I can't seem to find apple butter in the stores anymore, so I learned how to make it myself. It took a few tries to tweak the recipe to my taste, but it was worth the effort. (I still see Eden Organic brand apple butter around sometimes, but I will never buy anything from them again after they did a Hobby Lobby copycat lawsuit and made abortion harder to access.)

## Apple Butter ##

Ingredients:

- 3 lbs apples, not peeled
- 1/3 C apple juice
- 1/2 C sugar
- 1 Tbsp molasses
- 1 Tbsp vanilla extract
- 2 tsp cinnamon
- 1 tsp Primal Palate Apple Pie Spice (cinnamon, ginger, allspice, cardamom, nutmeg)

Process:

Chop and core apples, but DO NOT PEEL. The peel is where the pectin is and you want that to thicken the consistency. Protip: A melon baller works great for scooping out the apple's core after cutting in half.

You can use water if you don't have apple juice handy. The apples will release liquid as they cook, but you need some liquid to start things off or the bottom will burn. I use only a small amount because any liquid added has to be cooked down later.

Put everything in InstantPot. Cook for 20 mins, followed by natural release for 20 mins.

Blend with immersion blender, then cook down to desired consistency.

My InstantPot can't simmer at a low temp, so I transfer everything to a big pot (I use a large wok) to avoid splashing and burning as it cooks down over a low flame. Takes 30-60 mins, depending. Stir & scrape bottom regularly to avoid burning or sticking. Note, it will be a bit thicker after it cools.

The apple butter will keep in the fridge for a week or two. Put the rest in jars and freeze for later (but don't fill the jars to the top, leave a little space for expansion).

#cooking #recipe #AppleButter #InstantPot

Simple Apple Butter Made in the Crockpot

Simple crockpot apple butter—sweet, spiced, and easy to make. #SlowCooker #AppleButter #FallRecipe

https://crockpotmeal.com/simple-apple-butter-made-in-the-crockpot/

Simple Apple Butter Made in the Crockpot

This Simple Apple Butter Made in the Crockpot transforms fresh apples into a rich, spiced spread with minimal effort. Slow-cooked to perfection, it’s a sweet, aromatic treat perfect for toast, pastries, or gifting, all from the comfort of your slow cooker. Why You’ll Love This Recipe This crockpot apple butter is a delightful, hands-off way...

Crock Pot Meal

Best Easy Homemade Apple Butter Jar Recipe

easy apple butter jar recipe | quick preserve | no cooking needed

Make homemade apple butter in jars in 30 minutes! 🍏 Ideal for meal prep, gifting, or feeding a crowd. No special tools required.
#applebutter #jarrecipes #easypreserves #mealprep #apples

https://dishes-recipes.com/

Autumn-Inspired Apple Butter Slow Cooker Recipe

Cozy slow cooker apple butter—rich, spiced autumn flavor.

#FallRecipes #SlowCooker #AppleButter

https://crockpotmeal.com/autumn-inspired-apple-butter-slow-cooker-recipe/

Autumn-Inspired Apple Butter Slow Cooker Recipe

This Autumn-Inspired Apple Butter Slow Cooker Recipe transforms fresh apples into a rich, spiced spread perfect for fall. With warm notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves, it’s an easy, hands-off recipe that fills your home with cozy aromas, ideal for toast, biscuits, or gifting. Why You’ll Love This Recipe This apple butter recipe is a...

Crock Pot Meal

Spiced Apple Butter https://biketoworkbarb.blogspot.com/2025/11/spiced-apple-butter-recipe.html. Made today along with Cranberry Orange Jam with Crystallized Ginger from #SeriousEats (but with adjustments to cooking time--don't believe someone who says orange peels soften in 10 minutes--no pectin, added 1 T. lemon juice https://www.seriouseats.com/cranberry-orange-jam-with-crystallized-ginger-recipe).

Time to sit down and enjoy the sound of pinging jar lids.

#Food #FoodInJars #cooking #canning #FoodPreservation #apples #AppleButter #Jam #cranberries #citrus #ginger #recipe #recipes #RecipeOfTheDay

Spiced Apple Butter Recipe

Personal blog with heavy doses of bicycling, public policy, social justice, and family life.

/C O R R E C T I O N — Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard/

In the news release, Move Over PSL — Rita’s Apple Butter Concrete Is the New Fall Obsession, issued 25-Aug-2025 by Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard ove…
#dining #cooking #diet #food #Italianbutter #AppleButter #Butter #buttercream #frozencustard #Italia #Italian #italianbutter #Italianbuttercream #italianice #italiano #italy #vanillawafers
https://www.diningandcooking.com/2341427/c-o-r-r-e-c-t-i-o-n-ritas-italian-ice-frozen-custard/

/C O R R E C T I O N - Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard/ - Dining and Cooking

In the news release, Move Over PSL -- Rita's Apple Butter Concrete Is the New Fall Obsession, issued 25-Aug-2025 by Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Dining and Cooking

With the change in the weather, I start thinking about soulful warming comfort foods and my Jack Daniels Apple Butter Chicken certainly fits into that category of deliciousness! #chicken #applebutter #fallrecipes #dinner #flipboardusergroup

https://www.askchefdennis.com/apple-butter-chicken/?utm_source=flipboard&utm_medium=activitypub

Posted into Soulful Stews @soulful-stews-askchefdennis

Jack Daniels Apple Butter Chicken

With the change in the weather, I start thinking about soulful warming comfort foods and my Jack Daniels Apple Butter Chicken certainly fits into

Ask Chef Dennis
Is there anything more #autumnal than waiting an hour in line to buy fresh #applebutter, and experiencing an electric blue sky and a stiff, cool fall breeze...that blows a cluster of leaves right into your face. #silly

#ComfortFood #ComfortFoods #AppleButter

~ Here's another great addition to consider and try ... Found this brand about 10 years ago and This one's my pick for their apple butter. Great on warm, buttery Buttermilk biscuits. Definitely another comfort food fave😋

#CoopersMill

#AppleButter #ComfortFood #ComfortFoods

https://crossroadscandles.com/apple-butter-no-sugar-with-cinnamon-pint/

~ Are you an apple butter fan? This is a favorite I found about 10 years ago ... No sugar, but natural sweetness with the perfect amount/blend of cinnamon. You'll be surprised how much flavor this apple butter has. Great on warm, buttery Buttermilk Biscuits😋 Of course, don't forget the coffee!!

#CoopersMill #Breakfast #BreakfastIdeas #BreakfastTreat #Brunch 🙂☕☕🍞🍎🍏🍎

Apple Butter (No Sugar, With Cinnamon) - Pint

We proudly offer products from 4 incredible brands, featuring clean-burning candles, specialty gifts, home decor, gourmet apple butter, jams, sauces and more!

Crossroads Family of Companies