I watcedh this Dark Emu doc last night and the thing that sticks at me is the counter tone of "Nothing interesting happened anywhere until British/Dutch/Spanish showed up".

OMG what a boring version of the story of humanity that is.

That our little species has been wandering about, trying things, testing ideas, wondering what is over that next hill or ocean for 10's of thousands of years is what makes us fantastic.

That anybody was lucky their crops grew and obviously only lived on random berries and lucky shots at animals is the dumbest possible view of our history.

Stories about of interesting things, managed animals, lands, crops are all over the place and trying to stick to noble savage thinking is just idiotic.

#history #darkemu #aboriginal #nativeamerican #prehistory #migration

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt27751400

The Dark Emu Story (2023) ⭐ 6.9 | Documentary

1h 35m

IMDb

The Celestial Emu proudly watches over Australia.

#DarkEmu #MilkyWay #Astronomy #Australia

Dark Emu has sold over 250,000 copies – but its value can’t be measured in money alone

Our research team tracked the impact of Dark Emu, Bruce Pascoe’s bestseller, over five years. We measured its value across a range of criteria, from financial to environmental.

The Conversation

Reading: A Year at Yumburra #BLACKDUCK
#BrucePascoe (author of #DarkEmu) with Lyn Harwood. 2024
Maps, illustrations & photographs (black & white) of Three Salt Rivers area.

Six seasons on Country: Late Summer, Autumn, Winter, Early Spring, Spring, EarlySummer.

“Had we white-skinned, adopted Australians been wiser and more tolerant, eager to learn instead of teach, we might have gained much that is of value…”
Ernestine Hill - The Great Australian Loneliness. 1937
An early recognition of a cultural tragedy that was already under way and continues to this day 😩

#aboriginal #australia #darkemu

The Dark Emu constellation rising over Nyoongar Balladong boodjar.
This constellation is unusual as it's made from the dark spaces. The head of the Emu is the Coalsack Nebula, and the neck stretches from right to left at an angle. My phone couldn't quite get all the body and legs, but I got most of the body which you can see on the left.

#AstroPhotograhy
#Astronomy #IndigenousAstronomy #DarkEmu

Watching The Dark Emu Story in iview https://iview.abc.net.au/show/dark-emu-story.

I learned colonial Australian history in the 60s & 70s, read some interesting material raising interesting questions 20-30 years ago, taught a much better version to year 12 students some years later & then read this book.

I’d learned that Indigenous Australians were Hunter-gatherers, merely harvesting & hunting what nature provided. I’d taught (at a simple middle years level) that the first farmers were people who tended the land, cared for it, used fire to control some plants & promote growth of others,use some collected seed to increase the density of some plants etc, and cultivate the soil to replant food producing plants. I learned that this happened first in places like Sumerian, Egypt etc.

Later peoples used fencing to protect crops from animals & claim ownership of the land, invented machines to more effectively cultivate the land, selected & later bred more productive plants. Animals were domesticated, selectively bred & raised for meat & dairy. Such practices developed in fertile areas with generally reliable & sufficient rainfall, & were then transferred to less fertile areas to improve productivity.

Pascoe challenged this, using the evidence of journals & letters written by white people viewing the land & its people before white settlement. And archeological evidence is that the early farming, or gardening, or land management & the building of sophisticated fish tracks, & semi-permanent villages were taking place here well before such practices in the Mediterranean. And that they mined, & produced & traded.

And he was attacked, by right wing politicians & media, & conservative academics. He claims to be truth telling, while his critics claim he has produced propaganda to try to make Indigenous Australians more relatable to non- Indigenous Australians.

All Pascoe wants, is for people to know that Indigenous Australian culture was not as simple & unsophisticated as claimed, largely in attempts to justify the appropriation of land, the pushing of Indigenous Australians onto reserves, into missions, the “opportunities” to work as stockhands & domestic servants but nothing else, and the removal over decades of mixed race children from their families & placement into institutions (many but not all the result of sexual violence & exploitation), where many of the children were themselves abused & set on a path of crime & substance abuse. (See Jack Charles’ book https://www.penguin.com.au/books/jack-charles-9781760899158).

Good documentary, excellent & thoroughly researched book. Jack Charles’ book is a lighter read. He definitely wasn’t an entertainer but was such a treasure. I really regret not going to see him on stage before he died. #DarkEmu #TheDarkEmuStory #IndigenousAustralia

The Dark Emu Story

A thought-provoking documentary that charts the impact of Bruce Pascoe's Dark Emu - the book that challenged Australia to rethink its history and ignited a debate that continues to rage. Winner of Walkley Award for Excellence in Australian Journalism. (2023)

ABC iview

To anyone who remains bewildered by the punditry and polemic around Bruce Pascoe's #DarkEmu and would perhaps like some other #books on #Indigenous #Australian and #Aboriginal #history and similar subjects, and which have not attracted such diatribe, I can recommend the following, all by extremely qualified, professional historians:
1835 by James Boyce
The Story of Australia's People Vol. 1 by Geoffrey Blainey
Deep Time Dreaming by Billy Griffiths (I haven't read this yet but reviews suggest it provides a valuable contribution to the field)

But also, Dark Emu is still worth a read, if only as a jumping off point to further reading and to spark curiosity (though it has other merits too). All of this is to say that despite what you may hear from popular media, there is some excellent scholarship on Australia's indigenous peoples and their history, both before and after the white people invaded.

Lastly, #VoteYes

Editorial, The butterfly catcher, The Saturday Paper, 5 August 2023

https://www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au/2023/08/05/the-butterfly-catcher

#TheVoice #Racism #DarkEmu

The butterfly catcher

Sometimes a story will function in two registers. The first is obvious. It is the meaning of words in isolation. It is the object and the subject and the verb that connects them. The second register is more insidious. Occasionally it will be unknown even to the author of the piece. It is the register of secret meaning, where prejudice and placement and sheer number reveal the truth of why an item has run at all.

The Saturday Paper

Just watched the Dark Emu movie on #ABC. It's a big story with many themes, but what spoke to me was Marcia Langton's plea for all Australians to plant native grasses and vegetation wherever they can. I read Dark Emu over a decade ago and have been planting Kangaroo grass all over my garden. Now with Marcia's blessing, I think I have my wife's permission to plant it all over the 'nature' strip. #auspol #DarkEmu

If you missed it - you can catch up with it here https://iview.abc.net.au/show/dark-emu-story/video/IP1902H001S00

The Dark Emu Story

A thought-provoking documentary that charts the impact of Bruce Pascoe's Dark Emu - the book that challenged Australia to rethink its history and ignited a debate that continues to rage. Winner of Walkley Award for Excellence in Australian Journalism. (2023)

ABC iview