Adults Lose Skills to AI. Children Never Build Them.

Discussions of cognitive offloading often miss a critical distinction: What AI does to a 45-year-old's brain is categorically different from what it does to a 14-year-old's.

Psychology Today
@cwebber The list with the key points is demolishing.

@cwebber Oooh, this quote, exactly!

"...In my view, the most likely explanation for this is not generational preference but biological development. The older group probably offloaded tasks they already knew how to perform. The younger group offloaded task they never learned how to perform. These neural pathways for source evaluation and constructing arguments were never formed. You can’t atrophy a muscle that was never built...."

@ai6yr @cwebber When mentoring students I often get the question - how do you figure things out so quickly.

Then I tell them that I've been messing with hardware and software since I was in my early teens - and I made tons of (innocent) mistakes.

When you get to be an adult you then know how to approach complex systems where you might not have this much margin.

Much of it is heuristics. Offloading heuristics (despite biases) is a VERY BAD IDEA.

@ai6yr @cwebber Along the same line. I often got the question, what major should I study. I tell them, pick the hardest you can handle (if not a bit more). You will never have as much time to deal with this stuff as during college.
@ai6yr @cwebber One of my life regrets is not studying physics, with a minor in life sciences / biology (rather than having to do it the other way around - which stinks).
@koen_hufkens @ai6yr @cwebber experience: the collection of times when you went "oh, shit..." and filed it under "no, not doing that again, nope" for future reference.
@koen_hufkens @ai6yr @cwebber This is the good case scenario. The bad case scenario is https://circumstances.run/@agturcz/114568845841328174
Agnieszka R. Turczyńska (@[email protected])

Attached: 1 image @[email protected] Well, I do not know the full context of Mans's situation, but there is this meme, which I, as a Senior Dev, find very accurate 😅 @[email protected] @[email protected] @[email protected]

GSV Sleeper Service
@cwebber I was having this discussion with co-workers and came to the conclusion that with people relying on AI, things are gonna stagnate. no "new" knowledge will be pumped into the system so it will just be regurgitated slop once people stop thinking for themselves.
@notsle @cwebber Exactly. It's stealing and laundering the theft of human labour, AI depends entirely on humans who don't use it but think for themselves.

@cwebber and there it is: our education system has mostly been designed for compliance. It needs a redesign because humans will follow the incentives. We are not complicated that way. 🐒🍌 We need to incentivize critical thinking.

Thankfully, compliance was never one of my parenting goals. Nor should it be anyone’s.

Cooperation is a much better goal.

@KatLS @cwebber critical thinking is not something schools will ever teach, sadly. It's just not good for ruling/owning classes.
@lizzard @KatLS @cwebber Many schools try. It’s not easy to teach critical thinking. My school certainly tried to teach me, but I was an awful student. I thankfully had a family who found ways to make sure I learned that, if nothing else.
@ClickyMcTicker @lizzard @KatLS @cwebber My AP English teacher had a unit on logical fallacies and how to detect them. The science teachers (especially at AP level) were pretty consistent at teaching how to approach problems critically and not just plug numbers into an equation. All of this in a bland, middle-class public (USA) high school that spent way too much on football and not enough on teachers. Then again, that was also almost 40 years ago.
@dpnash @ClickyMcTicker @lizzard @cwebber I was likewise lucky in the 80s to have at least a few teachers that did this work. Mr. Jayne was the best history teacher ever🩷
@ClickyMcTicker @KatLS @cwebber many teachers try. I'm not so sure about the system as a whole. I'm not even thinking about the US here, I'm not from there. Just as a general class education thing.
@cwebber oof yeah, Sam Altman’s dream, apparently
The AI Race to Reboot Feudalism

Let’s be honest why they gamble everything

Medium

@cwebber

Anecdata: Asked a specifying question for my context of a presenter at an event. His answer: “I have set up an LLM to answer questions from these files at this url. Give it a try!”

I did not and I will not.

@cwebber More fodder for the top 1% wealthiest, to squeeze as much out of the masses as they can.

De Oppresso Liber

@cwebber This is the downside of using AI, which gives us everything ready-made, so all mental effort becomes unnecessary, weakening our minds.

@cwebber Dear lord 😞 This is destroying kids and will destroy society if it isn't stopped:

"A child offloading a task they've never learned to perform is not making a choice. They are skipping a developmental step (of critical thinking) that was never developed. The capacity doesn't exist yet. The foreclosure may be permanent—and because they have no independent baseline, they cannot recognize what they're losing."

@cwebber

developers who delegated coding to AI produced working code but failed conceptual understanding

I wish tech industry would have that sink in 

@cwebber I have been developing Adverserial skills....
@cwebber I got round this by lacking skills in the first place. #Winning
@cwebber This just happened 2 weeks ago. One of my grandsons had his 16th birthday. The family was pooling money so he could buy a new laptop. I didn't have cash so put a check inside his birthday card. He opened the card while we were all at dinner. He pulled the check out & actually asked, "What is this for?" He didn't know what a personal check was. It had to be explained. He even has a checking account, but had never seen a paper check. His parents, one of whom is my son, are failing.
@PattyHanson that's not really the same thing. Checks have been getting rarer and rarer for decades. I haven't seen a check in almost 20 years. Something that was important for you to understand when you were younger just isn't true for your grandson. Your son probably hasn't needed to use a check for a long time either and therefore teaching his kids about the just never came up. He's not failing because he didn't deliberately sit them down and explain what a check.
@cwebber It’s compounded by prior generations of decreasing education in arts and humanities, leading to adults (parents) who themselves did not learn creative thinking, ethics, or different cultures. I remember 20 years ago a comp sci professor complaining that his university was churning out tech grads with terrible communication skills. Those are now the “45 year olds” whose abilities atrophy “but could recover”. Their kids didn’t stand a chance against AI.
@cwebber I filed this under "Interesting if true". I'd love to believe it.

@cwebber

Considering that the humans are doing an absolutely terrible job, I figure the AI systems can at least be measured....

https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/reading/nation/scores/

NAEP Reading: National Average Scores

NAEP Report Card: Reading

@cwebber Algorithmic complacency kills curiosity and eventually free will.