I see that Hegseth wants to administratively separate service members who have medical waivers for shaving.

It's hard to imagine this as anything other than a targeted means of pushing Black people out of the military.

For those that don't know, the military has "personal grooming standards" that are enforced across the services; this includes a requirement to shave daily, if applicable. This is for a few reasons: to ensure a "uniform, military appearance", but also nominally to ensure a good seal with a gas mask.

However, so-called "no-shave chits" can be issued to service members for a variety of reasons, and these waivers exempt those people from this requirement.

For example, I once saw a guy who had one because a tree branch or something whacked him in the face during an exercise and gave him a gnarly slice that needed stitches. He couldn't reasonably shave _over_ the stitches, so medical gave him a no-shave chit while that was healing.

But the most common reason for issuing no-shave chits is for folks with "Pseudofolliculitis Barbae" (PFB), more commonly known as razor bumps, which are ingrown hair follicles on the face and neck.

Razor bumps are a real thing, and while I understand they are extremely painful, more concerning is that they can become infected, rendering a service member mission incapable.

But here's the thing: razor bumps affect Black folks more than others; up to 60% to 80% of adult Black men who shave regularly will experience them. The percentage among other demographics is much, much lower; like close to an order of magnitude lower. The military's own data, snapshotted in 2023, says that 63.5% of PFB cases since 2000 were among non-Hispanic Black service members (https://health.mil/News/Articles/2023/08/01/Pseudofolliculitis-barbae).

And let me be clear here: this is a real, known, diagnosable medical condition, studied and recognized by dermatologists. It's not like there's some kind of conspiracy to get out of shaving or something dumb like that. And from everyone I've ever known who's had it, they'd really, really, rather they didn't. I understand it sucks.

So separating service members who have medical shaving waivers will disproportionately affect Black service members. There's no way Hegseth et al don't know this.

"But wait a minute! What about the gas mask thing!?" I hear someone ask, "that sounds pretty legit." Ok, here's the deal: the waiver says you don' t have to shave down to the skin; it doesn't say you don't keep things trim and keep facial hare short. No one with a no-shave chit is running around with a full beard that's keeping them from putting on a gas mask.

But even if they were, what about all the SpecOps guys with their "operator beards"? And anyone who's been on a multiday mission outside the wire knows there are times when adherence to the grooming standards takes a backseat to operational necessities; most of us have gone a couple of days without a shave.

And if there were really a serious threat of chemical warfare and you absolutely needed to ensure you could get a seal with a gas mask, you'd shave regardless of the chit or you'd be in MOPP-4 anyway (with no exposed skin). Note that a gas mask really only covers the face and eyes; you'd be putting on a hood and other equipment to cover up the rest including, you guessed it, the area of the face and neck where the seal isn't perfect.

So yeah. I fail to see any way in which this effort is anything other than explicitly racist.

@cross
I see Vice President Vance sports a beard and eyeliner. But military members get booted? Huh, that's not hypocrisy, or maybe it is.
@cross
Other religious people, like Sikh folks, often observe the no shaving practice.
These policies are cruel + purposeful.
@fkaOctaviaKeats 100%. The article I saw only mentioned medical waivers for now, but I have no doubt they'll go for religious waivers next.

@cross @fkaOctaviaKeats

Correctly fitting N95 respirators in the medical profession for Sikh men or others who have beards for religious reasons is a solved problem.

I can't see why gas masks would be much different.

https://www.fta.net.au/post/the-singh-thattha-beard-wrap-technique

THE SINGH THATTHA BEARD WRAP TECHNIQUE

SINGH THATTHA BEARD WRAP TECHNIQUE, WHAT IT IS AND WHY WE DO ITThe Australian Standards and New Zealand Standards AS/NZS1715:2009 are quite clear on the need for individuals wearing a tight-fitting respirator to be clean shaven in order to achieve an adequate seal therefore receiving the masks full intended protection. The need to be clean shaven is still a requirement although there is an exception for healthcare workers. FTA enforces a clean shaven policy at all times with one exception being

Fit Test Australia
@pewnack @cross
Yes.
It's because the true intent is to do division + fear, not truly problem solving.

@fkaOctaviaKeats @pewnack ^^^ this a thousand times.

I can't help thinking about what these stupid policies are throwing away.

Consider someone like Sgt Malik Pugh, who was awarded the Navy and Marine Corps Achievement Medal for designing and 3d printing a replacement adapter for a particular cable; the OEM part was backordered 12 months.
https://www.dvidshub.net/image/8155284/sgt-malik-pugh-navy-and-marine-corps-achievement-medal-ceremony

Note that Sgt Pugh has facial hair because of PFB.

What gets me is that Sgt Pugh could have just sat back, kicked up his feet, and said, "oh well...guess we've just got to wait on the supplier." But what he did instead, by fabricating the part himself, is exactly what the Marine Corps is known for: no one told him to do that; he wasn't ordered to; but he saw a problem, took ownership of that problem, exercised some initiative and creativity, and came up with a solution. His actions helped keep his unit mission capable.

And now Hegseth wants to kick him out because he doesn't like his (in-regulation, mind you) facial hair?! That's not leadership. It's just stupidity.

Sgt. Malik Pugh Navy and Marine Corps Achievement Medal Ceremony

U.S. Marine Corps Sgt. Maj. Dennis Turner, sergeant major of 3rd Marine Logistics Group (3rd MLG), addresses the Marines of Communications Company, Combat Logistics Regiment 37, 3rd MLG, following an award ceremony on Camp Kinser, Okinawa, Japan, Dec. 6, 2023. During the ceremony, Sgt. Malik Pugh, a digital wideband systems maintainer with Marine Wing Communications Squadron 18, Marine Air Control Group 18, 1st Marine Aircraft Wing, was awarded the Navy and Marine Corps Achievement Medal for his superior performance while serving as an engineer section head with Communications Company, and for his initiative to create a computer-aided design connector cable that produced a functional replacement for a backordered cable. Pugh, a native of Fairview Heights, Illinois, graduated from Belleville East High School in 2018 and enlisted out of Recruiting Station Fairview Heights in 2019. (U.S. Marine Corps photo by Cpl. Sydni Jessee)

DVIDS
@cross I used to get that on my calves from shaving and it’s PAINFUL. I imagine that shaving over it when it’s already inflamed would make these guys susceptible to infection. It’s dumb and racist to take this exception away. (I only got it to stop by getting laser hair removal.)

@cross

Having those people ejected from the military may be a good thing, since perhaps then they'll have the correct allegiances when the Civil War resumes shortly.

@cross
Suspicion has to be that it's (more) about ensuring that black people don't get military training.