The American #FCC is accepting public comment on a proposal that would license the 902-928 MHz band to a private company (NextNav Inc) for use in terrestrial location tracking as a commercial alternative to free #GPS, GLONASS, & Galileo satellite positioning systems. The company already operates in the 920-928 MHz band.

This will significantly interfere with #LoRaWAN IOT devices and could have dire consequences for #decentralized communication networks such as #Meshtastic.

NextNav intends to deprive the public of these unlicensed frequencies and build a nationwide monopoly on PNT infrastructure in the 902-928 MHz band. (https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/10416238018537/1)

This is not only harmful to the #opensource and #openhardware community, it is a gross misappropriation of the public's precious radio frequencies to further the goals of a monopolistic for-profit corporation.

(https://meshtastic.org/blog/meshtastic-opposition-to-nextnav-proposed-changes/ )

Initial comments were due by September 5th. "reply comments" (comments that support the concerns expressed in other comments) are due by September 20th. You can make a comment here: (https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/filings/express?proceeding%5Bname%5D=24-240). You can view all public comments here: (https://tinyurl.com/FCC-24-240)

ECFS

Federal Communication Commission Electronic Comment Filing System

@catalyst In my opinion they should have to share the frequency. Fuck the corposcum.

@lispi314 frequency sharing is infeasible due to the proposed broadcast power of the NextNav PNT drowning out all other users.

agreed. fuck em'.

@catalyst that is the band used for #LoRa, isnโ€™t it? That would brik a lot of devices IIUC.

Edit: I only saw the first part of the post. The rest mentions the issue with LoRa explicitly.

@catalyst I have filed a comment. Has everyone else?
ARRL Urges Protecting the Amateur Radio 902-928 MHz Band

The American Radio Relay League (ARRL) is the national association for amateur radio, connecting hams around the U.S. with news, information and resources.

@catalyst It sounds like only *replies* to comments are still open (and will be until the 20th).

@catalyst Even freaking Honda is commenting with a "ehm, this'll break the keyfobs of our customers": https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/10905223575292/1

๐Ÿ˜น
(I'm positively surprised that they are aware of this and have taken the time to oppose it)

ECFS

Federal Communication Commission Electronic Comment Filing System

@manawyrm

The Boeing Company and the Worms of Portland published scathing letters of opposition against FCC proposal 24-240:

https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/1090488041242/1

https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/10905555323699/1

ECFS

Federal Communication Commission Electronic Comment Filing System

@manawyrm Also opposed to 24-240 are The Port Authority of New York & New Jersey, and the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority

https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/10904918302818/1

https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/108300505508335/1

ECFS

Federal Communication Commission Electronic Comment Filing System

@catalyst Yikes! I guess this is a reminder to never take available resources for granted--at any time, commercial interests may swoop in to try to take them away.

I'm honestly shocked that something like this is even considered, I had always been under the (obviously mistaken) impression that the 900 MHz ISM band was a permanent fixture that would never be under attack.

#capitalism #dystopia

@xorbit @catalyst It was supposed to be. So much stuff depends on this spectrum in ways that may not even be obvious. Key fobs, garage openers, basically every non 2.4ghz remote, they all depend on this band. The band was for public use for a reason, it was written to be a permanent fixture, and people have used it that way. This attempt to undo that state, if successful (given how many companies also agree that this can't pass, there's a good chance it won't.) would have disastrous and far reaching consequences.
@catalyst NO MESSING WITH LORA! Capitalist PIGS!