I’ve been experiencing repeating issues in #HomeAssistant with devices not responding. It’s been manifesting in the system log as an error:

cp210x ttyUSB0: failed set request 0x12 status: -110

That’s Zigbee dongle. The workaround was to reboot the system, but I’ve changed it’s USB port and it seems to be gone.

The system is #RaspbianOS on #Raspberry Pi5. Pi is powered via PoE and it should have sufficient power budget, though it’s running of an nvme.2 and with USB hard drive, so who knows…

@ssamulczyk I had to move my Conbee II stick to a powered USB-hub to make it stable on the Pi4...

@fhekland Yeah, read about it too… It’s been suggested as a possible solution in cases people can’t get it running at all.

Mine is running ok most of the time, having issues on occasion, lowering #WifeApprovalFactor significantly…🤡

@fhekland Yeah… My issue came back, though restarting HA was enough to fix it.

I’m now trying and old unpowered 2.0 USB hub I had laying around… We will see…

@ssamulczyk Ahh, sucks. Unless you can switch to the original power supply, perhaps you can tweak the power negotiation via config.txt?
I don't know if there is a cap on the input current for PoE on the Pi, but worth a try... https://forums.raspberrypi.com/viewtopic.php?t=367681
Raspberry Pi 5 USB power output - Raspberry Pi Forums

Performance option: usb_max_current_enable - Raspberry Pi Forums

@fhekland Yeah, I’m doing this as well, because without it I had issues with external USB drive…🤷🏻‍♂️

@fhekland I’m running this for PoE…

https://www.waveshare.com/product/poe-hat-f.htm

It should have plenty of power. Also, it’s running Pimoroni M.2 NVMe base with SSD and USB external hard drive… I’d assume there would be more issues and more often than this…

If that hub doesn’t help, then I’m going to run it through a powered one… Maybe then stock PS.

People have the same issue on standard PCs, though, so I don’t know…

Power Over Ethernet HAT (F) For Raspberry Pi 5 / CM 5, High Power, Onboard Cooling Fan, With Metal Heatsink, Supports 802.3af/at network standard | PoE HAT (F)

Power Over Ethernet HAT (F) For Raspberry Pi 5 / CM 5, High Power, Onboard Cooling Fan, With Metal Heatsink, Supports 802.3af/at network standard | PoE HAT (F)

@ssamulczyk Sounds like you're running your little Pi pretty hard 😅
NVMe and HDD can be pretty spiky in their current draw, and when you're at the limit, the USB 5V rail will eventually droop and devices start to brown-out.

Sounds like you soon have to get a powered hub (and a beautiful box to put everything in to make the WAF high enough 😉)

@fhekland My Waifu (🫣) is allergic to fan noise and humming, so it’s already hidden in a TV cabinet in a 1U enclosure along with 1U router…🤡 I guess I can squeeze a powered hub inside if I must…

I agree it might be a lot, running Pi 5 like that, BUT it’s mostly doing nothing. Once every now and then we watch something on Jellyfin, but mostly that USB drive is not being accessed. I cannot correlate the dongle issue with any heavy use on the system…

@ssamulczyk If you still have issues and you haven’t yet also consider putting it on a USB extension. Plugging directly into the USB port can cause interference issues. I’ve seen and others have reported this.
@GavinCampbell It’s already on a long-ass extension, because otherwise it would have been hidden and crammed along with 2 Pi’s, router, switch and modem… Way to much interference!🤷🏻‍♂️
@ssamulczyk Nice. Well that eliminates that issue. :)

@GavinCampbell I’ve also had, for a brief time, a separate Ikea Tradfri gateway.

So I had 2 Zigbee networks competing for the already narrow band…😂

That is some finicky shit, but when you do it just right, it works. I have 40+ Zigbee devices and that USB error was my only remaining issue…🥹

@ssamulczyk I’ve been through a number of controllers. Right now I have the Home Assistant ZBT-2 as my primary zigbee with the Aqara M3 for my legacy Aqara devices. I also have a ZWA-2 for zwave and another ZBT-2 for thread. That’s a lot of signals around my house. But it has never been more stable.

@GavinCampbell At least it’s all 2,4GHz… Also, sounds like a real nightmare to diagnose in case of a failure… Can’t imagine swapping controllers, as I think the data of the network is held on the controller.

I’ve once, accidentally, changed the controller’s channel and it took me hours to bring it back to normal…🥹

For me - a single network - was between either Zigbee or Z-Wave. Zigbee is just less expensive and there are more DIY things…🥸

@ssamulczyk Swapping controllers is a pain. I have a few hundred devices. Zwave is much easier with newer firmware you can back up and restore. Zigbee always was a pain and still haven’t really perfected that one. But with these controllers I’m now happy. I eventually want to get rid of the m3 but that may require replacing some devices too.