That sucks. Definitely push the last one. This happened to me one time in band camp

That sucks but this reminds me of…

…and that’s how I became king of the pirates, well anyways you should invest into my NFT cryptoAI trust me bro this gonna go to the moon!

Good thing he has three things to push all the buttons with…
“That’s rough, buddy” is my goto.
I’m more of a “well, shit” guy myself.
“my first girlfriend turned into the moon”
Empathize, “I can imagine how much that must have hurt, I’m sorry you had to deal with that”
Gotta find a non-patronizing way to ask if they need help, a hug, or to be heard.
“that’s crazy”
Or maybe ask what they need from you? Just a thought.

It works spectacularly well with people you’re close to or on very good terms with.

If my other half is kicking off about something, a quick “hey listen, are you wanting help to fix this or are you wanting to vent like fuck to feel a bit better?”

It’s rarely the former, though I’d be more than happy to help if it was. At least then I can let her rage out and decompress without throwing in unwanted suggestions.

Probably comes across as a bit blunt to people you don’t know well though.

Glad my wife and I aren’t the only ones. It’s frustrating to explain why proposed solutions won’t work while already worked up over stressful bullshit. Sometimes there just aren’t real solutions. Sometimes you just need to open a pressure relief valve for a minute so you can have a little reset and be better equipped to tackle the mountain of bullshit.

Yeah, it works both ways at the end of the day.

I know fine well I need to take some holiday days - I work with a team of fantastic guys and girls in a very bureaucratic environment, so any deviation from the norm in certain projects come with a raft of paperwork (an unnecessary volume in some cases), before the issue can really be put to bed.

Everyone makes fuckups. I’ve made fuckups and caused by line manager paperwork when I was at the coalface, and I’ll continue to make fuckups and learn from them in the future. I know my spuds will drop a bollock every now and then, and that’s cool.

There are times when someone has made a royal arse of something and it’s stacked another load of paperwork on top of me, and I get a bit angry about it. It’s not rational, it’s not fair to rag on the poor dude or dudette or dudethey who made an error, and I’ll let my partner know that I’m not after solutions - I’m just needing a bit of extra time to calm down and refocus. Solutions to those problems mean overhauling a heavy and entrenched system of work, and it’s not something that can be done at home - I could have married Kofi Annan, but unless he’s familiar with the system of work, there’s fuck all he could actually do.

At that point, it’s time to book a week or two off, and think about anything - everything - but work.

Whatcha want from me?

There is a secret fourth option that requires the player to cancel the dialogue and just perform an action:

Give hug

The Paragon interrupt.
I prefer the renegade

Sadly, no one does that.

It’s the best option.

Sadly, nobody does that.

Its the best option.

This is slowly being replaced by 👍ing or ❤️‍ing the message. No actual words needed.
I find that the variety of emotes people have available on discord say more than I probably would half-ass with words.
Haha, glad I know about this parody journal. There’s also the Journal of Immaterial Science for anyone interested.
And then what happened?
That must be really hard for you.
Wow. You don’t deserve that.
How do you feel about it now?
Ugh. That sounds awful.
You’re handling this better than I would.
How do you even respond to that?
Tell me about it.
What can I do to help?
You’ve got this, but I’m here.
Look at mister “I leave the basement twice a week” over here
In the land of the blind awkward the one eyed I dunno less awkward I guess man is king

Awesome list!

I would just change slightly the “What can I do to help?” (That is a call for a “nothing”) to “How can I help?” (That shows much more enthusiasm in wanting to help)

Hey thanks! I like that phrasing better. Less perfunctory, more sincere.
“Frankly, you brought this all on yourself” usually resolves it quickly, in my experience.
Hello, we’d like to offer you a position as police chief in a neighborhood that will statistically have a school shooting soon.
Ah drawing aggro like a true tank.
Lol that’s basically a therapist, minus the second option.
You might need to try a different therapist.
4: “I can help you hide the body if you want.”
“Its not that bad stop being a pussy” Works 30% of the time everytime.
Pussies are pretty tough though. Balls on the other hand … too warm, too cold, don’t touch me, you’ll hurt me. :)
Tell a related story is best choice because it shows that you really feel what that person is coming through since you’ve came through similar situation yourself
But then you are making this about yourself. Stealing the show. Reaping all the sympathy.
When is only you and your friend in evening near the grill, then i don’t know which sympathy i stole, i mean men truly open up very rarely and often in very small circle or even only to one person, so you have to show some compassion in these moments
So you say the initial cry’s a show?

It all depends on how you say it. Some people just genuinely do need to know someone understands them at face value. Adding your own experiences and using that to validate their feelings rather than overshadow then is an invaluable practiced skill. It allows you to layer advice into how you convey it, sometimes without them even realizing that’s what you’re doing.

A great way to do this subtly is to ask them questions that help you find VERY close similarities that open the door to a segway into your own experience. Example:

“Oh man, that’s horrible. Hitting a roadblock like that suck so much. Did you have to deal with [related thing] too?”

“YES and it only piled onto my stress. Ughhhhh.”

“I know all too well. It’s the worst and I wouldn’t wish it on anyone. I’m so sorry. If it helps, I could go through what I did. It’s not exactly the same, but maybe something that helped me will resonate? But I understand if you’d rather just vent. My ear’s always open.”

The trick is usually asking if they want to hear it. Then you know for SURE whether or not to proceed, and you’ve framed it in such a way that is less about you and more about investigating ways the shared experience can inform how they handle the issue themselves, or how the differences can add better insight into their own trouble.

You’re great at explaining this, thanks for giving these examples
And thank you for the vote of confidence! If this has been able to help even one person put this complex and often emotionally heavy interaction into an understandable framework then I’m happy. ❤️
that’s what neurodivergent people do to show sympathy - very often unknowingly. folks sometimes think we do that to get the attention for ourselves, but it’s just a long winded way of saying “i understand what you feel, you’re not alone in your pain”

I learned this a few years ago and my mind was blown because I’m autistic and this is indeed my instinct. I have also found that neurodivergent people are more likely to respond positively to an anecdote.

Neurotypical people tend to react better to “reflective listening” — basically the “it sucks” button, but more expanded. Like if someone is venting about something, I might say “That sounds really frustrating”, or similar. It feels like playing conversational ping pong where I’m not an active participant in the rally, but just reacting to my conversation partner’s shots.

I don’t tend to find reflective listening especially helpful if I’m the recipient of it (I cope with problems differently), so it blew my mind when I was trying to support a friend with these techniques and they ended the conversation by thanking me for the support, and they really needed that. It baffled me because I hadn’t felt like I’d said anything really at all, besides just reflecting stuff back at them, which felt sort of like small talk but even more superficial. But nah, turns out that different people find different kinds of support helpful. The_More_You_Know.jpg

Well you want to know the other person gets it, right? Otherwise it’s just hollow words. A well-chosen anecdote means that to some extent, you understand each other. I can see the appeal of that kind of commiseration.