Nightfall ā Children of Eve Review
By Steel Druhm
Greek oddballs, Nightfall have always been unpredictable and difficult to pigeonhole to any one genre or scene. Though they came out of the same scene as Rotting Christ and SepticFlesh, their style wandered over the map much more, flirting with Goth rock, melodeath and various shades of blackened traditional metal. Every time a new album appears, you go in not knowing what to expect. 2021ās At Night We Prey was a dark, brooding affair borrowing from Moonspell and SepticFlesh without fully abandoning their quirks and intrinsic weirdness. Children of Eve stays more or less in the same general vicinity, adding more Goth broth to the pot as they walk the edges of multiple styles. Can they continue their streak of quality releases, or will the wheels finally come of your Rube Goldberg-esque musical contraption?
As with any Nightfall release, it takes a few spins to get a handle on what is going on and whether it works for you. Opener āI Hateā is like a forced marriage between Rotting Christ and SepticFlesh, and though itās very bombastic and over-the-top, it still works at a core level through sheer blunt force. Itās heavy enough to satisfy, with hooks to tickle the brainpan, and vocalist Efthimis Karadimasā death bellows work hard to keep you invested. The haunting female vocals that counterpoint his death roars are effective, and the song paints a dark, occult atmosphere. āThe Cannibalā ups the heaviness significantly, approximating Behemoth at points while also dropping a chorus thatās so Amon Amarth, that they should start preparing for a raiding party to hit their town. From there things jump around and shift styles. āLurkingā has a grungy black nā roll energy with more Amon Amarthing wedged in, and āFor the Expelled Onesā sounds a lot like the Insomniumās pairing with Rotting Christ on āWhite Christ,ā with Efthimis mimicing Sakis Tolis vocally. Closer āChristian Svengaliā goes for a kind of epic doom and pulls it off, creating a larger-than-life vibe full of drama with smart touches of Goth.
While every track contains moments I like, some simply donāt come together. āSeeking Revengeā adds pop-like female vocals to a groove-heavy melodeath attack that never really takes flight, and āWith Outlandish Desire to Disobeyā is a night club-friendly goth rocker with poppy female vocals that feels underbaked and flat. Elsewhere, āThe Traders of Anathemaā fuses epic moments with thrash and groove-metal and it falls short of success. The alchemy that carried them through the last few albums is less prevalent here, and though moments of inspired lunacy appear, only about half the songs really resonate with me and make me want to hear them again. After repeated spins, rather than coming together and making more sense, Children of Eve feels disjointed and patched together with Fruit Stripe gum and duct tape. You can almost hear the styles grinding against each other like tectonic plates rather than coalescing into something interesting. Itās a credit to Nightfall that even when things go pear-shaped, the songs are never outright bad, just tepid.
Efthimis Karadimas is the sole original member and he guides the ship. Iāve always enjoyed his vocals and his flair for the dramatic, and his booming death bellows still carry weight. He also wisely switches up styles enough over the album to avoid sounding one-note. Kostas Kyriakopoulos does a decent job dabbling in riffs from across the metal spectrum and there are high points where he steals the show, though too much of his riffage feels generic and basic. Fotis Giannakopoulos (Nightrage, ex-SepticFlesh) does a fine job brutalizing the skins, thundering along as the band shifts styles and genres on a whim. Itās not a talent issue this time, just a cohesive and memorable writing issue.
Nightfall have a long and unusual track record and theyāve had their share of hits and misses. This is the least compelling release since the early aughts, and though I doubt Iāll be returning to it, I canāt say itās wholly lacking in merit. If you wish Rotting Christ was more adventurous and freaky, this might resonate, and there are a handful of interesting songs present. It just needs moreā¦Gorilla Glue.
Rating: 2.5/5.0
DR: 6 | Format Reviewed: 192 kbps mp3
Label: Season of Mist
Websites: nightfall.gr | nightfallofficial.bandcamp.com | instagram.com/nightfallband
Releases Worldwide: May 2nd, 2025
#25 #2025 #ChildrenOfEve #GothicHeavyMetal #May25 #MelodicDeathMetal #Moonspell #Nightfall #Review #Reviews #RottingChrist #SeasonOfMistRecords #SepticFlesh