Something I was wondering about this morning: native English speakers, do you pronounce initial [wh] and initial [w] differently? I.e., is there a difference in the way you pronounce 'which' and 'witch' or 'whether' and 'weather'?

Please boost for reach.

Yes
27.4%
No
67.9%
Huh?
4.8%
Poll ended at .
@joyce
Not here in the north of England! I have heard older RP (Received Pronunciation, the Queen's English or early BBC-speak) give a very slight extra emphasis (almost like a very faint whistling sound) on "wh" but I suspect that's all but died out.

@Gillinger

I think it's dying out in the US as well. When I was a child in the 1950s, I was drilled on the difference by an elementary school teacher, and later on, in the 2000s, I was chastised by a stuffy professor for pronouncing 'whale' without the h.

Maybe it's just Boomers who differentiate now.

my Irish American in-laws were old school New Englanders from the Poconos region. my FIL was first generation Irish American: his ma and da were folks off the boats at Ellis Island.

neither of them spoke with that fricative.

yet i noticed it immediately on Bob Ross. he uses it, ever so lightly in his early shows when he worked harder at hiding his southern (northern Floridian, to be exact) accent.

i think that USian fricative is more regional than generational.

@joyce @Gillinger