this morning I've made the choice to close 300 forum sites that have about 275k monthly active users, nearly all from the UK.

I've run forums for over 28 years, and did so to build families for those without families, to try and create a cure for social isolation and loneliness, to combat suicide, to create joy and love out of nothing but connections between people.

and it worked. it still works.

but on the 16th March 2025 I will delete the virtual servers running it all... that date is important, it's the last day before the UK Online Safety Act goes into enforcement.

I run these communities philanthropically, giving my time and money to do so, I ask nothing back, I just help build a nicer World.

but the scope of the Act is too broad, and my forums come under it... it does not matter that it's run by an individual and not a company, that it loses money every month... merely by being linked to the UK and allowing users to speak to users... it's within scope.

the penalties of non-compliance would be so devastatingly ruinous to me, that I don't see I have a choice... I must now perform a social harm to protect myself.

this is devastating.

https://www.lfgss.com/conversations/401475/

I cannot even express what these forums have achieved... the marriages, births, support for those with cancer, the love, the communities they have created.

@dee This seems like something your MP, or MPs of soon-to-be-affected members of your fora, should hear loudly and clearly. I have no idea if it is too late in the lawmaking process for that sort of thing, but bad legislation is bad legislation. Better to challenge it now than through the courts. 275k active users is a lot - that is a voice that, if unified, can be awfully loud.

@Brad_Rosenheim @dee It is too late. Act was implemented last year. And I, and many others, wrote to our MPs.

I would probably say that I wouldn't be too worried (unless you're the size of Facebook etc; against which this law was mostly written).

OFCOM isn't particularly well staffed enough to proceed with million dollar liability claims against small operators; but that is a risk that everyone needs to weigh for themselves of course. And I also wish I wouldn't have to think of it.

😞

@derickr @Brad_Rosenheim that risk is also non-zero... the number of times I've been forced to moderate someone and the subsequent anger and actions from that person.

things I've encountered are being signed up to porn sites, death threats, stalking behaviour (online and IRL), threats of violence, abuse... what the Act does is provide another weapon to those people to hurt and attack moderators and site admins, and now with huge liability and risks.

I do not imagine OfCom give a hoot about these sites, but I do believe they will be obliged to follow up on complaints, and that the complaints will be like a form of legal SWATting against those who operate communities.

the liability is far far too high, and the risk not low enough, even though I've had not one incident that the Act tries to prevent in 28.5 years of running forums.

@dee @Brad_Rosenheim Yeah, I totally understand where you're coming from.

Annoyingly, there is another bill going through parliament which will lower more user-data protections: https://www.openrightsgroup.org/publications/briefing-data-use-and-access-bill-hl/

Briefing: Data Use and Access Bill

Executive Summary The new Data (Use and Access) Bill drops several concerning aspects of the previous Data Protection and Digital Information Bill.

Open Rights Group