I asked around so-called influencers why they were not on #Mastodon . Here are the most common replies:

1) We can't go viral on Mastodon (read as we can't game the system because humans only boost good stuff)

2) They want a algo driven system (why do you want to see angry posts all day & night?)

3) You can't make money on Mastodon (WTF that even mean?)

4) It is way too technical & confusing. Which server to join? WTF is the server?

Only the last one is valid. The rest are all lazy reasons.

@nixCraft

The disdain for anyone that makes money through content online, is palpable. I'm not trying to change your opinion on that. I'm just pointing it out.

Going viral doesn't mean gaming the system. Most content goes viral because it is novel, entertaining, and fun.

And as I've said on here many, many times, the most viewed content on social media by far isn't angry content. It's happy/funny content. Twitter and 4chan are miserable places. TikTok and Instagram are happier places.

@nixCraft

I see a lot of replies of the form:

"You can make money on Mastodon! You just have to do A, B, and C! It works!"

And:

"We don't want influencers on Mastodon."

The thing I find funny about the "You can make money on Mastodon!" claim, is that it's almost always proclaimed by Mastodon dudes that don't make any money through their social media content, talking about people that do make money on their social media content. 0% experience, 100% confidence.🙂🙃

2/N

@mekkaokereke @nixCraft oh yes you can make money here, the issue is that its not the way how asocial media monetizes, here, the users decide to spend money, users here dont get ad revenue.

@april @nixCraft

I've seen authors get roasted on here for promoting their own books.

I've seen server admins get insulted for suggesting moving to a subscription model rather than a donation model.

I haven't seen many (any?) examples of people being financially successful on Mastodon with a "here's how I did it!" tutorial with real numbers. I just see vague hand-wavings about "It's totally possible!" but when I ask for concrete examples, it gets real quiet. 🤷🏿‍♂️

https://hachyderm.io/@mekkaokereke/113175911162464927

mekka okereke :verified: (@[email protected])

@[email protected] @[email protected] Minimum wage in NYC is $16/hr. At 52 weeks working 40 hrs a week, that's ~35K a year. Is nixCraft making $35K a year on Mastodon? I hope so! But I doubt it. If they are, how are they doing that? What mechanism are they using to be paid for their labor and craftsmanship? Donations? Subscriptions? (And $35K is not enough to cover the average 1 bedroom rent in NYC. Let alone pay for food, health insurance, clothes, and utilities). People deserve to be paid for their labor.

Hachyderm.io

@mekkaokereke @april @nixCraft I'm fairly financially successful with monetization on Mastodon, and do publish figures (but it's been a while since I've written an updated article)

YTD I've made €7,713.27 in gross revenue from the community, or between €500-1500 a month. That's across 3 channels, excluding GitHub Sponsors.

Last year was €8,497.03 from supporters, averaging €40 per transaction.

@thisismissem @mekkaokereke @april @nixCraft

I hope you do realize that this is less than minimum wage? How much was that per hour of work?

Can you honestly say that this is "financial success" and that it could be emulated by others if one could make more money delivering food and biking around the city?

@raphael @mekkaokereke @april @nixCraft

I've only been tracking open-source contributions in terms of hours since the Q2 of this year. This year so far I have done 184 hours of work on open-source, of which 21.50 hours were funded separately and 8 hours of admin work.

I fully agree that the community support I receive is currently well below minimum wage, which is why I'm trying to increase that income.

I've also done a lot of freelance work to make ends meet, which balanced things out.

@raphael @mekkaokereke @april @nixCraft

As for is this "financial success", well, it's my full time job, I have no other employment besides the community funding, grants, and freelance work.

I don't work for any for-profit company. I meet my needs.

Note: I'm excluding from those numbers the grants and freelance work, which is the lions share of my income.

@raphael @mekkaokereke @april @nixCraft also, for context, some of the other people in the fediverse development sector that I've spoken to about community funding for projects have reported similar figures, €12,000-ish per year without grants and other income sources.

@thisismissem @raphael @april @nixCraft

Hot take:
People think that the Fediverse isn't safe(yet) because of slight differences between how you see the world, and Eugen sees the world, and Ro sees the world, and Oliphant sees the world, and Jaz sees the world, and Sierdy sees the world, and Hrefna sees the world, etc.

But the real reason the Fediverse is not safe and secure (yet), is that none of you can earn a stable and secure living working on Fediverse safety full time.🤷🏿‍♂️

1/N

@thisismissem @raphael @april @nixCraft

I am profoundly uninterested in giving my hot take nitpicking ideas on how any of you should be thinking about safety. And I don't think we want or need consensus.

I am deeply interested in how we change state to where you all can earn a living working on this stuff full-time, in a way that avoids the usual "money with downsides and baggage" like VC money, or becoming dependent on wealthy benefactors who may change their minds (eg Big Tech grants).

2/2

@mekkaokereke @raphael @april @nixCraft for full disclosure, my total revenue year to date, excluding open/future invoices is €44,960 with €4,210.61 in expenses.

So I have made a decent income for a developer based in Germany, where a less-experienced developer would make €40-45k, and experienced developers would be €60-90k.

That's including freelance contracts, bug bounties, grants, etc.

@mekkaokereke @raphael @april @nixCraft

But yeah, the Fediverse as a whole is extremely underfunded, and that only changes with people wanting to say “I value this and I want to fund it's existence”

@thisismissem

I value the Fediverse and want to fund its existence. I don't want to simply set money on fire. What are my options?

My charity budget is completely allocated. My investment budget is not.

#asking_for_a_friend

I think that's a critical challenge, if someone solves that without breaking the ideals, it would be beyond awesome.

@mekkaokereke @raphael @april @nixCraft

@iwein @thisismissem @raphael @april @nixCraft

The Nivenly Foundation has given grants to many of the folk I mentioned in this post. ♥️👍🏿

https://hachyderm.io/@mekkaokereke/113177194652670163

I'd say either give to one of those folks directly, or give to Nivenly.

https://nivenly.org

Speaking of investment, the goal is not to create a new part of the non-profit world, where these orgs are dependent on philanthropy. The goal is to bootstrap these orgs and help them become independent, running without VC or philanthropy

mekka okereke :verified: (@[email protected])

@thisismissem @[email protected] @[email protected] @[email protected] Hot take: People think that the Fediverse isn't safe(yet) because of slight differences between how you see the world, and Eugen sees the world, and Ro sees the world, and Oliphant sees the world, and Jaz sees the world, and Sierdy sees the world, and Hrefna sees the world, etc. But the real reason the Fediverse is not safe and secure (yet), is that none of you can earn a stable and secure living working on Fediverse safety full time.🤷🏿‍♂️ 1/N

Hachyderm.io
@mekkaokereke @iwein @thisismissem @raphael @april @nixCraft I would hope so. But nobody has explained to me where what the business model is supposed to be.

@polotek @iwein @thisismissem @raphael @april @nixCraft

Super fair question.

I think moderation is a service. It makes sense to me to subscribe to that service, and to be billed periodically.

Right now though there's a large gap between "what people are willing to pay for that service," and "how much that service really costs to provide." This is obscured by the fact that most moderation is 100% volunteer today. 🤷🏿‍♂️

@mekkaokereke @polotek @iwein @thisismissem @raphael @april @nixCraft Hell yes. I would love it if I could delegate moderation to a paid service that would be better at it than I could be, and that could collect signals from multiple servers to catch problems before many people have to see them.
@marcprecipice @mekkaokereke @polotek @iwein @thisismissem @raphael @april @nixCraft it’s just people, babe. Good moderation is just good people all the way down
@marcprecipice @mekkaokereke @polotek @iwein @thisismissem @raphael @april @nixCraft this is a service we (the Mastodon org) currently provide to the EC (we also host their instance), and they pay for it. It is all very manual for now, but would be made much more easier with what I described here: https://renchap.com/blog/post/evolving_mastodon_trust_and_safety/
Our recently announced Fediscovery project will build the first bricks towards this.
Evolving Mastodon’s Trust & Safety Features • Renaud Chaput

Here are my personal thoughts about how we could handle Trust & Safety features in Mastodon software. This is based on my own experience in the field, my current knowledge of the source code and architecture, as well as my experience managing infrastructure for mastodon.social & mastodon.online since December 2022. Context Managing a Mastodon instance is hard work, with the most effort going to moderation and abuse, and not technical operations as one might expect. This includes:

Renaud Chaput