@nielso
I try to remember what the issue is here, because I know Jack forwards the alsa midi devices and you can use it to link devices together in Carla (as an addition to aconnect on the shell). I also remember seeing midi clock messages in the data stream... ah wait, Jack has its own start-stop-resume message feature it uses to synchronize audio and video streams, right? And you need to sync that one to a midi clock source to use it in your applications?

That's interesting! I remember I had a hard time syncing software plugins to external gear. It kinda worked when I ignored the existence of Jack and use native Alsa for midi transport but a) the latency was immense (150-250ms) and b) not all plugins were able to use Alsa for midi and Jack for Audio, so I eventually gave up entirely and went full DAWless.

I own a hardware midi clock (Nome 1, was Midronome: https://simntonic.com/pages/about-nome-ii) and I always wondered how they solved this issue. Answer is simple: Linux not supported. 🤣

@momo

It turns out that midi_clock_sync does set the Jack Transport tempo, but Carla overrides it with its own setting, so the sync to USB MIDI never happens.

@falktx – is there a way to prevent Carla from enforcing the Jack Transport tempo?

Note that Pipewire apparently does not provide a Transport Clock for its Jack layer, because… who would need that? 🤪 (Or did they implement it by now and I'm not up to date?)

Which basically would mean, this setup of mine, which runs half-ways, will not run on the laptop I intend to use it on. Because that laptop is 100% Pipewire, while my studio desktop machine is old Jack + Pipewire. Oh my.

But I have to do other stuff for a while now.

Would be a start if I could prevent Carla from overriding the tempo.

EDIT: I found Carla doesn't claim Jack Transport Master if there is another master already, but it only checks so on startup apparently, so midi_clock_sync must be started first.

Nasty trick. A checkbox in the GUI would be great.

@nielso @momo @falktx I know @dreamer has mentioned midi issues with Pipewire before, so it could definitely be a common issue.

I have never needed to use an incoming midi clock, so I wouldn’t even know where to start.

Have you considered reaching out on Github to the relevant parties?

@mosgaard @momo @falktx @dreamer

Turns out Carla can do it with old time Jack when started second, because then it will not claim Jack Transport Master status. (I'd love a checkbox for this.)

I will see with my Pipewire setup on the lapop, but have to do some work for money now first.