"America is on the brink, so of course the #media doesn't get it. Last week, the disconnect between rising GOP #fascism - on a debate stage, in #Trump's arrest posturing - and journalists covering 'a normal election' was really jarring

Now what?

The media is really not getting it about 2024, GOP authoritarianism and the election"

If @willbunch wrote it, you should read it.©.. & I thread it. 1/...🧵

https://www.inquirer.com/opinion/commentary/media-2020-election-trump-authoritarianism-20230827.html#loaded

Journalism fails miserably at explaining what is really happening to America

Momentous week of GOP debate, Trump's arrest gets "horse race" coverage when the story's not about an election, but authoritarianism.

https://www.inquirer.com
2/ "If you watched the hours of TV news coverage during an especially momentous week in August, there was little sense of that reality, and for long stretches of pundit blather, none at all — as talking heads gave earnest high school debating marks to candidates who are all but ignored by the GOP voter base. The disconnect deepened the next night as Trump turned what would surely be his comeuppance —his surrender...― into an outlaw display of authoritarian force."
3/ "..There was little discussion of why this accused felon was getting a phalanx of dozens of motorcycle cops, comprising police who are drawn to Trump’s authoritarian bluster like moths to light. Trump’s glowering mugshot instantly became the most-talked-about picture in American history—yet not one pundit was able to explain why tens of millions of everyday voters are so eager to return to the White House this man who attempted a coup on Jan6, or why his poll numbers rise w each indictment"

4/ "America is entering its most important, pivotal year since 1860 & media doing terrible job explaining what is actually happening. Too many still covering elections like it was 20th cent., as if old touchstones like debates or 30-sec spot still matter.

What we are building toward on 11/5/2024, might have outward trappings of election but it is really show of force. What we call GOP is barely a political party...but a dangerous antisocial movement that has embraced many tenets of fascism"

5/ "There is no “Trump scandal” because — for them — each new crime or sexual assault is merely another indictment of the messenger, the arrogrant elites from whom their contempt is the No. 1 issue. These foot soldiers stopped believing in “democracy” a long time ago — no matter how big an Orwellian sign Fox erects."
6/ "DC pundits like Parker, Baker are trained to talk to folks on stage & their high-priced consultants, not mob that moves modern Repub'ism away from believing in elections. I’ve been inside/outside of Trump rallies in Hershey, West Chester, Wildwood & what I learned is only issue that matters isn’t an issue at all, but contempt for media outlets like CNN they believe look down on them & their savior. Of cs, salary of Baker or Parker or CNN punditocracy depends on not understanding that"
7/ "News media better get comfortable talking about what is really happening in places like Anthony’s Farmville, Va.,ought to be explaining both the legit anger over “working overtime hours for {BS] pay,” manip of that anger by demagogues like Trump, + uncomfortable ques about how much of the rage is over threats to outdated, detestable hierarchies of white supremacy & the patriarchy."
8/" Ramaswamy went on CNN w a dark, rt-wing appeal that is the change that far too many people are seeking, in stunning riff that blamed racist mass shooting in Jacksonville by a white gunman who targeted Black people not on racism but on antiracism & media. Ramaswamy insisted that media, universities, certain politicians have rekindled racism & “I can think of no better way to fuel racism in this country than by taking something away from people based on their skin color.” Meaning white people"
9/ "These are the stakes: dueling visions for America — not Democratic or Republican, with parades and red, white, and blue balloons, but brutal fascism or flawed democracy. The news media needs to stop with the horse-race coverage of this modern-day March on Rome, stop digging incessantly for proof that both sides are guilty of the same sins, and stop thinking that a war for the imperiled survival of the American Experiment is some kind of inexplicable “tribalism.”
10/ "We need to hear from more experts on authoritarian movements, and fewer pollsters and political strategists. We need journalists who’ll talk a lot less about who’s up or down and a lot more about the stakes — including Trump’s plans to dismantle the democratic norms that he calls “the administrative state,” to weaponize the criminal justice system, and to surrender the war against climate change — if the 45th president becomes the 47th."

11/11 🎯 "We need the media to see 2024 not as a traditional election but as an effort to mobilize a mass movement that would undo democracy and splatter America with more blood like what was shed Saturday in Jacksonville. We need to understand that if the next 15 months remain the worst covered election in U.S. history, that it might also be the last."👈

PLEASE read the entire column. I left out a lot.

@GottaLaff There was a Kennedy2024 sign in very liberal Asheville, NC yesterday. Someone removed it before I could.
@sepfeiffer And there's one around the block from me.
@GottaLaff The problem, as Will points out, is that EVERYTHING is done to sow unrest and dismantle democracy. That sign has no support in Asheville. It was *planted*
@GottaLaff And now I’m going to have a glass of wine and cook. Cheers Laffy!
@GottaLaff
If the media published as many interviews of Democrats and Democratic voters as they do Republicans, I think the overall narrative would shift, but I guess we're just too boring.
@GreenFire It's always, ALWAYS, the same. Infuriating.

@GottaLaff
It's like how can almost of the people from a twice impeached, criminally indicted administration have gotten jobs in our media and/or get so much attention from them when it comes time for them to try to sell their books.

Our mainstream media would have offered #Prigozhin a gig to be their Russian commentator I have no doubt if he'd volunteered to call in to them.

@GottaLaff
I do have to thank goodness that we have MSNBC as a counter to #FauxNews but that seems to be the only actually pro-Democratic media organization in contrast to how many our opponents control.

Also, besides acknowledging that, I wanted to post a screenshot of this rightfully angry Democratic state representative from Florida.

She's pleading for America to wake up to the danger we're facing.

@GreenFire @GottaLaff I turned on CNN for the arrest coverage and was pretty impressed. I think they've turned back around to more balanced coverage. MSNBC lets their hosts talk too much, and while I agree with them it just gets a little tiresome.

@GreenFire @GottaLaff I mean, what's the fun in this interview:

Reporter: Would you kill someone you didn't like?
Progressive: You're joking - that's horrible. No!

@GottaLaff I don't know why I have to keep being the one to say this. The GOP has ceased to be a functioning political party, with political goals and political means of achieving them.

They want to kill us. That's the platform.

@LadyDragonfly You're not the one to say this. MSNBC prime time hosts go there all the time. I do too. So do my followers and many many journalists and legal analysts.

In fact, some former Republicans have too. 2 nights ago, Stuart Stevens did. So have multiple GOP pundits (or former GOP) repeatedly. They're terrified too.

@GottaLaff maybe it's starting to break through the noise then. Feels like I've been screeching this into the void for coming up on a decade now.
@LadyDragonfly Me too, but we've definitely not been alone. Know that.
@GottaLaff thank you, that actually does make me feel a bit better. Sometimes it helps just to be told.

@LadyDragonfly Yeah, sometimes people forget to voice things, they let others do it for them.

You're not alone. Not by a long shot.

@GottaLaff @LadyDragonfly While Bunch about may be right, three themes I wish he'd addressed are:

1. Primary eligible GOP voters are 34 percent of the electorate. If 50-60 percent of the 34 percent are cult-members, so what?

2. Reporters could do a way better job explaining how any of what is "really happening to America" will change communities.

3. Readers/listeners need options and information, i.e. what is ranked choice voting?; how might RCV change our election landscape?; what is the Electoral College, and what's the fastest way to dispense with it?

As long as we have only social media & ad-driven news and information, and Citizen's United written in stone, I have little faith that many editors/publishers will address any of the above.

@GottaLaff Thank you boosting this article.
@JanF_Blogs Will is a dear pal. He's fantastic.
@GottaLaff
Entirely maddening to me are folks like Joe Scarborough with 7 years of experience in Congress, twenty plus years ago telling people today, via his old "when I was in Congress" war stories, this is what they need to do. And he drags the same type of people to the table for their outdated advice. So blinded by stage lighting, they hardly know time of day much less anything of great substance.
@Atticus1956 And let's not forget how he and Mika sucked up to Trump in 2016.
@GottaLaff
Really! I've heard Joe & his cronies on multiple occasions castigate Trump over his 'wanting to fit in/belong' with the old money in NY & FL seemingly forgetting, we watched them doing the same 'with' Trump.

@GottaLaff

VOTER TURNOUT in a presidential election has not reached 70% since 1900. This is one factor we can control and certainly one we can improve upon, even when voting laws and dirty politics muddle progress.

Person-to-person engagement is key. Volunteer efforts are critical. Funding campaigns is vital.

YOU can make a real difference, even if your bank account and volunteer time are limited. EVERY SINGLE EFFORT IS VALUABLE.

🔷 It’s not too early to #DonateToDems
🔷 It’s not too early to join activist organizations.
🔷It’s not too early to get involved locally to register voters, encourage others to check their registrations, to help young people register.

You know what the stakes are if MAGA-GOP candidates prevail.
You’ve experienced the disaster of a Trump administration.

DONATE TO DEMS. JOIN ACTIVISTS. WORK TO GET OUT THE VOTE.
#TootTheTruth about Biden/Harris Administration’s successes.

#BidenHarris2024
#GOTV

@cynblogger @GottaLaff

Call your county Democratic Party office and offer to do one or more of these things:

- Make phone calls
- Canvass
- Write postcards
- Staff their office
- Assemble yard signs
- Deliver yard signs
- Put signs in your own yard
- Give them money

You'll do good and build your own community.

@GottaLaff ….great heartfelt and spot-on thread. America teeters on plummeting into fascism….Nazi-ism….and the media plays footsie with nonsense days of yore. They must ring the bell loudly and often to the real plight we ALL are facing….

@GottaLaff The news media is slow to understand that, in a Trump America 2, they will be the first to be sued, raided, and shut down by a hostile DOJ unconcerned with the Constitution.

First they came for the journalists...

@GottaLaff

"What we call the Republican Party is barely a political party in any sense of the word but a dangerous antisocial movement that has embraced many of the tenets of fascism, from calls for violence to its dehumanizing of “others” — from desperate refugees at the border to transgender youth."

The for-profit media, by and large, isn't ever going to "get" it.

It's the for-profit media and that's always going to be it's primary motivation, profits.

@joeinwynnewood @GottaLaff

That's very sad.

Back in the day (sorry to sound like an old lady, but that's what I am), news organizations were not profit centers. The networks produced them kind of as a public good. They weren't expected to make money.

Now that's all changed, as you know, and trust in news organizations has declined ever since.

@GottaLaff this is a great thread and sadly how we’re failing.
But I’ve been wondering…who were all of the people that comprised that motorcade? And where did they come from? Any details?
@GreetingsOut Which motorcade?
@GottaLaff trump’s
@GreetingsOut Secret service and entourage.
@GottaLaff I’m still curious who was in his entourage. Any off duty law enforcement or public officials? It’s good to know who the seditionists are.
@GreetingsOut Anyone employed by Trump is a seditionist (other than his lawyers, if they’re the legit ones)
@GottaLaff too true. And as I realize you know, we can add fascist to that description too
@GottaLaff I think my curiosity is if there were any law-enforcement personnel that were doing that off of duty. Because I’d like to know that. I don’t know if someone has a list of who is in it somewhere
@GottaLaff "This weekend, the New York Times’ Peter Baker, an influential news analyst, noted on Twitter/X that in 1994 some 21% of Republicans and 17% of Democrats viewed the other party negatively which has risen to 62% (GOP) and 54% (Dems). Baker was recommending a story condemning “tribalism,” when what we are really seeing here is the vitriol of an authoritarian movement and the increasing condemnation from those who are appalled by it."
@GiddingsMJ @GottaLaff It is long overdue that the New York Times be held to account for Peter Baker's manipulative newssculpting BS.
@GottaLaff
That won't happen because they care more about keeping viewers than being right.
@72mz That's his point, yep

@GottaLaff Good piece, but @willbunch needs to pay attention to syntactic parallel structure.

Should be “Democratic or Republican… flawed democracy or brutal fascism.”

Going anti-parallel here undermines the thesis.

@GottaLaff "Republicans want to hang newspaper publishers from lamp posts. Democrats want to give money to indians. Voters should not let these distractions affect their vote in next year's referendum on Hunter Biden." - The Editorial Board
@GottaLaff 🤢🤮🤢🤮🤢🤮

@GottaLaff Ramaswamy utilizes an interesting variation on political theorist Carl Schmitt's Friend/Enemy Distinction. In the NSDAP's application in Third Reich Germany, it was argued that by getting rid of all the Others (Jew, communist, Roma, gay, etc.), society would be made great again as the problems are specifically caused by the existence of those Others. In a sense, purge the barrel of the bad apples and you've got nothing but greatness.

Ramaswamy's variation is even more sinister than that used by the Reich, returning to the core of distinction. By removing distinctions from our political, economic, social and legal systems, we remove the bad apples. People are prohibited from being recognized by race, gender or any other identity dynamic. "I don't see differences" becomes codified into law. Naturally, this legal blindness not only fails to impact society in general but it legalizes all forms of discrimination against Others.

Instead of centralizing fascism into the State to determine the Friend/Enemy Distinction, Ramaswamy's fascism distributes the fascist element into the atomic level of all individuals. We could appropriately regard this as Libertarian Fascism.

@GottaLaff He said something similar about climate change during the debates. He said the efforts to address climate change are cause of the problems we're facing.