I've been pondering the posts by @kissane and @siderea about 'not finding your people' #OnHere and am wondering if sentiments toward fediverse-wide #FullTextSearch have shifted at all. I know this has been implemented several times, and then been graciously shut down by developers who listened to community feedback.
#Mastodon #Fulltext #Search
From US - want opt-out fulltext search
37.3%
From US - DO NOT want opt-out fulltext search
13.6%
From Europe - want opt-out fulltext search
33.1%
From Europe - DO NOT want opt-out fulltext search
16.1%
Poll ended at .
@siderea @kissane @krohne what the hell's wrong with opt-*in* full-text search
I think opt-in search is great. I have signed up for @buercher's #TootFinder, but few people have. What if something like that was the default search in the UI, and people were encouraged opt-in when they signed up?

@krohne enshrining some third-party rando in the signup flow is not the way to do this.

the way to do this is to have a standard way to explicitly mark posts as searchable, the same way that Mastodon and several other Fedi servers already have a `discoverable` flag that explicitly marks accounts as searchable. that way, *any* search engine has a way of knowing what people have volunteered for.

https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon/pull/23808 unfortunately, the effort to patch this into Mastodon has stalled out.

Add setting to explicitly consent to full-text search indexing of public posts by ClearlyClaire ยท Pull Request #23808 ยท mastodon/mastodon

NOTE: This PR does not implement the search functionality itself, just a framework to express explicit consent for posts to be indexed Mastodon has historically refused to provide full-text search ...

GitHub

@krohne if we don't build something like this, "is this post set to public visibility" is the only intent signal to work with, and searching all public posts surprises Mastodon users.

(and only Mastodon users. "public = searchable" is the rule for full-text search implementations on most other Fedi servers that have it, except for GotoSocial.)

@krohne UX-wise, agreed that there should be an opt-in button in the signup flow. you should be able to switch this on easily. but it should never be switched on for you.