If we in the #USA manage to get our country back from the current #dictatorship, and we still think government is a good idea (I'm not trying to resolve the question of #anarchism right now), we need to recognize first of all that we can't go back to the prior status quo. Certain core aspects of that system got us into this mess, and will require fundamental change.

(1) Our #voting system needs overhaul. The right to vote needs to be recognized explicitly as a RIGHT, not a privilege for each state to regulate largely as it pleases. In particular, no criminal conviction should ever be able to impair the right to vote; racist abuse of the criminal law has been used to accomplish widespread disenfranchisement of minorities. Also, we need to recognize that winner-take-all voting systems are utterly incompatible with genuine democracy. If you ever have to ask whether you can afford to vote for who you really want, as opposed to voting for the lesser evil, you do not live in a democracy. Something like proportional representation, ranked-choice voting, or instant-runoff voting is not a luxury; some such system is a minimum requirement for authentic democracy.

(2) To hell with "#SeparationOfPowers". Any protection it supposedly offered us has been purely illusory. Indeed, it was never intended to safeguard the people. It was designed by an elite who deeply distrusted the people, in order to safeguard their wealth and power FROM the people. A legislature answerable to the people is the best safeguard for their rights that any government can hope to offer. Autonomy for the judicial and executive functions of government, as separate "branches" outside the control of the legislature, has brought nothing good. Throughout most of its history, an autonomous Supreme Court has consistently defended the most depraved policies of private power against legislative efforts to control them; and now it has aided and abetted the autonomous Presidency in fulfilling its inherent tendency to degenerate into a #dictatorship. Put the courts and all executive functions under full legislative control, to be granted only such limited and conditional autonomy as the legislature sees fit to offer them.

(3) We will need to overhaul our understanding of what the right of #FreeSpeech consists in. I do not like the unclear slogan "money is not speech"; but the right of INDIVIDUALS to speak freely is what must be safeguarded, and if that is to be accomplished, we cannot allow private capital to monopolize control over the media of communication, much less recognize an inviolable right for private capital to buy such control. Also, we may need to place severe restrictions — as #Germany has done — on organized promotion of certain ideas that involve a systematic attempt to suppress the very existence, let alone the free expression, of others. A #fascist march has more in common with a brandished weapon than with a discussion of fascist ideas in, say, a university classroom or a private home.

These changes (1)–(3) will not, of course, be sufficient by themselves. I have not addressed issues as fundamental as who will own the means of #production, whether people should be guaranteed an unconditional #BasicIncome (#UBI), or how (and whether) #policing should be done. But (1)–(3) will still be needed, no matter how a host of other basic questions are to be resolved.

@dedicto

Still stunning when I talk to Americans about how http://elections.ca even just exists.

Like, they don't know that actual political parties running elections is inherently corrupt and is not even close to democracy.

We are in a federal election now, and no one is going to #hangingchad us or #jan6 us.

This isn't brain surgery.

#cdnpoli #canada #mexico #fascism #antifa #elbowsup

Elections Canada On-line - Élections Canada en ligne

Elections Canada is the independent, non-partisan agency responsible for conducting federal elections and referendums.

@Maxfieldripken

Part of American Exceptionalism is the belief that by definition the American way of doing something is always the best way. I think it would be almost impossible to get an Elections Canada equivalent in the US; " not invented here" plus too many people profit off the flaws and corruption.

@dedicto

@Jgmeadows @Maxfieldripken The bloom is seriously off American exceptionalism right now. My belief: we actually WERE exceptional in certain ways — just not as strongly or pervasively as most of us thought. But at present we're getting a fearsome lesson in the limits of our exceptionalism — AND losing, with appalling speed, most or all of the advantages that made at least some of it real.

This nation has gone seriously off the rails. I doubt we will ever recover the prestige we had (even among those who hated us!) until recently. And we won't be able to keep fooling ourselves about it forever. Sooner than you think, Americans may be willing to listen to advice from outside as we have never been in my 67 years.

But in any case, you've already got one American who is willing to listen. Tell me more about Elections Canada.

@dedicto @Maxfieldripken I hope enough Americans get the message; those on places like Mastodon are a loud minority, but a minority nonetheless.

As for Elections Canada, the most important thing about that organization is that it is non-partisan. Not under the control of political parties. So we don't get gerrymandering, or conservative provinces succeeding in making it harder to vote (they would if they could)

The wikipedia article has more details: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_Canada

Elections Canada - Wikipedia

@dedicto @Jgmeadows

Exceptional in good ways though?

Imperialism, rapacious capitalism, subverting and overthrowing democracies around the world for centuries, global oppression, slavery and systemic racism, definitely exceptional in those areas.

I mean baseball and Jazz are good.

Maga means make America great again, and great? How? Was it ever great, and great in what ways, good, bad, net positive?

@dedicto @Jgmeadows

Well, go to their website. See what they do.

They run non-partisan federal elections. Every province and territory has one too.

Never a hanging chad or insurrection.

@Jgmeadows @dedicto

I remember when George w. Caesar was President, and it came up about #AbuGhraib and American torture. And I think the White House Council office wrote an argument saying that what the United States was doing in Iraq or any of the black site torture facilities, wasn't torture. Because America doesn't torture people. Therefore everything we do, isn't torture. And they said it with a straight face.

@Maxfieldripken

Yup, I remember that. It's not a crime when Americans do it.

@dedicto