I never thought I'd see the day where I agree with Oracle on some #opensource matter more than Red Hat, but, well... https://www.oracle.com/news/announcement/blog/keep-linux-open-and-free-2023-07-10/

@geerlingguy I had to add to the thread just to say I feel ya! Your sentiment is exactly mine!

I still wouldn't say Oracle are good guys, but in this instance, yes

#oracle #redhat #linux #opensource

@mlippert @geerlingguy While #redhat may have completely bungled their message, having listened to some of their reasoning, it doesn't actually sound that anti- #opensource.

It sounds like they mainly want people to just use their upstream directly, instead of taking their curated release and having to strip out all the branding/etc. I think all that's added to #redhat is specific version pinning/testing and branding -- if that's the case, #oracle is just piling on misinformation.

@freelock @mlippert @geerlingguy

Red Hat add some code and Branding to the Linux kernel, makes RHEL. That's ok.
Alma/Rocky makes a RHEL flavour. That's not ok?

That's like taking free food from a public food bank, labelling it as your original product while not distributing it to those in need and then selling it for a profit instead.

I *had* a lot of respect for Red Hat.

@abhijit @mlippert @geerlingguy What I've heard is they want people to fork off CentOS Stream instead of RHEL -- and they're not adding any code to RHEL that isn't already in CentOS Stream.

In any case I don't have a horse in this race, I don't use RHEL and don't care that much -- and generally I don't like seeing IBM taking over RedHat, or any of the long term changes that we'll probably see as a result -- but I do think the reaction to this is a bit overblown.