1/3 Debunking UN World Happiness Report and why Finland is NOT the happiest country in the world

The UN report is misleading because it relies on a single metric: Cantril’s Ladder.

This 0-10 scale oversimplifies wellbeing and ignores how country rankings differ when using positive vs. negative affect.

Reliance on one ordinal scale is often mathematically problematic.

https://yaschamounk.substack.com/p/the-world-happiness-report-is-a-sham

#Findland #wellbeing #socialscience #un

The World Happiness Report Is a Sham

A case study in elite misinformation.

Yascha Mounk
2/3 Challenging "Happy" Stereotypes
Blanchflower & Bryson (2024) find Nordic countries rank lower when measured by daily worry or pain rather than just life satisfaction.
Their summary index of 8 metrics reveals some US states like Hawaii and Minnesota lead the world, while other us states such as West Virginia (101th) and « happy » Bhutan (99th) rank poorly.
Study: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11205-023-03262-y
#Nordic #Wellbeing #bhutan #SocialScience
Wellbeing Rankings - Social Indicators Research

Combining data on around four million respondents from the Gallup World Poll and the US Daily Tracker Poll we rank 164 countries, the 50 states of the United States and the District of Colombia on eight wellbeing measures. These are four positive wellbeing measures—life satisfaction, enjoyment, smiling and being well-rested—and four negative wellbeing variables—pain, sadness, anger and worry. Pooling the data for 2008–2017 we find country and state rankings differ markedly depending on whether they are ranked using positive or negative affect measures. The United States ranks lower on negative than positive affect, that is, its country wellbeing ranking looks worse using negative affect than it does when using positive affect. Combining rankings on all eight measures into a summary ranking index for 215 geographical locations we find that nine of the top ten and 16 of the top 20 ranked are US states. Only one US state ranks outside the top 100—West Virginia (101). Iraq ranks lowest—just below South Sudan. The Nordic countries that traditionally rank high using life satisfaction do not rank as highly on other measures. Country-level rankings on the summary wellbeing index differ sharply from those reported in the World Happiness Index and are more comparable to those obtained with the Human Development Index. The state level rankings on the summary index look very different from those just based on positive affect measures and look more similar to rankings based on objective wellbeing measures.

SpringerLink
3/3 The Policy Paradox
Measuring happiness is fraught with error. Critics like Yascha Mounk argue the UN ranking is a "sham" because it overlooks the multifaceted nature of wellbeing.
For millennia, humanity has struggled to define a "happy life."
While both communism and liberalism claim to offer the definitive path, data suggests we have mostly failed to find the right government policy to achieve it reliably.
Happiness at a society level remains a complex, open debate.