Federico Viticci Feb 10, 2024

Speaking of things that don’t work – I’ve always used and liked 1Password, but for the past year or so their Safari extension has barely worked for me on Mac and iPad. It regularly fails to authenticate or just never comes up.

Sad, but not surprised, to see that their Vision Pro experience with compatibility mode doesn’t work out of the box either with Safari. I get this empty spinner that never goes away 🤷‍♂️

I may have to finally consider other options for personal and team use. 😔

Show threadCasey LissFeb 10, 2024
@viticci 1Password has been doing everything in their power to convince their [non-enterprise] users to find alternatives.
Show threadJason Snell

@caseyliss @viticci I have to be honest, 1Password saved my bacon on Vision Pro. It actually autofilled all my passwords -- but not my two-factor codes 🙃

Still, I do feel the pull of just using Apple's password management at this point, now that passwords can be shared

Feb 10, 2024 at 6:42pmWeb
Show threadStephen RoblesFeb 10, 2024

@jsnell @caseyliss @viticci I’ve switched completely from 1Password to iCloud Passwords and it’s great.

Still need categories like secure doc numbers (passports) or WiFi passwords (you *have* to add a website url to create an entry), but otherwise love it.

Show threadTaraFeb 10, 2024
@stephenrobles @jsnell @caseyliss @viticci I’m tempted to do this as well, but my mom almost knows how to use 1password 5 years later, and I hate to change it now. 😂
Show threadStephen RoblesFeb 10, 2024
@TeeeBear that’s a big reason to stay for sure.
Show threadTaraFeb 12, 2024
@stephenrobles I thought we were better than we are, apparently. 🤦‍♀️
Show threadStephen RoblesFeb 12, 2024
@TeeeBear haha it's ok, the time has not yet come
Show threadMigrated to tenforward.socialFeb 11, 2024
@stephenrobles Okay, that is one limitation I can’t get behind. @jsnell @caseyliss @viticci
Show threadK. CollettFeb 11, 2024
@stephenrobles @jsnell @caseyliss @viticci I’ve been slowly migrating that sort of information into secure Notes in preparation for a possible move away from 1Password. Definitely not as nice as the bespoke solution that 1Password offers but possibly good enough.
Show threadCalebFeb 10, 2024
@jsnell @caseyliss @viticci I've switched. It's relatively painless and way smoother in everyday use.
Show threadJerrod HofferthFeb 10, 2024
@jsnell @caseyliss @viticci The only reason haven’t switched is that I desperately need the cross-platform access to use on my work PC (eew, I know).
Show threadMike LapidakisFeb 10, 2024
@jerrod @jsnell @caseyliss @viticci This, and little things like additional fields and multiple URLs. It’s insane Apple’s password manager doesn’t support multiple URLs (or the ability to edit the URL after creation). I’ve tried to switch, but it’s just too there yet.
Show threadDoug BaileyFeb 10, 2024
@jsnell @caseyliss @viticci Looking forward to switching if Apple supports Firefox on Windows like they support Chromium browsers. 🤞
Show threadRick WilliamsFeb 10, 2024
@jsnell @caseyliss @viticci I switched after death by a thousand cuts from 1Password. It’s been working great, and the windows version is serviceable enough for the little I need it. Adding the ability to use it in Chrome in MacOS removed the last bit of friction for me.
Show threadScott HillFeb 11, 2024
@jsnell 1Password copies your two-factor code to your paste buffer when it fills your password. When you get to the screen asking for the code, long pinch (that feels weird to write) and select “paste”.
Show threadJason SnellFeb 11, 2024
@scotthill ok ... but on all other Apple devices it just autofills....
Show threadScott HillFeb 11, 2024
@jsnell Agreed, it would be better that way. I did write to their support about another bug, and they replied (without a date commitment of any kind) that they're working on a Vision Pro-native app.
Show threadBest Wishes, TheJesusFishFeb 11, 2024

@jsnell @caseyliss @viticci I tried switching, but Apple keychain only supports one login per url (making google stuff a nightmare). So I had to switch back.

I have really turned around on 1pass. It used to be the best app I owned…now it’s just trash. I have the same issues Viticci has with the extension, and it’s infuriating.

Show threadMarc MagninFeb 11, 2024
@TheJesusFish @jsnell @caseyliss @viticci would that be specific to the AVP? Because on MacOS, IOS and IPadOS you can have many logins per url 🤔
Show threadBest Wishes, TheJesusFishFeb 11, 2024

@marcmagnin They may have updated it since I last tried (which was the release of sonoma), but that was one of the restrictions.

Another was that the file 1password exports needs to be proofread to make sure all the passwords are formatted correctly because password import will fail silently, and not tell you which passwords failed to import.