Back when I was working on the board of the CBLDF I got very used to the idea of material for adults being challenged by people who thought comics were for children. The idea of books aimed at children being challenged just because they had positive black characters was unimaginable. The world's changed.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/comics/2023/04/08/jerry-craft-new-kid-school-trip-book-ban/
Jerry Craft drew a positive Black story. Then the calls for a ban began.

The celebrated author of “New Kid,” a graphic novel aimed at young readers, was caught off guard when his books started showing up on lists of inappropriate material.

The Washington Post
@neilhimself I would love the opportunity to interview you one day on any topic for https://youtube.com/@traversingthestars
Traversing the Stars

Entertainment podcast with a Sci Fi vibe! Reviews, discussions, and lots of interviews from around the entertainment industry! Hosted by Jeff Haas

YouTube
@neilhimself Earlier this year, schools in our district in Alabama canceled visits of a best selling Black children’s author, Derrick Barnes, with vague explanations (lies). This was during Black History Month. Most of the parents were pissed!
@neilhimself We just packed up my wife's classroom library yesterday, maybe 400 novels (edit: kid says 40+ per box x 20 boxes, they counted), based on official guidance from more than one direction. State law here is specific to sexual content but nebulous in nature, and parents are challenging books based on things outside the law, enough that the risks are just too great for our family.

The books could be kept on the shelves if:

  • a list is provided to parents, opening teachers to attack and lawsuits from previous exposure
  • the books are reviewed for content, but the language in the law allows for differences in opinion to turn into lawsuits against both the district and the teacher
  • a permission slip is signed for a student to read a specific book

Under cover of night, Romeo (age 16) and Juliet (age 13) consummate their marriage. Hard not to admit it includes "content involving human reproduction or sexual matters" when the price of failure is a felony. If adopted curriculum (Gatsby, Mockingbird, 1984, Giver, Outsiders), stuff read by most students in US public schools over the last 40 years isn't considered safe anymore, modern young adult fiction doesn't stand a chance. 📚💔

@knapjack I can also imagine “Black Like Me,” “Shane,” and “Old Yeller” making the list, given the vagueness of the law. Anything of an English poet dealing with passion would be out as well, Chaucer’s “Canterbury Tales” is obviously a non-starter, as would “Beowulf.” Shameful. How can anyone become exposed to literature at this rate? @neilhimself
@IanAMartin @knapjack @neilhimself the people promoting these laws consider that a feature, not a bug.

@mwyman Alas, yes.

“Reading gives people ideas! Where will THAT lead‽ They might end-up doing ANYTHING!!” To which I would reply ‘yes, that’s the point’ and send them into further panic. @knapjack @neilhimself

@IanAMartin @mwyman @knapjack @neilhimself

A few folks around here always challenge the Bible to be banned every time they talk about banning books based on some BS rule.

@duckunix Were there bibles in the classrooms or school libraries before?
@GreenSkyOverMe The libraries will have copies. And, yes, public US schools...

@mwyman @IanAMartin @knapjack @neilhimself

Keeping people too overworked, underpaid, sick, without birth control, and uneducated to stand AGAINST the system is the goal.

@knapjack @neilhimself

Might I add that the bible, biology books, national geographic, encyclopedias and other books are now in contempt by this standard.

But, this was never about being correct- it was about making people happy. But no one ever was- nor will be.

@lucifargundam @knapjack @neilhimself Here's a crazy thought: how about, if you don't like a book/don't want your child to read a book ... just don't read it/make it available to them... BUT... if the book is required reading for school then you read it with your child, and have a discussion with them about what you find objectionable or concerning

@rmquist @knapjack @neilhimself

When there were adult magazines in my household, I found them and 'read' them without permission. I was told not to read them, but did so anyway. They didn't make them go away.

When my guardians eventually realized that there was no stopping my exposure to things they didn't want me to be around, they begrudgingly had to step up and start talking to me about various subjects on a case by case basis.

@rmquist @lucifargundam @knapjack @neilhimself ah, but that would expose them to different ideas and viewpoints and possible attempts at empathy and christians just can't have that.
@FlorriePuddlefoot @lucifargundam @knapjack @neilhimself What so many "christians" fail to remember is that Christianity was founded on ideas and viewpoints that differed from the "establishment" ... not the least of which is to love one another... and you can't truly love what you don't know...

@rmquist

Nah! It's much easier to just have a fit and have the book banned so no one can even mention it to their child.

@lucifargundam @knapjack @neilhimself

@Catmama @lucifargundam @knapjack @neilhimself I wish I could disagree with you...but I don't like being wrong 😄 It's part of the "if we don't acknowledge it, it doesn't exist" school of parenting....
@rmquist @lucifargundam @knapjack @neilhimself and you know, I had a great time listening to audio books with my sons and discussing the books. We listened to Starship Troopers and The Forever War and talked about the differing views of war. We listened to Frankenstein and talked about what it meant to be human. Books are a wonderful way to connect with people!

@FlorriePuddlefoot @rmquist @knapjack @neilhimself

Imagine that- having civil discussions as a means to understand and get along with each other...

@knapjack @neilhimself It is literally the future evangelicals want.
@neilhimself @knapjack supposedly this is to keep us all safe from totalitarian communism or something
@knapjack @neilhimself Exposing myself to culture made me a target of religious violence, when I was little. Why should we be surprised this is happening, when we’re letting religious extremists take more authority than they had then? They always wanted these books out of schools, right down to the Mark Twain.
@knapjack @neilhimself I can't help thinking 'Fahrenheit 451' by Ray Bradbury, while not a YA novel, must be removed for being too 'meta'.
@knapjack @neilhimself that is heartbreaking and infuriating. I am very sorry for her, and the kids who are being cheated.

@knapjack @neilhimself

Starting to think the US is punking the rest of the world. But we know you can't be living the plot of Fahrenheit 451

@knapjack @neilhimself

..." isn't considered safe anymore" ...dont buy in

The is no consideration, this is a fascist attack on speech and people, deciding for everyone what they are allowed to say, read, dress, how to be in the world.

Times havent "changed" this is an assault, an attack. And those that can must resist this assault unto stopping the State from functioning.

@knapjack @neilhimself

I like voting and collective bargaining. Protect the weak.

@knapjack @neilhimself Interesting! What state is this (if you don't mind my asking)?

@knapjack @neilhimself @EriogonumDarwin

Makes me want to finally start one of those Little Free Libraries that I see here and there.

@KristinKim @knapjack @neilhimself @EriogonumDarwin I've actually wondered already what the legal status of the Little Free Library would be in this not so Brave New World. (Afraid New World?) Given that they're fining people for feeding the poor, I suspect they will be illegal as soon as the bigots learn about them.

@spotrick @knapjack @neilhimself @EriogonumDarwin

I considered this as well, but I will not refrain from action out of fear of the ‘might be someday’

If it happens, I can just take it down… and come up with a Plan C.

@knapjack @neilhimself Texas, Florida and the rest of the Stupid States will soon pass laws forbidding people to keep those books in their own homes.
And yet, Christian birth rates are still dropping, partly due to porn.
Fuck hypocrites. … no no don’t do that. They only beget more hypocrites.
@knapjack @neilhimself What lunacy. Banning books only makes kids more likely to want to read them. And it isn’t about what’s safe or proper, it’s about someone proving they have power to impose their will on others.
@knapjack @neilhimself Brave New World is toast, right?
@knapjack @neilhimself This is really sad, when the only way one can keep people interested in one's own views is by suppressing any other thought, belief, or viewpoint. Free markets apparently do not apply to ideas.
@knapjack @neilhimself
If a parent doesn't want his kid to read something ok. But he should not have the right to keep my kids from reading books. Scary direction this country is going in
@[email protected] @neilhimself the US political right is trying hard to bring about a new Dark Ages, in which the only book anyone is allowed to read is the Bible.
@zakalwe I expect the Bible would be next, in that scenario. Allowing the general public access to the Bible was controversial for centuries, and probably still is in some circles. Catholicism did Not Like it when the printing press opened up their religious texts.
@knapjack @neilhimself The Bible can be banned if anyone complains about its sexual content and violent nature. That will happen soon enough...
@knapjack @neilhimself I take pleasure in remembering the excitement of finding well-written racey novels on my parents' bookshelves and devouring them - especially the juiciest bits - over and over and over again. Names of authors escape me, but seriously, isn't this an important part of our critical rites of passage toward healthy human development? Those authors were probably Updike and Conrad and Heller. I don't even remember, but the content was a formative part of my development.

@knapjack @neilhimself The truly idiotic thing about school book banning is that most kids could not care less because they get their content from the Internet.

I can't wait for the moral panicky parents to figure this out.

I predict they are going to force schools to allow only specific websites and block all others, making the castrated Internet a useless resource for learning.

But the kids still will not care because they have mobile phones.

@paulrichwine

A castrated internet has been a thing in some schools for years.

@knapjack @neilhimself

@knapjack @neilhimself Do have to laugh somewhat in that the most hard core stuff these days is in video game stories, streamed series, and the content in various online platforms. It’s like there is no idea what life is like for youth today. Banning books is almost laughable (and they are also online).

@knapjack @neilhimself I keep thinking, any day now, the cognitive dissonance between American celebration of Liberty and Freedom versus the new Puritanism, loading on more and more regulation and restrictions, from books to bodily autonomy, is going to make conservative heads explode. 😞

I guess when a single judge can invalidate the medically well researched work of the FDA, there are no limits. Stick a fork in America, it's done.

@knapjack @neilhimself So Fahrenheit 451 was the correct dystopia after all?
@knapjack
I hope you and your family are safe and remain so. Your post is heartbreaking and to this obviously "sheltered" Aussie, it doesn't make any sense at all.
@panisuze @knapjack its weird isnt it. I wonder if we ban books in Oz? I’ve never heard of it. Although I could imagine Aussies going well you can stick that rule where the sun dont shine.
@panisuze Thank you. We are safe, but it's hard to believe, and hard to explain to our teen, who is flabbergasted.

And my wife, who has been teaching since 1995, appalled and disheartened and all of the above. And half of her students have seen Cocaine Bear, so the fervor over novels is as ridiculous as it is dangerous.

It reminds me of something a friend told me maybe 20 years ago about an Afghan kid he had in his history class. Their family fled Afghanistan years before, the mom had been a surgeon, and like a Handmaid's Tale nightmare progressively saw her rights being taken away over a short period of time: couldn't work, girls couldn't go to school, etc. They were wealthy enough and took action early enough to leave, but couldn't fathom how it could possibly happen.

I feel like we're in the middle of that train wreck here, asking ourselves what that strange noise is.

@knapjack @neilhimself

" .. and here there's a picture of the Monna Lisa " SEXUAL !
" .. he gave her a goodnight kiss .. " SEXUAL !
" little Red riding hood meets the wolf " SEXUAL !
" you can see here how two USB connectors mate .. " SEXUAL ( uses the word "mate" )
" .. the coupling of the gears ... " SEXUAL
" .. these two prime numbers form a pair .. " SEXUAL !
" .. the word 'Libro' is of male gender .. " SEXUAL !

Lawyers' feast all over the places I suppose ...

@knapjack @neilhimself I hope the bible was the first book packed away.
@DavidNicol Coincidentally, it was @neilhimself's Norse Mythology, which was a Battle of the Books book this year. Loki turns into a mare, gets pregnant. You know, mythology stuff.

But someone already played the bible card in Utah: https://www.sltrib.com/news/education/2023/03/22/utah-parent-says-bible-contains/