Gaza Ministry of Health looks like they might be are UNDER reporting war deaths.

Gaza's war death stats look somewhat like Russian #COVID data, which is to say, they look suspicious, but they definitely DON'T look like an over count.

🔗 https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(23)02713-7/fulltext 🔗 the Lancet article this data is from

It zig zags up, looking like real world data, then on about 27 October 2023 it simultaneously drops AND shows possible under-dispersion (a statistical term meaning the number per day is suspiciously consistent). It looks a bit like when #Russia were refusing to report more than 800 COVID deaths per day, but it' isn't quite as severe.

🔗 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9111161/ 🔗 "Underdispersion: A statistical anomaly in reported Covid data" Dmitry Kobak

This is unfortunately unlikely to be a real reduction because, despite reported war deaths in the general population halving, deaths of UN Workers increase.

It is possible the Government of Gaza are deliberately under-reporting deaths, exactly like Russia were during the pandemic. (Realistically if you started - or massively escalated - a war, and
got tens of thousands of people massacred by a much-better-armed enemy, you might not fully admit to how bad things were getting?)

But in this case I think it's more likely that deaths per day have exceeded Gaza's capacity to report them. Despite the constant accusations, the numbers Gaza's MOH are releasing are not just an estimate, they are only the named identified dead, they exclude anyone trapped under rubble and possibly those who ended up buried in mass graves (mild "citation needed" but I've heard that from moderately reliable sources and I'll believe it till I see a more reliable source refute it).

But it doesn't just hit a ceiling, something very suddenly goes wrong with their data reporting on 27 October 2023 (+/- 2 days) … I've not yet found what this corresponds to, but it might be around the time the #IDF ground invasion of Gaza began?

(cc my other profiles @kirt @kirt @kirt for the notifications)

#data #statistics #PublicHealth #PublicHealthData #Lancet #TheLancet

#Gaza #GazaGenocide #GazaMassacre #GazaMOH

#Russia799 #враньё799 #враньё #799враньё #CovidRussia #Covid19ru #UNRWA

#فلسطین #فلسطين #غزة #حرب

×

Gaza Ministry of Health looks like they might be are UNDER reporting war deaths.

Gaza's war death stats look somewhat like Russian #COVID data, which is to say, they look suspicious, but they definitely DON'T look like an over count.

🔗 https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(23)02713-7/fulltext 🔗 the Lancet article this data is from

It zig zags up, looking like real world data, then on about 27 October 2023 it simultaneously drops AND shows possible under-dispersion (a statistical term meaning the number per day is suspiciously consistent). It looks a bit like when #Russia were refusing to report more than 800 COVID deaths per day, but it' isn't quite as severe.

🔗 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9111161/ 🔗 "Underdispersion: A statistical anomaly in reported Covid data" Dmitry Kobak

This is unfortunately unlikely to be a real reduction because, despite reported war deaths in the general population halving, deaths of UN Workers increase.

It is possible the Government of Gaza are deliberately under-reporting deaths, exactly like Russia were during the pandemic. (Realistically if you started - or massively escalated - a war, and
got tens of thousands of people massacred by a much-better-armed enemy, you might not fully admit to how bad things were getting?)

But in this case I think it's more likely that deaths per day have exceeded Gaza's capacity to report them. Despite the constant accusations, the numbers Gaza's MOH are releasing are not just an estimate, they are only the named identified dead, they exclude anyone trapped under rubble and possibly those who ended up buried in mass graves (mild "citation needed" but I've heard that from moderately reliable sources and I'll believe it till I see a more reliable source refute it).

But it doesn't just hit a ceiling, something very suddenly goes wrong with their data reporting on 27 October 2023 (+/- 2 days) … I've not yet found what this corresponds to, but it might be around the time the #IDF ground invasion of Gaza began?

(cc my other profiles @kirt @kirt @kirt for the notifications)

#data #statistics #PublicHealth #PublicHealthData #Lancet #TheLancet

#Gaza #GazaGenocide #GazaMassacre #GazaMOH

#Russia799 #враньё799 #враньё #799враньё #CovidRussia #Covid19ru #UNRWA

#فلسطین #فلسطين #غزة #حرب

There were airstrikes on Al-Shifa hospital on 27 October … but there's been airstrikes on hospitals most days? So possibly meaningless?

When the #IDF say Al-Shifa had a #HamasBase in it … do they mean a government office that was reporting on civilian deaths?

#Hamas were more than a decade over due for an election, which is … not great … but still, a lot of "Hamas" is not military.

cc @kirt @kirt @kirt @kirt

#27October #AlShifa #GazaMOH #GazaData #Entity
#حماس #غزة

The same #Underdispersion has now been noted by #AbrahamWyner from #UniversityofPennsylvania but (for reasons I have not yet found) his data starts on 26 October.

https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/how-gaza-health-ministry-fakes-casualty-numbers

Some of the correlations are interesting, but they only include about a dozen data points from way over a hundred days of #war … I'll have a closer look to see how those are picked… 🍒

cc other mes @kirt @kirt@med-mastodon.com @kirt@mstdn.science

How the Gaza Ministry of Health Fakes Casualty Numbers

The evidence is in their own poorly fabricated figures

Tablet Magazine

I was planning to look at male vs female counts myself.

If it is real (for a bigger subset of days) I think what it shows is fudging dates to hide the identities of combatants, and possibly downplay the number of them.

But, the #IDF already assuming (implausibly) that almost every male over 15 is a combatant, the real number is very likely to still be lower than that.

More importantly, it doesn't indicate that the women and children under 15 are not real civilians who really died.

But i should read this properly…

cc-ing my other profiles @kirt @kirt @kirt

That is not true, "Unfortunately, verified control data is not available to formally test this conclusion, but the details of the daily counts render the numbers suspicious".

but they think #UNRWA are a division of #Hamas

@kirt @kirt @kirt

what on earth are they talking about?

"death count reported on Oct. 29 contradicts the numbers reported on the 28th, insofar as they imply that 26 men came back to life"

a total number of men goes down?

why are they looking at the cumulative totals?

i need to look at this data…

@kirt @kirt @kirt

"Hamas also blames all deaths on Israel even if caused by Hamas’ own misfired rockets, accidental explosions, deliberate killings, or internal battles." https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/how-gaza-health-ministry-fakes-casualty-numbers

They actually don't, at least they didn't before the October 2023 (they've named no fighters who've died in #Palestine since 5 October)

The #AlQassam list of martyred fighters includes those who died in accidents.

They've also released at least one official statement on a fighter they executed.

cc @kirt @kirt @kirt

How the Gaza Ministry of Health Fakes Casualty Numbers

The evidence is in their own poorly fabricated figures

Tablet Magazine
@kirt @kirt @kirt @kirt
... and now that the genocide is obvious to all of us, the next stage is denial.

i still need to find those lancet papers…

@kirt @kirt @kirt @kirt