.

"Pretti was trying to help a woman whom federal agents shoved violently to the ground. A fellow ICE observer, the woman flew a few feet through the air and landed hard; it had to hurt. 'Are you OK?' Pretti asked her, according to bystanders. Those were his last known words."

~ Joan Walsh

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/15

https://www.thenation.com/article/society/alex-pretti-nurse-neighbor-friend/

Alex Pretti Was a Good Man at a Time of Great Evil

The 37-year-old ICU nurse was killed helping another ICE victim. We must honor his sacrifice.

The Nation

"We know the fascists don’t want white people standing up for immigrants and other people of color, who are the main victims of Operation Metro Surge (and all the other perversely named federal invasions, including Maine’s revolting 'Catch of the Day,' as though immigrants are fish to be caught and killed.) And apparently, they don’t want men coming to the aid of the women they assault."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/16

"But it was not lost on Pretti’s devastated parents that he died 'while trying to protect the woman ICE just pushed down all while being pepper-sprayed,' they said in a statement. They wanted us to know that fact. 'Please get the truth out about our son,' they added. 'He was a good man.'

Alex Pretti was a good man at a time when very bad men are running our country."

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/17

"One of the images that continues to haunt me is the federal agent clapping in the split second after the execution of Alex Pretti at point-blank range. What kind of monster watches a man murdered with at least 10 bullets, then applauds? Not a shake of the head, not a moment of gravity about the taking of a human life, but clapping."

~ Steven Beschloss

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/18

https://www.americaamerica.news/p/snapshot-monsters-in-our-midst

Snapshot: Monsters in Our Midst

They are not just indifferent to a deadly shooting, they revel in it. But their terror is triggering a rising tide of anger and resistance.

America, America

"A doctor who said they tried to attend to protester Alex Pretti after he was shot in Minneapolis has said that federal agents were not attempting to give the 37-year-old medical assistance and were instead counting the bullet holes in his body."

~ Mike Bedigan

#ReneeGood #AlexPretti #murder #execution #violence #Trump #Minnesota #evil
/19

https://www.the-independent.com/news/world/americas/us-politics/alex-pretti-minneapolis-shooting-doctor-bullet-holes-b2907313.html

Doctor who attended to shot protester says agents were counting bullet holes rather than administering CPR

‘I asked the ICE agents if the victim had a pulse, and they said they did not know,’ the doctor wrote in a sworn declaration

The Independent
@wdlindsy - I'm convinced they counted the bullet holes because they have a scoreboard at the hotel.
@wdlindsy when we bring the perpetrators of this to trial, the name of the Maine operation will be evidence.
@wdlindsy There is the whole cumulative effect.
For many, it's not just "oh, this was a white guy" (we've been thoroughly trained that when they say somebody was threatening, they were! Esp. but not exclusively if it was Certain Demographics.
But this is making people question the earlier claims. This is (I HOPE HOPE HOPE) creating literal disillusionment. True actually wiping away of false views..
We still need to find a way to stifle the propaganda hoses, though... I'm afraid it would be asking too much for the disillusionment to go that far :( :(

@geonz @wdlindsy
I overheard a right wing radio personality, on the radio of another truck at work today, describing a scene in some store of a crowd of anti ICE protesters, surging forward, and knocking over a refrigerator "in their RAGE to get at officers!"

I believe that description is entirely bullshit, designed to paint protesters as terrorists.

America is full of guns. If there were REAL leftist terrorists dozens of 'officers' would have been shot with long rifles from blocks away.

@geonz @wdlindsy

Positively selecting for cosplaying 3%ers, who believe they will be on "the Right side of the next American Revolution" and hiring them into ICE for ideological reasons filled that agency with the dumbest and most paranoid 20% of America.

And that is the type of people they have been chosing to hire for 8+ years, based on the experience level of the people who have shot other human beings.

Wholly unqualified to evaluate threats. Bring back IQ tests or psych evaluations.

@Urban_Hermit @wdlindsy ... bring that stuff bakc while we figure out how to dismantle that whole flogging culture.
@Urban_Hermit
The whole thing has to be dismantled.
@geonz @wdlindsy
@Urban_Hermit @wdlindsy It is important for us to understand just how they are getting their heads and weapons in this place.
@wdlindsy I realize that there are probably many reasons for this, but that the more sympathetic one for many people is the white man with the gun rather than the mom with a same sex partner speaks volumes about how far we have to go.
@bbelton @wdlindsy It could easily be that his killing occurred so close on the heels of hers. This honestly doesn’t need to be about sexism, when shock, anger, horror, and disbelief are all right here.
@wdlindsy Now that ICE has killed a white guy with a gun, the white guys with guns have discovered empathy.

@wdlindsy

"They did not believe.

Until the soil was a stain of blood.

And the ground a flood of tears."
SearingTruth

@wdlindsy My jaw drops; 10 shots! This isn't even war. This is a psychotic rampage.
How can they win when ICE struggles to recruit and anti-fascists have no issue with recruitment?

@wdlindsy

"That we are not together.

That is the greatest lie ever told."
SearingTruth