Via Sherrilyn Ifill:

Listen pundits and Dem influencers. Your willingness to continue beating this horse is becoming…weird. Ask yourself why most prominent Black leaders & ordinary Black ppl are for #Biden staying in. We love Kamala, so what could be the reason? Maybe we see America through a different lens. One that allows us to see things that you don’t. Your apparent dismissal of that possibility is very revealing. And not in a good way.

@GottaLaff
I don't see a huge gap here…

Black voters: 53% agree that "Joe Biden is just too old to be an effective president," 32% strongly.
vs.
2020 Biden voters: 62% agree, 32% strongly.

(Black voters differ from other racial groups because there are way fewer Republicans.)

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/07/03/us/elections/times-siena-poll-registered-voter-crosstabs.html

Cross-Tabs: July 2024 Times/Siena Poll of Registered Voters Nationwide

Results of a nationwide New York Times/Siena College poll conducted among 1,532 registered voters from June 28 to July 2, 2024.

The New York Times

@Carwil You’re quoting the NYT?

Vs Ifill?

Guess which one has more cred.

@GottaLaff
Oof, the whole idea that polling results are best understood as the extension of an institution's general credibility is off base.
@GottaLaff
Who can better assess voter sentiment across a nationwide population, a well-conducted poll with a sizable sample, or a prominent leader in that community? An interesting empirical question, but it doesn't have one obvious answer.
@Carwil @GottaLaff
I trust the Congressional Black Caucus, with their ear to the ground, more than polls. Even the Squad hasn't gone wobbly on Biden.
Are you serious?

@Carwil

The crosstabs for NYT polls have too frequently looked silly compared to other high quality polls.

I would not trust their subgroup slices without corroborating numbers from at least one decent poll specifically targeting the subgroup.

@GottaLaff

@joeinwynnewood Bingo. And thank you, Joe, as always. @Carwil

@GottaLaff @Carwil

Why polls aren't working, and the very bad idea that they want to fill in for them:

https://ash.harvard.edu/articles/using-ai-for-political-polling/

Using AI for Political Polling – Ash Center

Ash Center

@GottaLaff @Carwil Definitely the one that talked to a randomized sample and normalized to population makeup rather than one person who talked to a limited subset of people without controlling for the demographics, age, and propensity to vote of that group.

Individual leaders have weight but high quality polling doesn’t reflect the ideology of the pollsters any more than high quality elections reflect the ideology of the vote counters.

@GottaLaff
Asked more specifically, "Do you think Joe Biden should remain the Democratic Party’s nominee for president, or should there be a different Democratic nominee for president?"

Black voters: 47 to 43, different nominee
Biden '20 voters: 49 to 44, different nominee

@Carwil @GottaLaff

"a CBS News/YouGov poll conducted during the same period as the Times poll found that 42 percent of Black voters think Biden should not run for president, while 58 percent think he should. Overall, 69 percent of voters think Biden shouldn't run, but only 41 percent of Democrats said the same."

This implies a very low reliability in the polls. This is either a systemic problem with the polls, or a problem with the skew of different pollsters.

Those are differences _way_ outside of statistical noise.

@Carwil @GottaLaff This whole series of opinions based on one flawed source with extremely vested interests has a very "Hey, I'm not a reply guy, I'm just asking questions!" tone to it. Pass.

@Carwil @GottaLaff That's a misleading question unless it names somebody as the alternative. As the question is asked, voters are free to imagine they can snap their fingers and get whoever they want.

* I'd also want to know how many people gave up on the poll halfway through?
* And I'd also want to know if the people who refused to take the poll were much different from the people who actually took the poll?

@gpk Good points. There's another one that @msignorile made on his show: Those who respond, are they enthusiastic about a replacement? Or are they thinking, sure, why not, but not enthusiastic enough to call on someone to step in. I'm phrasing that wrong, but it was something like that. IOW, not passionate about Biden leaving the race.

@Carwil

@Carwil @GottaLaff That's called a "push poll" and it should be viewed with tremendous skepticism considering that the NYT has been on the warpath against Biden since the debate.

You will get a different result if you ask voters, "Should Biden stay in the race."

@Carwil @GottaLaff do we have similar polling for views of trump?

@GottaLaff

From my view the loudest voices who are demanding Biden go now are those who don't want any possibility of a woman, especially one of mixed ancestry, becoming President ...

Being one step behind the man is OK, especially if it garners black votes ... but becoming President ...? Nah ...

@MyView @GottaLaff Harris is polling better than Biden right now against Trump. Joe’s coattails are a drag. Just give her the nomination

@GottaLaff

It's entirely predictable:

Biden: let's tax large corporations and billionaires.

LC+B: f*ck you, old maniac. Watch this.

@GottaLaff The Dems are Swift Boating themselves and all Trump has to do is sit back and watch.
@GottaLaff vote like Black Women - they save us every single time

@GottaLaff Some pundits and celebrities over on Twitter are being first-rate class-A-number-one bastards about this. They've gone from concern trolls to outright gamergate-level internet bullying.

A lot of them are "conservative Never Trumpers" that were always in this only for the money and attention, but some of them seem to be liberal voices, like Rob Reiner. I don't know what to do about people like Reiner. We need celebrities on our side.

@GottaLaff I wrote the WH--said, pay no attention to DC pols and pundits

@GottaLaff

Do you think, I'm just asking that those of us who think Harris would be a better candidate than Biden see things that you don't and your dismissal of us is problematic?

I don't pretend that I have any influence over anyone and I will vote for anyone who's running against Trump.

@GottaLaff Maybe Ifill could be so kind as to reveal what it is that Black people see that the rest of us can't? Because to those of us lacking perspective, it sure as shit looks like Biden has been losing all year, has no plan to turn it around, doesn't have the capability to turn it around, and is going to usher in American fascism with his stubborn pride.

@ThisAccountKillsFascists @GottaLaff

Who is 'us' again?
This #Mayonnaisian in Tacoma knows her history
Changing horses at this point has not worked EVER, & #Project2025 is becoming known, so #CorporateMedia is pulling out all the stops to preserve shareholder's #TaxBreaks

@PeachMcD You can't "know your history" about something that has never happened in American history. By that logic, I could say that I know my history and it shows that an 81-year nominee who displayed signs of cognitive decline during a live debate and says he can't handle events after 8 PM anymore never wins.

As for changing horses, a lot of people are confusing cause and effect. It's like saying that you're always sick when you go to the doctor, so you should stop going to the doctor.

@PeachMcD We are fording the most dangerous stream that we've ever crossed, and the horse can't seem to keep its head above water. That's why we're thinking that maybe the risk of changing horses is still better than the risk of sticking with the horse that's drowning!

@ThisAccountKillsFascists I respect & hope that you are arguing in good faith but I completely disagree

Solidarity from Tacoma anyway
   

@PeachMcD I assure you that I am arguing in good faith. I cannot emphasize enough how critical it is that the Democrats win and MAGA lose.

I know that we are riven by a disagreement right now about tactics. But I appreciate that you see that we're all on the same side of the fight.

@ThisAccountKillsFascists
Your handle is a clue 😁 

I am not & never was a fan of either JB or KH

I believe that JB's continued reaching out to imaginary 'moderate Republicans' instead of to his base will end up with him being remembered as the Neville Chamberlain of our generation

That said, the replacement of McGovern in 72 is a precedent I have no desire to repeat & I think the division being fanned by #CorporateMedia is meant to f with turnout Dems need

@ThisAccountKillsFascists @GottaLaff If people who don't look like you are unanimous in their support and you don't understand why - then maybe you should look inward for answers, not outward...

@hu_logic First, they're far from unanimous in their support. At least two polls have already been posted in the replies showing that a substantial portion of the Black community wants to replace Biden as nominee.

Second, there is no particular reason to believe that Black politicians have unique insight into how to win this election.

@hu_logic Third, it is completely illogical to argue that Black leaders have a unique perspective due to their history and lived experience, and then turn around and say that if you don't have that history and lived experience "you should look inward for answers." Um, no. Either Black leaders have a unique perspective, in which case the rest of us can only get it if they share it, or they don't, in which case what are we even talking about here?

@ThisAccountKillsFascists @GottaLaff

Vain preening child playing around in serious stuff.

*plink*

@jztusk There is nothing more serious than beating Donald Trump in 2024. I like Joe Biden personally. I think he would have wiped the floor with Trump in 2016, and I'm very grateful he beat Trump in 2020. But I'm not in the Joe Biden fan club; I'm in the democracy and rights fan club. Joe Biden has been down in the polls all year, and given the electoral college, he actually needs to be up to have a chance to win. Silly little ad homenims aren't going to save us.

@ThisAccountKillsFascists

1. Biden polls better than any other alternative
2. He's not dropping out
3. No one else has offered to be a replacement
4. The virtual roll-call vote is in ~2 weeks, and delegates are already pledged to vote for the winner of their state's primary

This is a non-starter, and the only reason to bang on about it is if you're trying to push the "Dems in Disarray" narrative to suppress turnout.

@textualdeviance
1. True, but we know that name recognition, media coverage, and being at the head of the ticket matters a lot in polling. Who knows what kind of bump Newsom might get, for example, if he were the nominee.
2. That appears to be true. But we're discussing what should happen, including whether we should try to force him out.
3. True, today no one wants to stick their neck out or be responsible for disunity. But things can change quickly in politics.
4. True for many states.

@textualdeviance This is telling: "the only reason to bang on about it is if you're trying to push the "Dems in Disarray" narrative to suppress turnout."

A lot of Democrats are suddenly falling into conspiracy theories of their own. As I've said before, they seem to think that the rest of us didn't hear the debate, can't see that Biden is avoiding interviews, and can't read that he's been losing all year. No, it must be that we're all part of the NYT conspiracy to bring him down.

@GottaLaff um... So what's up with the two radio hosts who did radio interviews with Biden from Milwaukee and Philadelphia? Are they GOP hacks? Or part of all the psyop or whatever, when one said he believes Biden is in decline and other said questions were sent to her ahead of time from WH? They didn't just throw Biden under the bus more like pushed him right into its path.
@htpcnz I wish I knew. Or maybe it was their staff?
@GottaLaff My hunch on why the media won't quit their attempts to bash the unbashable Biden -- the Russiapublicans have got SOLID polling (not that manufactured crap that runs on CNN & in the NYT) showing tRUmp can't possibly win, so the media oligarchs, knowing this election could be the death knell for the GOP (electorate getting browner & younger & more foreign-born & more liberal), are pulling out all the stops to try & chill the race. Won't work, tho, because no one reads/listens to them.
@sirc I hope you’re right.
@GottaLaff The media has underestimated Joe Biden his entire career. They know they can't beat him, so all that's left is trying to depress support for him, but NO ONE forgets how awful it was waking up every damn day with that orange hate-clown in the White House. We ain't going back to that, no matter how much the media tries to spin things. PS, hope you & the fam are enjoying Canada!
@sirc Agree, but it’s worse than that. Dems aren’t helping Dems. https://www.threads.net/@aaron.rupar/post/C9PrQaWA75D
Aaron Rupar (@aaron.rupar) on Threads

Nancy Pelosi on Morning Joe didn't exactly express enthusiasm about Biden staying in the race: "It's up for the president to decide if he's going to run. We're all encouraging him to make that decision because time is running short ... I want him to do whatever he decides to do."

Threads
@GottaLaff which russkies are poking at the "ifluencers" ...
@GottaLaff ...there is positive powerful in Biden/Harris match....it's as if people forget that this is a choice election between Dems Biden/Harris and their team of Americans working for American or Trump/some Unnamed MAGA Lunatic and their nightmare destruction of America Program 2025 working for themselves and their rich buddies.