In 1791, the Second Amendment was written.
In 1847, the bullet was invented.
Thus, the Second Amendment only applies to muskets.
In 1791, the Second Amendment was written.
In 1847, the bullet was invented.
Thus, the Second Amendment only applies to muskets.
@DavidBFox @Strandjunker
Probably cannons, too. And catapults? You know like from LoTR where they launch big rocks at each other?
I mean we could lug around cannonballs and cannons, right?
Second Amendment! 'Murica!
@JJPeterson
I've been saying for years, written to my House Rep, talked face to face with my State House Rep about the concept of taxing ammo exorbitantly.
Tax a box of ammo an insane amount of money but if you can show via an endorsement on your state issued ID that you have taken a gun safety class, the tax is lifted at purchase.
It wouldn't be hard to implement at all.
@Strandjunker
@Strandjunker Also - the word "own" appears nowhere in the 2A. Neither "keep" nor "bear" equals "own" in a contract - and the Constitution is the basis for our contract law.
There is not now nor has there ever been the right for any individual to own a firearm. Per the 2A, they all belong to the well regulated militia (now called the National Guard) who gets to decide who "keeps" and "bears" them until the militia says "give em back and go home".
@Strandjunker You don't even need that.
"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State..."
The state militias organized for the purpose of national security (in a time when the standing military was due to be disbanded) was renamed the National Guard in 1903.
Thus, the 2nd Amendment applies only to the National Guard.
Furthermore, we now provide them with guns. So the whole thing is obsolete.
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/justice-burger-2nd-amendment-meme/
@Strandjunker Your clever dismantling of the "originalist" arguments around the 2nd amendment does not take into account the fact that the originalists know they're full of sh*t and don't care.
It's pure, unadulterated nihilism in pursuit of power.
@Strandjunker I'm not American but i still can't fathom how all of this mess can be called "a well regulated militia". "Conceal carry without a permit for everyone" seems to stretch the meaning quite a bit.
It's really as if words didn't matter at all.