Jeremy Keith on the Web on Mobile

Link to: https://adactio.com/journal/21728

Daring Fireball

@daringfireball

If we're deciding whether the Web or native apps are superior, "the people who make them" (or perhaps just how they're made) is a useful single factor to specify we're talking about. Typically when you've asserted native apps are better, I've taken you to mean both in theory and in all ways.

I'd agree the potential for good Web apps is way under-realized; not that there's no potential. For my money, the Mastodon Web app on iOS is way nicer than the Mastodon iOS app.

@Starfia @daringfireball The aspect of web apps that’s clearly worse is discovery and installation.

Installing an iOS app is complicated but easy.

Installing a web app is simple but challenging.

@pixelscience

The discovery specifically is easy and challenging respectively? It is on iOS and the Mac, I would agree – the system doesn't go out of its way to tell you about installing Web apps.

I've noticed that Android goes right ahead with some form of notification if a web page is configured as a Web app. So I think that's more of a critique of Apple than of Web apps.

@Starfia Agreed. But the complaints about web apps tend to be Apple/WebKit related

@pixelscience

Right – the article had already noted that, then shifted the topic to criticism inherent to Web apps themselves, arguing that's where it was deserved. So that's the context within which I was commenting.