You see a lot of hand wringing about social media and division and isolation. I think that the division and isolation are real but it puts the cart before the horse. We are divided and isolated because we have lost public space and public time. You can't afford to go out and be with people or even pursue solo delights, like walking, fishing, bird watching or what have you.

If we think about semi common land as places where you can be with others away from work it will include places like pubs and cafes, parks, forests, hills, clubs dedicated to games or shared interests. The costs of entering have increased. Transport is expensive, adequate gear costs, the drink or the cake is exorbitant. Many of these places require a critical mass of people to survive. There are less people with the time and the resources to maintain or participate in shared activities.

It becomes the preserve of the rich few. They in turn mark their enclosure by making it seem like possession of the right, hyper-expensive gear is a prerequisite of entry. You rarely see people out for a cycle in a pair of old trousers, a t-shirt and battered old bike these days. It's all lycra and carbonfibre.

We lack the time and the energy to do it even when we have the money. So we turn to youtube and social media to fill the lack, but the division will remain until we can get the boot off our faces by freeing up access to the common and the semi-common. Then we can be with each other again.

#Commons, #SocialMedia, #CapitalismIsKillingUs

@RobertoArchimboldi @mothninja Except I think spaces like Mastodon allow us to build connections and networks even if we’re too sick or disabled to get outdoors. It’s a window onto the world for those who cannot access common spaces

@purplepadma, I'm not against social media, especially non-commercial social media. I think that the division is being caused by a loss of access to shared social space by a lack of money, time and energy. Zuckerberg just profits from that.

There is a strange sort of nostalgia for the lockdown. Then all social interactions were online. There was a big, communal shared experience and rules of rent were temporarily lifted. I don't mean that you didn't have to pay rent, although here you couldn't be evicted and housing was found for everyone. I mean that the logic of capitalism was temporarily suspended. We were supported by each other and the state. The link between your 'productivity' and your ability to meet your needs was broken. That brought people together. It is no coincidence that there were genuinely revolutionary, mass anti-racist protests during that period. It is that, I think, which people long for

@RobertoArchimboldi Yes, in a perverse way I enjoyed lockdown because my local community really came together. There was a secret window painter who went round painting rainbows and messages on ship and house windows. People shopped for each other. We had socially distanced drinks with the neighbours with our chairs about 5m apart.
@purplepadma @RobertoArchimboldi I also feel guilty saying this, because the initial phases of the pandemic were horrific and terrifying and a lot of people including me lost people to it, but there are bits of it I miss - I do now understand the people who said that World War Two was the best years of their life because they had purpose. For the first time in my life the world made sense, everyone's highest priority became not money or status but taking care of each other. We created building
@purplepadma @RobertoArchimboldi and street Whatsapp groups, shopped for each other, my neighbour sewed scrubs and face masks, did what looked like dodgy drug deals in carparks to exchange carrier bags of toilet paper or fruit crumble, people put boxes of children's toys or books in their front gardens for other parents to take if their kids were bored. I wish we'd managed to keep that bit

@afewbugs @purplepadma you are right. I was very lucky and didn't lose friends or loved ones. Of course medical professionals and key workers were in a horror show. Over policed racialised people were often trapped in really small, overcrowded spaces really felt it. I have been a bit glib.

Purple Padma's experience, or mine, are though not so unusual. I do think that the right were so keen to get back to 'normality' because the whole logic of the reduction of society to private answers valued only as input into the generation of profits was being threatened

@RobertoArchimboldi

I confess to be in the habit of cycling on a battered old bike in a pair of old trousers.

Though I'd wish there'd be places in town for hanging out without having to pay for coffee or something.
@snippet if I could, I would ban Lycra and carbonfibre, so more power to your elbow (or knees I suppose)