I only really have a single gripe with #dnd #5e. Sure, it's not perfect, but basically all #ttrpgs have their issues.

My problem is simple: #dnd is the most famous #ttrpg out there... and it's terrible for new players. You literally need an existing expert to teach you the ropes.

There are way too many mistakes you can make as a player, and basically no guidance for the DM. We all know that the encounter balance is terrible, but new DMs don't.

A bunch of friends all deciding they want to try #roleplaying for the first time and picking up D&D is the easiest way to have them quickly burn out and decide "it's not for us".

So when I find people that are interested in #ttrpgs, and I can't personally GM for them, I recommend the following games:

1. Edge's #StarWars rpg game (used to be Fantasy Flight's). The Beginner Boxes are absolutely insane, it's a very popular IP and since it's not DnD it doesnt get as polluted by any preconceived notions they might have about what #ttrpgs are supposed to be about (I've legit had people said they didn't want to play DnD cause they didn't know much medieval history...)

2. #Fate Accelerated: super tiny booklet that the GM can understand in a single afternoon. Simple mechanics. The good thing about this option is they are immediately playing a "full" game. Still wish there was a beginner box or beginnner game sort of thing. If you know of one, let me know!

3. #Pathfinder2e, which usually just happens when they really really want something like D&D... and #pf2e has an amazing Beginner Box! I also find the 3-action system very intuitive for players that have like played a videogame. Once. Ever. And encounters being balanced makes it less likely the #GM has an aneurysm.

So when I get asked what I want from #onednd... I just want a good Beginner Box! And tools so that DMs don't end up crying after their epic boss falls in a single round...

I just want people that come to the hobby saying "I've heard of D&D!" to be able to play...

@Kenan in my experience #pf2e is vastly easier to run than 5e was despite being a more complicated game. The consistency of the rules and the keywords especially make it a lot easier to be consistent with rulings.

@Robbydigital I agree, in general I would say that anytime anyone wants to play 5e they actually just really want to play #pf2e and just don't know it yet... I have a hard time coming up with a real reason to ever play DnD once you know any other #ttrpg... it makes me so sad that "the most popular rpg" is just so inadequate compared to the general ecosystem. It becomes a terrible gatekeeper that drives people away from the hobby through bad experiences...

And I think I'm ranting now 😆, stopping before I go too far 😜

@Kenan I can't say I agree with the first sentiment. I would think that while it is true that a lot of the people who have been kicking around the sister for a while and who have houseruled it to death probably want 2e even if they don't realize it. I think a very substantial portion of the 5e player audience probably wants a narrative system or something else that is super lightweight with fantasy trappings.