There is a lot of demand for digital privacy and security advice out there right now and lots of people are giving advice and writing guides. I beg them to do a few things:

1. Be explicit about the threat model your advice is meant for.

2. Do not give advice you haven't tried implementing yourself. Eat your own dog food.

3. Get feedback on your guide from your target audience before publication.

4. Incorporate that feedback. This is not an optional step.

If your intended audience can't understand your instructions, can't be bothered to carry out your instructions, and/or following your instructions fails to actually solve the problems that they have, you're just masturbating.
@evacide this was a very strange post to see in my feed without context
@evacide this is great advice, like, universally

@evacide In that case couldn't they be called JOI?

I'll see myself out.

@evacide I saw this answer before the start of the thread and unintentionally applied it to a very different problem that I currently face. I agree with you and in addition I think it is an excellent statement that applies to many other situations.
@evacide It is absolutely stunning how many situations to which this applies.
@evacide This is beautiful. Thank you.
@evacide pragmatic advice devoid of emotion and connector. Well said.

@evacide If I'm going to give instructions to someone else, I first write them out and try to follow them exactly as written. It makes mostly sure they are reproducible. Mostly.

I like the callout on threat models and their applicability. I'm going to steal that.

@evacide Honestly, this is good technical writing advice in general. Write to your audience first and foremost. Anything else is wasting time and possibly doing harm as you make people feel stupid, embarrassed, and ashamed.
@evacide It's embarrassing how many technical people do not know how to communicate and have no interest in doing so.

@evacide Before writing yet another guide, see if there already is a good enough guide you can share, as is or with some commentary, and/or contribute to, rather than starting from scratch.

For a starting list of existing guides, see page 5 of the full version of
https://www.turnoffyourphone.org (that guide is good too).

ObXkcd: https://xkcd.com/927/

Step One: Turn Off Your Phone

Activist Anti-Surveillance Tips from a Friendly Neighborhood Hacker

Fight for the Future
@evacide I've always considered privacyguides to be pretty up to par because they use threat model labels! :P
This is solid advice. Especially #2; you can't recommend what you haven't used.

@evacide Number two is questionable.

Let's say I use Linux exclusively. Why can't I give good advice for, for example, using local users in Windows?

@evacide as to 1., the burden of that specification lies with the advice solicitor