"Most Canadians who make more than $250,000 in profit in a single year from capital income, like the sale of secondary properties or stock options, will now pay more in tax on the income above that threshold."

We need seniors to sell off their properties, not hoard them. Increasing capital gains tax will make the housing market worse.

If the gov wants to tax people, tax landlords. This will force landlords to sell, increase the housing stock for sale.

#ONpoli #TOpoli #CANpoli

@Tomthndsh That's a bit misguided, I think. You seem to be referring to seniors who sell their principal residence they've lived in for decades after the children are grown up and gone. That's been exempt from Capital Gains completely - no change there.
If they're "investors" selling some other property they own, is it really too much to ask that they pay tax on 2/3 of the excess rather than just half?
https://www.nbc.ca/personal/advice/home/principal-residence-exemption.html
#cdnpoli
How does the capital gain exemption for principal residences work?

Thinking of selling your property and making some money? Find out how your profits could be tax exempt.

National Bank

@SheamusPatt Better to tax landlords, and give some sort of financial break for people to sell their investment property and leave the landlord industry.

A stick and carrot approach. The goal is to fix housing.

This is a tax on the middle class, that are too scared to invest in the fixed stock-market, and make nothing on interest from a savings account. Tax the ultra wealthy, not the middle class.

#ONpoli #TOpoli #Canpoli

@Tomthndsh Presumably selling their investment property to other landlords? The small boost in the capital gains exemption rate seems quite reasonable. Anyone owning investment properties that are generating more than $250,000 in capital gains isn't a "poor senior" - they're well off.
There are more direct ways to fix housing.

  • Get back into direct investments in non-market housing
  • Bring back rent controls

#cdnpoli #onpoli #TaxTheRich

@SheamusPatt Many people started to invest in housing and avoided the stock market. Their retirement savings is really having a 2nd property. Especially since many jobs over the last 30 years didn't cover enough to retire on.

The government by taxing the sale of these investment homes is perpetuating the crisis, and making money off the landlord industry; they like it. No interest in moving away from what is happening. No interest in providing affordable housing.

@SheamusPatt If the government was interested in fixing the housing crisis, they'd drop the capital gains tax if you sold your investment property to a new home buyer.

#ONpoli #TOpoli #CANpoli

@Tomthndsh I don't quite see that. It's the vendor, not the buyer, paying the tax and it's market value so they can't just add the cost onto the price. If the tax is so onerous that they just hang onto it, then they'll rent it out so it's still housing for someone.
#cdnpoli #onpoli
@SheamusPatt "...it's still housing for someone.." is an argument in support of landlords.
@Tomthndsh
Does that not just move the housing from the rental market to the owner market making it only available to people who can afford to buy it.
@the5thColumnist It moves back the ratio of people owning/renting to before this mess started.
@Tomthndsh
That assumes the problem is lack of housing for sale NOT the affordably of housing for sale.
@the5thColumnist About 50% of the rental market is mom/pop investors. Most people avoid the stock market because it seems random and fixed.
We need to fix this mess. Best way to do it is to build a large amount of social housing.
Build tent cities, using the army, to house the thousands of homeless in Canada that are sleeping in parks and forests, immediately!
But much of this mess is because of poor finance oversight.