The 'Misunderestimating' Trap:

Many progressives think that people who vote conservative are just stupid, especially those who vote against their economic self-interest.

Some believe that if we tell them the real economic facts, they will change how they vote.

In reality, those who vote conservative have other reasons, and we must understand them.

Conservative populism is cultural — not economic — in nature.

Conservative populists see themselves as oppressed by elitist liberals who look down their noses at them.

They see liberals as trying to impose an immoral "political correctness" on them.

And they are very angry about it.

More at FrameLab:

https://www.theframelab.org/twelve-communication-traps-democrats/

Twelve Communication Traps Democrats and Progressives Must Avoid

Dr. George Lakoff outlines the major pitfalls of political framing

FrameLab
@georgelakoff Thank you for posting this. I was trying to figure out how to get it out of my head myself, and this article did a much better job of it.
@knowprose @georgelakoff https://youtu.be/6q_BE5KPp18 further recommended reading, eh, watching. He talks along the lines of urbanites vs. Rural people and how many urbanites identify as rural. And about... medical research about worse health outcomes for rural identifying people. Spoiler: that happens even to rural identifying people in cities, so "rural" as a selfidentifier is a proxy for antiintelectualism, so people smoke more, don't get vaccines,... and die sooner.
Rural Cosplay is, Unfortunately, A Thing

YouTube

@georgelakoff I wish they would please tell us how we oppressed them?

As for stupid... some believe that is a an intellectual judgement, however it is one based on their actions. They are the person who repeatedly grabs the electric fence with a clear danger label "just to check". They have memory of a goldfish so consequences of their stupidity just do not change them. Cipolla had the perfect explanation - the stupid are led bandits. Another take is they are suckers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vGAqYNFQdZ4

Don't Be a Sucker

National Archives Identifier: 24376Local Identifier: 111-EF-6https://catalog.archives.gov/id/24376Creator(s): Department of Defense. Department of the Army. ...

YouTube

@enmodo @georgelakoff

Well last time I tried to get my racist GOP friends to stop being fucking racists, they told me I was "just showing off how educated and politically correct" I was, so maybe that's it

@darwinwoodka @georgelakoff and who told them that being that way is "educated and politically correct"? Their propagandaist programmers from the Fox pulpit. I'm fun of goading those who say "woke" with "it's better than being asleep" but yeah maybe we should stop using that language ourselves.

The irony is many of those who hate the idea of being "woke" claim to be Christian and yet their anti-woke behavior is basically the opposite of their (claimed) saviors teachings.

@darwinwoodka @georgelakoff ultimately I don't know how to help or communicate with someone who is bending over backwards to believe 2+2=5. They just need to anti something. They need to have someone to blame for everything. They need to believe all the shit rained down on them by Cipollas "bandits" aka sociopathic apex predators of humanity is not their fault for electing them. We need those special glasses from "They live" that allow them to see reality but no one has created them yet.

@enmodo I mean they do, if you bother to listen.

But then it kind of confirms their opinion that you don't bother to listen.

@georgelakoff

@volkris @georgelakoff they told us we forced them to get gay married, have sex changes, took away all their guns, made them go to drag shows.

@enmodo citation to them telling you that?

@georgelakoff

@volkris @georgelakoff well I was knocking on doors for the Harris campaign among other things, but you'd have to have been there.

I think this video gives an example of most of these except guns: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e5Z1hdiwRo0

They will claim "I'm okay with you doing whatever you want" and then claim it's being pushed on them as if their kids are being forced to go to drag queen story time. And they will hold up their signs and support people who want to stop people doing whatever they want.

MAGA Man Gives Brain Melting Take On LGBTQ+ Rights

YouTube

@enmodo so you see how that's not quite the same?

@georgelakoff

@georgelakoff A March 2024 repost of a 2006 article? Isn't it worth a rewrite/re-think?
@georgelakoff Oh I think theyre angry about having equality imposed on them.

@georgelakoff :: shrug :: Children think that Santa Claus is real.

i really don't care why conservatives are the way they are. If they're legal adults, it's up to them to get their shit together. We're not their fucking mommy.

@georgelakoff

Conservatives are bigots willing to hurt others, & themselves, to retaliate against their perceived "enemies".

They're fed a garbage scow's worth of lies from Fox News that portray women, POC, immigrants, LGBTQ, the young, seniors, the poor, unions, and Democrats as the "enemy".

The moneyed fund mass malign influence campaigns knowing bigots are THE voting bloc reliable enough to hurt themselves in order to hurt others.

Spiteful. Self-defeating.

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/23/books/review-sum-of-us-heather-mcghee.html

Book Review: ‘The Sum of Us,’ by Heather McGhee

Heather McGhee’s compassionate but cleareyed book argues that divide-and-conquer tactics have left all Americans worse off.

The New York Times

@georgelakoff Great minds think alike! Just today emeritus professor of cosmology Kari Enqvist wrote a column about this on Finnish Broadcasting Company Yleisradio.

Yes, the column is in Finnish, so it is very likely that most can't read it.

https://yle.fi/a/74-20130037

Kari Enqvistin kolumni: Konservatiivisen oikeistopopulismin marssi tulee jatkumaan

Konservatiiviset populistit menestyvät, koska he lupaavat itsekunnioituksen palauttamista ja parempia aikoja, pohtii Enqvist

Yle Uutiset
@georgelakoff Empower unions and they will boss the party. The messaging pablum doesn't work to cover up the rightward slant of the party.

@georgelakoff Well the other thing you need to consider is that maybe you're simply wrong about the economic benefits?

I see that sort of thing all the time, progressives insisting that something is economically against so and so, but when you sit down and work through it, the progressive simply has their analysis wrong.

Question your priors. Don't assume that you're right just because the other side doesn't agree.

@georgelakoff isn’t that the definition of stupidity?

@georgelakoff

Fact: Some people are just arseholes.
We can dress it up however we want.

@georgelakoff

I struggle to understand how this conflicts with the idea that these are people who choose to inflict pain on others and self and who choose to not view all humans as equally human.

@georgelakoff yeah, but they're still idiots for falling for that in the first place. Not all - many seem to have been indoctrinated from birth.
@georgelakoff Liberals dont give a fuck what conservatives do and dont do. Liberals dont try to control how conservatives live. They just want to be left alone. On the other hand conservatives wish for everyone to live in the 1800s where they are "emotionally".

@georgelakoff

Damn, that website is annoying AF.

[popover] SUBSCRIBE, SOB STORY

[intentionally hard to close popover bullshit]

Subscribe!

Subscribe!

Subscribe!!!!

Subscriiiiiibe!!!!

"Help us fight back — become a paid subscriber today!" NO. Fuck you.

Closed.

@georgelakoff
This is the ideological and progressive, optimistic "trap". The harsh fact is that there are pigs who support their butcher.

@georgelakoff Unfortunately, the rest of us describe it not as "political correctness", but as reality.

When your feelings are more important than verified, objective facts (yes, the US has a long history of, um, being an imperfect union. And global warming is real. And tax cuts have never paid for themselves.)

I could go on, but why? The point is that conservatives place their feelings higher than reality.

@georgelakoff This is the truth. Just having a college education, at any level, makes you an enemy of conservatives without any political or economic consideration at all. They refuse to believe that thinking is a good thing, and is free for all.

Telling them how stupid they are only reinforces this.

@georgelakoff Is it because I am woke?