It is a damning indictment of white feminism that we're finally seeing someone properly stick it to JK Rowling and it's a 25 year old Algerian woman.

There are so many people in the world who have more power than Imane Khelif. So much more. Fucking piles and piles of power laying around, doing fuck all.

And all she wanted to do was box, but she's going to stand up for herself anyway.

And once again, we will all benefit from the work of women of colour.

And SO HELP ME GOD if one more fucking lefty dude points out that Imane Khelif didn't stand up and shout TRANS RIGHTS on Algerian television, they will fucking regret it.

@detachedspork

Imane Khelif's ordeal is adjacent to the struggle for trans rights, but it isn't the same. There is a concurrent struggle for women to be allowed to visually present and behave in public without the degree of persecution they face being directly tied to their adherence to European brood-spouse standards.
Many trans people experience this struggle as well, but the issue of whether niche expressions of gender conformity should be a passport to public life is a larger umbrella.

@detachedspork

Ella Emhoff is another person in that same situation.

Fighting for free clearance for authentic self representation in public, decentering those who would police expression according to arbitrary gender ideas, is important work that frees people to contribute their best selves to society. It's the tail of the same beast that Katherine Hepburn was fighting.

http://archive.org/details/movieclassic04moti/page/n239/mode/2up?view=theater

Movie Classic (Mar-Jul 1933) : Motion Picture Publications, Inc. : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive

PREMARC/SERLOC merged record

Internet Archive

@detachedspork

The treatment she was subjected to infuriates me beyond reason. It’s so low to just base it of looks.

I can only give Khelif accolades for the integrity of her demeanour. Suing X and Rowling is a good way forward. Keeping people responsible for their actions is the only way forward. Words have meaning, especially if you have a huge following.

@detachedspork I was really happy to hear she's named JKR in the lawsuit, what JK did to her was abhorrent. Whenever I hear about her latest bigoted bullying tirade I think about how much difference things could be if she used her platform and influence to make the world better instead of being an asshole.
@detachedspork Tip of the Cub cap to Imane.
@detachedspork JK thought she’d fuck around and fight an Olympic Boxer and found herself knocked out.
@detachedspork It still takes a cis woman to hold her accountable for her transphobia
@cannabitch @detachedspork which demonstrates that transphobia harms cis women as well as trans women. Which shouldn't really be any surprise as terves have constantly tried to enforce a narrow gender binary which disallows ANY deviation from a sub-Victorian norm.
@detachedspork What are the odds she's going to be like "my first name's abbreviation is a common way to say Just Kidding, so no one would take me seriously, checkmate libel laws."
@detachedspork wow, just reading this and the comments and I can't help to just be disappointed.

@detachedspork

JKR specifically targeted Khelif, which hasn't happened in the past.

Attacking a group is different from singling out an individual. One you can prosecute, the other you can't.

Previously JKR stayed on the "right" side of the law, but this time a line was crossed.

@maya_b @detachedspork I was wondering if she had done any particular calling out of an individual before Khelif. I haven’t been following her hate parade enough to know if that’s true. If it is, that would explain why Khelif can actually go after her in court. As a cis woman, I couldn’t sue JKR for her TERF rhetoric, but Khelif can make what sounds like a solid claim of cyber harassment under the French law.

@queenofnewyork @detachedspork

JKR's been slowly ramping up over the years, and lately gone really over the top.

Anyone who's tried to go after JKR has been threatened by her legal team.

But this is the first time that I know of that JKR has named one person in particular.

IIRC there is also scope under UK law for slander/defamation in addition to harassment, though I think the French case has more standing.

@maya_b @detachedspork The French law sounds very interesting. I need to see if I can get one if my LawTube follows to dig into it. It sounds quite promising as a tool against cyber harassment, but I suspect a lot is going to come down to how it’s implemented.

@queenofnewyork @detachedspork

French law is a mystery to me, but iirc, they were the first to have an actual Misogyny charge so could be more progressive than most

@queenofnewyork @detachedspork

that being said, the European Court of Human Rights suffers no fools, so even if there're issues in the French system it may still proceed.

This could get really legally interesting (and also expensive for a poor bullied billionaire)

@maya_b @detachedspork I don’t know a ton about UK law, so I don’t know if other things she’s said in the past could be termed to have broken any hate speech laws. The US barely regulated hate speech and then only if it comes with imminent threat of violence. Sadly upholding the violence of the system doesn’t count. It’s an aspect of law that I struggle with, honestly. I want more accountability but I also worry about who defines “hate speech.”

@queenofnewyork @detachedspork

The UK has some particularly weird speech laws. Basically you can't say offensive stuff about your "betters" or else.

There's movement in the UK system to shut down lawsuits that effectively silence criticism but change is slow.

@maya_b @detachedspork Here too. We have anti-SLAPP laws in some places that are designed to make it so the wealthy can’t use the courts just to shut you up, but they aren’t nationwide. So people and companies can venue-shop to places without that sort of law. But yeah, slow to change. Which is a good and a bad thing, honestly.