The Empty Leaderboard
2,530 words, 13 minutes read time.
Mark Holloway felt the heat of the stage lights on his neck, but for the first time in his life, it didnât feel like a spotlight of judgment. It felt like a cleansing fire. He stayed in that embrace with Chris for a long momentâlong enough for the silence in the room to turn from awkward to heavy, and finally, to something holy. When he pulled back, he saw that Chris wasnât the âLakefront Kingâ he had built him up to be in his mind. Chris looked exhausted. There were dark circles under his eyes that no Instagram filter could have hidden if Mark had been looking for them instead of looking for reasons to feel inferior.
âMark,â Chris whispered, his voice barely audible over the hum of the cooling fans in the ceiling. âThat lake photo? That was the only ten minutes of that entire weekend we werenât screaming at each other. My oldest son told me he hates me on the drive home. I spent the last three nights sleeping on the couch because I donât know how to talk to my wife anymore. I saw you walk in every Sunday and I thought, âThereâs Holloway. Heâs got that quiet, steady strength. I wish I was that composed.'â
Mark felt a dry, ironic laugh bubble up in his chest. âWeâve been haunting each other, Chris. Weâve been living in each otherâs shadows, and the shadows arenât even real.â
The pastor, a man named Miller who usually kept a tight grip on the âorder of service,â didnât move toward the microphone. He stayed in the front row, his head bowed, his shoulders shaking slightly. The âprogramâ had officially died, and in its place, something raw was breathing. Mark looked back at the stageâthe mahogany lectern, the expensive lighting, the 4K screens. It all looked like cardboard now. It was all just scaffolding for the real work happening on the floor.
Mark turned toward the rest of the men. He didnât go back to the microphone. He didnât need the ten thousand watts anymore. âI used to think that being a âMan of Godâ meant being a man of answers,â he said, his natural voice carrying through the hushed rows. âI thought it meant having the firmest grip and the most certain spirit. But look at us. Weâre a room full of experts on things that donât matter and novices on the things that do. We know the stats of players who donât know we exist, but we donât know the fears of the man sitting six inches away from us.â
A man in the back, someone Mark recognized as a high-powered attorney named Steven, stood up. Steven was known for his sharp suits and an even sharper tongue in committee meetings. He wasnât wearing a suit tonight. He was wearing a faded polo shirt, and he looked smaller than Mark remembered.
âIâve spent forty thousand dollars on a kitchen remodel I didnât need because I wanted my brother to be jealous,â Steven said, his voice cracking. âAnd my daughter hasnât looked me in the eye in six months because Iâm never home to eat in that kitchen. Iâm a success in the courtroom and a stranger in my own hallway. I look at all of you and I feel like Iâm wearing a costume.â
One by one, the âHolloway Effectâ began to ripple through the pews. It wasnât a landslide; it was a slow, steady breaking of a dam. These werenât the polished testimonies you hear on a Sunday morningâthe ones where the struggle is safely in the past tense and wrapped in a neat bow. These were âpresent tenseâ confessions.
Mark sat down on the edge of the stage, his legs dangling over the side. He felt a strange sense of peace watching the hierarchy of the church evaporate. The âAlphaâ guys, the âQuietâ guys, the âSuccessâ stories, and the âStrugglingâ cases were all bleeding into a single, unified color: human.
He thought about his houseâthe one with the mortgage that felt like a collar around his neck. He thought about the SUV with the French fry in the seat crack. He thought about the regional account he didnât get. For years, those things had been the metrics of his soul. If the account was up, Mark was up. If the house needed a repair he couldnât afford, Mark was âbroken.â He had tied his identity to a set of moving targets, and he was exhausted from the chase.
âYou know,â Mark said, catching the attention of a younger guy in the front row who looked like he was about to bolt for the exit out of sheer vulnerability-overload. âThe hardest thing I ever had to do wasnât admitting I failed. It was admitting that even if I succeeded, it wouldnât be enough. Weâre all trying to fill a canyon with pebbles. We think if we just get a bigger pebbleâa faster car, a better title, a more âspiritualâ reputationâthe hole will go away. But the hole is infinite. And the only thing that fits in an infinite hole is an infinite grace.â
He looked at his hands. They were the hands of a middle-manager. They were soft in some places, calloused in others. They werenât the hands of a warrior or a titan of industry. They were just Markâs hands.
âI spent my whole life wanting to be David,â he mused, referring to the biblical king. âBut I think Iâm actually just one of the guys in the army who was hiding in the trenches because Goliath looked too big. And the irony is, I was hiding from you guys too. I thought if you saw my fear, youâd leave me behind. I didnât realize you were in the trench next to me, just as terrified, watching me to see if Iâd run first.â
The atmosphere in the room had shifted from a âconferenceâ to a âhospital.â The fluorescent hum of the lobby seemed miles away. Here, under the dimming stage lights, there was a sense of heavy, honest brotherhood that Mark had spent forty years looking for and forty seconds finding once he stopped lying.
He stood up again, but this time he walked toward the back of the room. He wanted to get away from the âMain Stageâ entirely. He wanted to be on the level ground. He passed David, the man with the truck, who reached out and gripped Markâs forearm. David didnât say anything, but the look in his eyes was a silent âthank you.â It was the look of a man who had been given permission to stop holding his breath.
Mark reached the back doors, the heavy oak handles cool to the touch. He turned back one last time to look at the room. The men were no longer sitting in neat rows. They were gathered in small clusters, talking, some with hands on each otherâs shoulders, some just sitting in a shared, comfortable silence. The âLeaderboardâ was gone. The âHighlight Reelâ had been edited down to the raw footage.
âIâm going home,â Mark whispered to himself.
But home didnât feel like a place he had to perform for anymore. Home was just the next stop on a journey where he didnât have to be anyone but Mark Holloway. He pushed the doors open, the cool night air hitting him like a physical blessing.
The cool night air was sharp, smelling of rain and the distant scent of pine mulch from the churchâs landscaping. Mark stood on the sidewalk for a moment, letting the silence of the parking lot wash over him. The gravel crunched under his feet as he walked toward his SUVâthe silver crossover he had spent so many years despising because it wasnât something else.
As he reached for the door handle, he heard the heavy thud of the sanctuary doors opening behind him. He turned to see Jim, the group leader with the booming charisma, stepping out into the light of the entryway. Jim looked different without the pulpit in front of him. He looked smaller, his shoulders slightly hunched against the chill.
âMark! Wait up,â Jim called out. He jogged down the concrete steps, his breath blooming in the air like small, white ghosts. When he reached Mark, he didnât offer a handshake or a pat on the back. He just stood there, looking at the silver SUV.
âIâve lived in this town for fifteen years,â Jim said softly. âIâve led this group for five. And tonight was the first time I felt like I wasnât the only one in the room who didnât have a clue what he was doing.â
Mark leaned against his car door. âYou too, Jim? I figured you had a direct line. You always look like youâve got the next five years mapped out.â
Jim let out a short, hollow laugh. âMark, I spend my Tuesday afternoons rehearsing my âspontaneousâ prayers in the shower so I donât sound like an idiot. I stay up until two in the morning wondering if Iâm just a professional Christian whoâs lost the plot. When you got up there and talked about the leaderboard⊠I realized Iâm the one who built the leaderboard. I thought that was my job. To keep everyone climbing.â
âItâs a long way down,â Mark said, not unkindly.
âIt is,â Jim agreed. âBut the air is better down here, isnât it?â
They stood in silence for a minute, two men in a parking lot, no longer defined by their titles or their perceived successes. Jim reached out and squeezed Markâs shoulder. âSee you Sunday, Mark. And hey⊠donât worry about the parking spot next to Davidâs truck. He told me heâs selling it tomorrow. Heâs going back to a sedan so he can start paying off his kidâs tuition.â
Mark watched Jim walk to his own car, then he climbed into the driverâs seat of his SUV. He didnât turn on the radio. He didnât check his phone for notifications. He just sat in the dark. He reached down and picked up the lone, shriveled French fry from the consoleâthe tiny, greasy monument to his âmediocreâ life. He looked at it for a second and then tossed it into the small trash bag hanging from the dash. It was a small act of cleaning, a minor order in the chaos.
The drive home felt shorter than usual. He wasnât racing the phantom cars of his imagination. He wasnât rehearsing the speech heâd give his boss to explain why the regional account was better off with the younger guy. He just drove. He noticed the way the streetlights reflected in the puddles, the way the neighborhood houses looked warm and yellow in the dark.
When he pulled into his driveway, he saw the light in the living room was still on. He saw the shadow of his wife, Sarah, moving past the window. Usually, this was the moment the âMaskâ went on. He would straighten his posture, wipe the exhaustion from his face, and prepare to be the âStandard-Issue Husband.â
But tonight, Mark Holloway stayed in the car for a moment longer. He looked at his reflection in the rearview mirror. He saw a man who was tired, yes, but he also saw a man who was finally, undeniably real. He thought about his son, Leo, and the bike chain that needed fixing. He thought about the daughter who was becoming a stranger and the wife who deserved to know the man she actually married, not the one he was trying to be.
He opened the garage door, the motor groaning with a familiar, domestic rhythm. He walked through the mudroom, kicking off his sneakers. The house smelled like laundry detergent and the taco seasoning from dinner.
Sarah was on the couch, a book open in her lap. She looked up as he walked in, her eyes searching his face with that intuitive, terrifyingly accurate âwife-radar.â
âHow was the meeting?â she asked, her voice soft. âWas it the usual? Coffee and a âbe a better manâ lecture?â
Mark walked over to the couch. He didnât stand over her. He sat down on the floor by her feet, leaning his back against the cushions. It was a position of vulnerability, of being âless thanâ in a way that felt entirely right.
âNo,â Mark said, reaching up to take her hand. âIt wasnât that at all. I think⊠I think I finally quit my job today.â
Sarahâs eyes widened, her hand tensing in his. âThe firm? Mark, we canâtââ
âNo, not the firm,â he interrupted, turning to look at her. âI quit the other job. The one where I try to be everyone else. Iâm just going to be me for a while. Is that okay? It might be a little messy. I might not have the best truck in the lot or the most polished prayer in the room.â
Sarah looked at him for a long beat, her expression softening into something Mark hadnât seen in yearsâa look of pure, uncomplicated relief. She reached down and ran her fingers through his thinning hair.
âMark Holloway,â she whispered. âIâve been waiting for that guy to come home for a decade.â
Upstairs, a floorboard creaked. Leo was probably awake, sneaking a book under the covers. Tomorrow, there would be bills to pay. Tomorrow, the younger guy would start the regional account. Tomorrow, the world would still be full of leaderboards and highlight reels.
But as Mark sat there on the floor, his wifeâs hand in his and the weight of the world finally off his shoulders, he knew he wasnât afraid of tomorrow anymore. He had found the one thing that no amount of competition could provide: he had been found out, and he was still loved.
The leaderboard was gone. The race was over. And for the first time in his life, Mark Holloway was exactly where he wanted to be. He was home.
Authorâs Note
This story is for the man sitting in his driveway with the engine idling, staring at the garage door and wondering when the hell heâs finally going to feel like heâs âarrived.â
Weâve all been sold a lie. Weâve been told that manhood is a ladder, and if you arenât climbing, youâre suffocating. We walk into our churches, our offices, and our gyms with our chests out and our secrets locked in the basement, terrified that if the guy next to us sees a single dent in our armor, weâre finished. We spend our lives comparing our raw, unedited internal disasters to the polished, high-definition highlight reels of everyone else.
Mark Holloway is the guy in the mirror. Heâs the man who realized that the âLeaderboardâ he was killing himself to climb was actually a gallows. He finally understood that you canât be loved if you refuse to be known, and you canât be known if youâre too busy pretending to be a goddamn superhero.
Stop looking at the guy in the next lane. Stop measuring your worth by the badge on your grille or the title on your door. As it says in Galatians 6:4:
âEach one should test their own actions. Then they can take pride in themselves alone, without comparing themselves to someone else.â
This story is a punch in the mouth to the âSunday Morning Mask.â Itâs a reminder that the most masculine thing you will ever do isnât winning a fight or closing a dealâitâs having the stones to drop the shield and tell the truth.
The race is a scam, brothers. Step off the track. The only person youâre supposed to outrun is the fake version of yourself youâve been dragging around for years. Go inside. Be real. Be home.
Call to Action
If this story struck a chord, donât just scroll on. Join the brotherhoodâmen learning to build, not borrow, their strength. Subscribe for more stories like this, drop a comment about where youâre growing, or reach out and tell me what youâre working toward. Letâs grow together.
D. Bryan King
Sources
Disclaimer:
The views and opinions expressed in this post are solely those of the author. The information provided is based on personal research, experience, and understanding of the subject matter at the time of writing. Readers should consult relevant experts or authorities for specific guidance related to their unique situations.
#authenticBrotherhood #beingKnown #biblicalManhood #breakingSilence #breakingTheMask #ChristianBrotherhood #ChristianLiving #ChristianMenSFiction #ChristianMenSGroup #ChristianMentalHealth #ChristianResilience #churchBasementStories #churchCommunity #churchCulture #churchFellowship #churchSmallGroups #churchStageStories #competitiveSpirituality #emotionalHonesty #faithAndFamily #faithBasedStorytelling #fatherhoodAndFaith #FatherhoodStruggles #findingSelfWorth #Galatians64 #graceVsPerformance #healingThroughHonesty #heartOverAppearance #honestFaith #identityInChrist #lettingGoOfPride #livingWithoutComparison #maleComparison #maleLoneliness #malePeerPressure #MarkHolloway #menSGroupTopics #menSMinistryResources #mentalHealthAndFaith #mentalHealthForMen #modernChurchStory #modernDiscipleship #modernManStruggles #overcomingInadequacy #redemptionStories #relationalHealth #religiousFiction #religiousMenSStories #religiousShortStories #socialMediaComparison #spiritualBurnout #spiritualFreedom #SpiritualGrowth #spiritualIdentity #theComparisonTrap #TheEmptyLeaderboard #toxicMasculinityInChurch #vulnerabilityAndLeadership #vulnerabilityInMen