master: welcome to my Smart Home

student: wow. how is the light controlled?

master: with this on-off switch

student: i don't see a motor to close the blinds

master: there is none

student: where is the server located?

master: it is not needed

student: excuse me but what is "Smart" about all of this?

master: everything.

in this moment, the student was enlightened

@lritter FWIW I'd really like a timer on closing the window, so I can run the aircon on a timer before I get home.
@GyrosGeier timer controlled power adapters are blessed

@lritter I'd love something triggered by sunlight/temperature to open/close curtains in order to make the most of natural warming/cooling cycles.

But I don't want it enough to sell my soul to IoT companies.

@GyrosGeier

@zeborah @lritter @GyrosGeier there was a video this past year from Technology Connections on awnings, which are no longer common in North America home design but which can be used for something similar. Adjustable roll-op awnings, or pre-planning, can make it so the south facing windows are shaded in summer, but get direct sunlight in winter when the sun is closer to the horizon, so you don't get solar heating when you don't want it, and do when you do.
@zeborah @lritter @GyrosGeier solar cell connected to a motor?
@lritter So, more of a Wise house than a Smart house, then? :P
@FunkyBob @lritter I love my Home Assistant but Wise Home is a great concept
@stooovie @FunkyBob @lritter
I usually say "smart, but not smart enough to get into trouble". But "wise home" is also great, and a lot shorter too πŸ˜…
@lritter @Natanael_L Learning about rhetoric, liars and semantics? (i.e.: Corposcum always purposely misused "smart")
@lritter The smart light switches I installed reverted to wise switches all by themselves. We're just a waste of money or turns out.
@davesomebody @lritter I like your use of β€œwise” vs smart.
@lritter I mean I might go as far as mechanical timers on some things, like lights for a hydroponics system in my basement but, I don't want motorized blinds & might even use a timer on the internet router one day .... to turn it off about 1 day/week.
@lritter the enlightenment being that the master wasn't an actual one
@lornova this is the secret solution to every koan.
@lritter @lornova oh, nice, I didn't know there was a universal shortcut-hack.

@lritter

the approach to smartness i am teaching in my IoT course

@sebastian I have long believed that IoT stands for "Internet Of Things That Don't Need To Be Connected To The Internet"
I love the idea of a connected home, but I don't want to connect it to anything outside of my home.

@mocelet

Intelligence of Things that know when to connect and when not to.

@lritter I feel the same about ai, and streaming.
@lritter exactly
& People wonder why I build bicycles for fun
@lritter so true, simple things over work better then conplex ones
@lritter That's not a smart home that's a manual home. A smart home is when you have your own server to control everything in your house that doesn't require an Internet connection :3
@snow @lritter go meditate some more until you understand
@mirabilos @snow or just maintain a smart home for 10 years.
@lritter
Reminds me of when my mom wanted all off these smart bulbs and shit, and i was like "this is a terrible idea what if the wifi goes out" (as it was prone to do, our wifi was about as stable as a drunk in an earthquake) and when it did, weekly, and we were woken up in the middle of the night by our lights going full brightness, i was like "told you so"
@kharos
@DiodeHyena @kharos perhaps smart homes are for people who want to go on an adventure without leaving the house?
@lritter And everyone clapped, and the students name was Albert Einstein.
@Jenetrix that-- *checks notes* that is exactly correct

@lritter you gain wisdom!

"smart houses, stupid people”

@lritter student: but master, what if you are bed-bound, or unable to coordinate enough to open or close blinds yourself?
@lritter @kithrup you position the switches suitably of course, duh
@mirabilos @lritter Wow. You are quite the ablist. Bye.
@lritter one of my favorite essays about this:
https://dynomight.net/midwit-home/
The midwit home

Less automation and less agony

DYNOMIGHT
@eldersea @lritter i love this thank you for sharing it!
@lritter For scheduling and remote access I do enjoy smart devices, but I never interfere with the glorious and holy ability to just use the light switch.
@lritter I once had someone ask me "You know so much about technology, why don't you like IoT?" I said, "Because I understand how things can go wrong."

@lritter @mattgrayyes having achieved the revelation they were seeking, the student set off for the month long journey back home. it was treacherous. a neighbouring warlord had suddenly died, sparking off a war of inheritance that embroiled the countryside. as much as the student had learnt, it was impossible for them not to be scarred by the horrors, mentally and physically, and lost an arm to a stray arrow. he finally returned to his home temple, and greeted his master and resumed his training.

master: you seem to be having difficulty meditating

student: I… cannot put out of mind the horrors of the war. The pain of my missing arm.

master: there is a war?

student: how could you not know, the entire kingdom is in upheaval

master: I have been focused for weeks to get home assistant to talk to the threads edge router. My mind has no room for externalities. Open the heavy shutters.

student: master, i cannot! I lost an arm!

master: well, ask Siri.

The student did, and the entire temple was enlightened

@lritter Master was enlightened shortly after about managing expectations
@lritter Buddhist jokes!! we need more of these on the tl
@lritter ah, so this is that serverless thing everybody's been talking about.

@lritter like with most tech conveniences, smart home stuff is wildly superfluous for most people but an accessibility godsend for others

I use automated lighting to help manage a severe circadian rhythm disorder. At some point I'm hoping to move over to home assistant but for the time being I'm still just using big corporate home automation smart home stuff

@lritter
I love this, but I truly do not want to go back to the time when to change TV channel you got up, walked to TV, clicked switch round, then went back to seat to watch.
Yes I am old enough to remember, even when only one channel in UKπŸ˜€πŸ˜Š
@RHW @lritter We had a dial that would turn the antenna in the right direction so that Walter Cronkite didn't look like a Picasso. I think that's why people had kids back in he day. "Hey, Codey, channel 3, sou'sou'east."
@lritter I for years thought of a system to be able to open my blackout curtains from bed... but two years ago I made this. It works not perfect, but when it fails it is so easy to solve that it is not worth the energy to improve it.
Beautiful? No.
Functional? Yes.
Works during power outings? Yes.
Hacked? Frequently, but only by my cat.
@lritter In that case, our home is VERY smart. So dumb it is smart.
@lritter @annaleen
Hello,
Thank you for sharing.
I live in this kind of house.
Thank you for sharing.
I had the same discussion with a guy about electric/manual car windows over 20 years ago.
What we want is not what we need.
Views on "Progress" in disguise : technics evolve, we must sell thist better (new) device which will improve our market share.
Today, cars - are full of electronics and are less reliable.
In favor of #lowtech :
"ANY DEVICE IS DOOMED TO FAILURE"
The-Tao-Of-Programming/1.pdf at master Β· benajaero/The-Tao-Of-Programming

My typeset of the eternal truth. Contribute to benajaero/The-Tao-Of-Programming development by creating an account on GitHub.

GitHub
@lritter TBH, I'm part of this house's AC system: I open/close awnings, blinds, windows and doors as needed. 3 awnings, 7 blinds (4 already electric), 12 windows and 8 doors in total. Sometimes it's annoying, specially when closing/opening hatches before/after a dust/rain storm.