Every man should watch the Barbie movie if only for the scene where Barbie and Ken first arrive in the real world and are both receiving a lot of attention, and the very different experiences they have being the object of the male gaze. It is certainly no spoiler to say there is an undercurrent of implicit violence in Barbie's experience that is completely absent from Ken's.

This is something that took me a long time to really understand as white cisgendered heterosexual man: that in every space we occupy we are an implicit threat to everyone outside of that group. And truth be told I can't fully understand it because I haven't had to live my entire life with that weight bearing down on me and that fear pulsing in my bones. What I can do is look at myself and how my presence and actions are perceived by others, regardless of how good my intentions might be.

I'm not saying that white cisgendered heterosexual men need to feel guilty about this (though we probably should a little), but we need to recognize that for us, as with everyone else, to be is to be perceived. For those of us handed privilege that we didn't deserve, that means being perceived as an instrument of that same corrupt and violent system of oppression that bestowed that privilege upon us and denied it from others. Did we ask for that privilege? No. Do we benefit from it at the expense of violence inflicted on others every single day? Absolutely.

So how do we reconcile that? We can't. It's just a bare fact. I can't say that I'm one of the good ones and exempt myself from responsibility for the damage it causes. What I can do is look at my own life and think about times when I might have made people uncomfortable, times when I was thinking more about my own experience and what I thought I was owed by women more than the woman's experience and what effect my actions had on that experience. We're all the good guy in our own head, and the protagonist of the story. We need to try to step outside of that false perspective to see the full picture.

If your first reaction to reading this is saying "not all men," you're missing the point. This is not a contest of who can be the best and most enlightened. It's just as absurd as saying "I don't have a racist bone in my body." Of course you don't, but you do have racism in your mind, I guarantee it. We are humans so by nature we are messy, flawed, contradictory creatures. For those of us with privilege it is our duty to recognize that our human flaws can have a greater effect on those around us than we might expect, because society amplifies those flaws—it has been designed to weaponize them.

We can't be perfect, so all we can do is try to do better. This is an ongoing process and not a destination. You can't work on yourself for a while and say you are done. If it feels oppressive to constantly have those second-guessing thoughts in the back of your mind, think of those who have had to live with actual oppression, second-guessing everything they do, without the luxury of ignoring those thoughts because the consequences of doing the wrong thing could be violence or death. Even if it's not always that severe, the threat is always there. Yes it's ugly. It's about the ugliest fucking thing that humans have ever created. But not looking at it isn't going to make it any prettier.

@theropologist not boosting till I've seen the movie but discourse on point.

@theropologist , I'm 6'3", and 250 lbs. I am a big guy, and can lift heavy things. I have known since I was about 18 that people get scared near me. I didn't understand this until I was older, mid 20s maybe. It changed how I acted around people... instead of being silent, I would tell a joke. I would sit more. I would wear clothing that was less intimidating. I would try to never be alone with anyone. I would smile a LOT more, even if I didn't feel like it.

It is amazing how often the smallest guy in the room would try and challenge me, still, to this day, and how often women will back away.

@theropologist @lisamelton I agree 100%. Check out “Schrödinger’s Rapist.“

(I don’t know if this URL will work. If not, just search for the title)
https://omnivore.app/shawnking/u-7-be-3316-e-1-c-40-11-ee-84-db-cb-24529176-f-3-starling-2-c-sc-1892d03e6fb

@theropologist As a non-White cisgendered male, I feel like I'm in the middle of the road. I get the threat from white cisgendered males, but still remain a threat to women and others. That helps me to understand a little bit when I pass it down.

@ned @theropologist

You don’t ‘remain a threat’ if you are open, friendly, and act like a person meeting another person rather than looking and sizing them up for ‘use’. To approach people in a kindly, accepting way removes the sense of ‘threat’. Of course evil, violent people can do the same. It’s a testament to this society that so many are so traumatized they can trust no one and nothing. We must try not to let that happen by keeping actions supportive, by listening, by helping, by respect.

@NoctisEqui @ned @theropologist I wish that were so, however most women have experienced the “I’m just a nice non threatening guy and the minute you let your guard down my real goal will become clear” act.
Many predators have been described as appearing charming , non threatening , and friendly by victims.
@theropologist
Men are afraid women will laugh at them.
Women are afraid men will kill them.
@theropologist I thought of that #Barbie line today, after a (white) man started banging on the shopwindow of the café where I was, holding a small noose he had made. He insisted aggressively pointing at me and pointing at it, stayed banging for 10 minutes. Did it to other women in the place too, not to men. When I left 90 min later he was outside waiting, shouting 'now people know what I am capable of'. And I knew full well he was. No man gave a shit, all women scared. UK today, #patriarchy.
@sheislaurence @theropologist Yeah, men see other men harass women & do nothing about it every single day. Fuck the patriarchy!
@theropologist are there stripes on your back from self flagellating yourself ?
@violinguy @theropologist
He's proven to be a master contortionist by the way he's able to kiss his own ass.
@TheCannonball @violinguy @theropologist It's always great when you guys out yourself so deftly, and I know exactly whom to block.

@theropologist

Another perspective: in every space men occupy, men ALSO HAVE AN implicit AUDIENCE with everyone outside of that group.

The stats on any of my posts compared to what you have acquired on this are disheartening.

I share stories about motherhood, what I believe is God's unique way of connecting with each individual, & the beauty that brings to life, which includes #synchronicity I've been able to document. But no one responds.

Enjoy all of the continued support, sympathy, & camaraderie.

@ceejaedevine I posted this specifically because I've been told by friends that are not white men that men should speak about this, and I've shared similar sentiments with them privately. I've also been grappling with this issue personally as the admin of an instance who's trying to make a safe space for vulnerable communities. I am not looking for numbers here. I'm just sharing my perspective. I also recognize the importance of listening to perspectives of those who are not granted undeserved privelege, which is why I was reticent to post this in the first place.

@theropologist
I refuse to feel guilt for being a white male. That's fucking dumb and short sighted. No one should feel bad for the circumstances of their birth or heritage.

Instead, I feel empathy for people affected by a male dominated world and work towards undoing the harm it could cause to future generations.

@TheCannonball you're literally making the same argument as me but choosing to be an asshole about it. Enjoy the block.
@TheCannonball @theropologist I agree. We shouldn't feel guilt of who we are. Instead, we should support those who are in need. That is better than feeling guilt of who we are. Who we are is who we are, we don't choose how to be born, so no, guilt is not the answer. Because guilt can play a huge role into how we feel about things. It can make us hate ourselves but there's no base for it. So instead of promoting how people should feel guilt for what they were born into or who they are born as, we could promote tolerance and understanding towards those who choose different paths in who they are. Nobody should feel guilty or ashamed of who they are.
@theropologist Well this toot was super handy to weed out all the butt hurt narcissist dudes who can't have something not be about them for even one movie.

@theropologist Timely.

Fuming tonight because I enjoy pool from time to time at an established POOL bar to focus on something other than this profoundly sick society. The regulars know to give players space, but some entitled white dudes showed up and after I explained that they should watch out for players not the other way around, I got death stares. If I were male, they would make room. It’s 2023, FFS, and I refuse to roll back to 1950. 🤨

@theropologist

Thanks for saying all that. I agree and feel the same.

I would love to hear responses from black and brown people, although their response might be that they have better things to do than educate us.

@theropologist

As a white guy I understand emotionally exactly what you are saying. Many people, races, tribes around the world have committed horrible crimes towards others, but the white race, in my opinion, was and still is globally the worst bad actor. Now, as a white US citizen should you feel personal guilt for the genocide of indigenous Americans and the enslavement of Africans committed by your forefathers? NO! However, should you feel responsability? YES!

After WW2, the democratic German government assumed responsability for the hate crimes commited by the German NAZI Regime against Jews, and other minorities. They paid reparations to individuals and Israel, made "NAZI free speech" a crime, and teach still today students in words and images/films about the NAZI crimes, for example.

Apart from the US government, every white US citizen can show responsability not only for the crimes of the past, but today when racism especially against African Americans is still rampant. Being sympathetic is not enough! Show that you are an anit-racist by action.

Racism is one of many forms of discrimination which began 5000 years ago with the enslavement of women by greedy men. I shall add here a part of an earlier toot I made about toxic masculinity.

5000 years of patriarchy have not only made women slaves but have also left traumatic injuries in the psyche of many men. However, while women fight for their equality and freedom with increasing success, many men are still locked in rituals of toxic masculinity. The global patriarchy, i.e., capitalist economy with "democratic" or autocratic administration, causes more and more war and environmental destruction of the human habitat. There is already talk of the danger of human extinction. Whether it is possible to stop this "journey of mankind on the way to hell" (Gutierrez, UN) depends finally on most men in all countries, whether they can emancipate themselves from their toxic masculinity, i.e., to focus primarily on COOPERATION instead of COMPETITION.
This could start with men who are friends, for example, sitting down to talk about their role fears, relationship problems and professional competition. Just like in AA groups, learn to open, and talk about your own typical "male problems" with the aim of breaking free from patriarchal role constraints, learning to socialize cooperatively with women and other men. If you want to save humanity from extinction, the best place to start is with yourself by freeing yourself from destructive, oppressive behaviors.

So, to become an anti-patriarchal, white, ciswhatsoever man, you can really do a lot about getting there, to become a Mensch.

Love and peace
😘❤️🙏🏽
@theropologist Thank you. You reminded me of my own realization of what my mere presence means for women. I, a large cishet white guy, was walking behind a woman one night after working late. She abruptly changed course. I followed. She ran to a security guard. I wasn't following her. I was playing Pokemon Go and only pieced this together later. Me being carefree and her afraid for her safety. I try to remember this and that it's not enough to not intend harm.
@theropologist the one thing I might add to this is the high degree of homoeroticism to the Kenergy. While it’s making the sociological point you call out, Ken is also being cruised on a gay beach, although “chastely” in the way that homoeroticism is sublimated into ritualized violence and performance.