As a retired teacher, I can tell you that this is an automatic A.
As a retired teacher, I can tell you that this is an automatic A.
Brilliant kid. It took me some time to see the mistake.
@MissPixiePancake @alice That question has the same energy as the SNL workout mirror sketch and "Who is Shannon Delgado?".
@MissPixiePancake Question 3 also deserves a failing grade for the test setter.
There are (present tense) 8 fish in the pond. 7 fish swam (past tense) away. How many are (present tense) left in the pond?
The question presumably wants the result given, 8 - 7 = 1, but the answer to the question as actually asked is 8.
If you want the test taker to do arithmetic you'd have to ask how many fish were (past tense) in the pond *before* the 7 swam away - answer being 8 + 7 = 15.
@MissPixiePancake
I say this with a recognition that it's really hard to set exam questions. My mom taught, and would go over her test questions looking for ambiguity, then get me to look over them for ambiguity and I'd usually catch something.
Then she'd get the tests back and somewhere a student had understood a question differently from how she'd intended it - but it was a legit misunderstanding - so she marked the answer they gave to their understanding of the question, not what she meant
This answer would have so been me!!!
That is excellent reading comprehension.
Also ... Fish can't swim away of a pond.
Oh god, you are right, I always translated a pond to "une marre" in french who doesn't have a river and never to "un étang" who has a river.
And ... It's the same word in English, it change so many landscape description that I read in books and stuff ...
What a nightmare.
@the_moep that sort of thing has become pervasive.. "just guess what they meant"
me: NO! Communicate back and get it clarified instead of assuming.
many people are too uncomfortable with things being undecided, even at the price of assigning incorrect values.
There ARE 8 fish in the pond.
7 fish SWAM away.
How many fish are left in the pond?!
This is a crazy question.
The only good answer is 8. Because there ARE 8 fish in the pond. After swam away.
And yes, who is Susan? 💖
Halal Susan my beloved
Fish left with Susan...
Desperately seeking Susan...
Haha! 🎯
@MissPixiePancake @billgoats I had a High School teacher who did that as an intentional gotcha. Everyone who did the sensible thing and assumed that was a typo and Susan was Jane got marked down because "you didn't spot that it's unsolveable".
Teaching kids to be nitpicky assholes ...
@MissPixiePancake "This question is nonsensical¹⁾, so the answer is 'Mu (無)', but Jane is suppositly singing songs by Whitney Houston²⁾ or The Ting Tings³⁾" <- Philosophers can't even answer grade school questions …
-----
1) In the sense of Wittgenstein's Tractatus 4.003.
Are the branches on the same tree?
Is there another pond next to the original that the fish jumped into?