Alright I've finished season 1 of Magic Knight Rayearth now, it's Good.
First of all I decided before reaching the end that it shouldn't actually be classified as a Magical Girl Show. The fact is a lot of the Qualia of the Magical Girl Genre is mutually exclusive with being an Isekai. Now Reverse Isekai is a different story.
They only look like Magical Girls as much as they do because they're wearing their Magic JRPG Armor over their School Uniforms.
But most importantly, whether or not someone like me is judging the show as a Magical Girl Show effects how I judge it, the standards and rules I tend to hold that Genre to greatly effects how Okay I'm willing to be with how it ends, or how season 1 ends.
However the show's biggest weakness as a Fantasy show is the failure to make this "Secondary World" feel at all lived in. There's only one episode where they visit a Town and not much happens in it.
In that context it falls shot of even the most Generic and Unimaginative of modern Isekai and Quasi Isekai that so many see as inherently disgraces to the Legacy of Classic Shoujo Isekai like Rayearth. These modern Isekai may not do much to distinguish their Discount Dragon Quest worlds and towns from each other, but they do more then enough to feel like living worlds worth fighting for.
It looks like this issue may be fixed by Season 2 which I'll be starting soon. But some effort should have been put in at the start.
I know to a lot of people the Slice of Life downtime in certain Fantasy Shows kills their "urgency". But to me the Ugrency means nothing if you fail to convince me there even is a world to Save.
#EpisodicDaily #MagicKnightRayearth